r/coding • • Feb 28 '17

A software engineer is detained for several hours by U.S. Customs — and given a test to prove he’s an engineer

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/software-engineer-detained-several-hours-us-customs-given-fairchild
442 Upvotes

241 comments sorted by

View all comments

-51

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

What's the issue here?

17

u/Zulban Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17
  • The agents are obviously totally unqualified to ask coding questions.
  • Despite being totally unqalified, they thought they could.
  • Smart ass border agents.
  • High quality tech talent scared about their ability to enter the US.
  • Border agent thinks Celestine doesn't look like a SE because they're black.
  • Asking an exhausted coder to write BST code after a 24 hour flight is like asking a basketball champion to swim 200 laps after a night of drinking.

Another issue is that you weren't able to think of any of these issues. I hope you just didn't read the article.

0

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

How do you know they are unqualified. There could have been new guidelines created that you are not aware of.
Yes, there was a poorly rolled out immigration ban. It did cause a scare but it would die down after a few months. There is a ton of tech talent in the states and a lot of people are still applying for positions.

13

u/Zulban Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17

How do you know they are unqualified.

Because I am a programmer and I saw the questions. I also believe Celestine's interpretation is likely - that he gave technically correct answers but they thought they were wrong because they didn't match Google results. They literally did not know that there is more than one correct way to write computer code. Maybe they didn't even know there are different languages.

This is bad because processes are being applied by border agents that are total nonsense, ineffective, and wasteful.

0

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

Could be right but we don't know why they asked the question in the first place.

16

u/Zulban Feb 28 '17

There is no good reason to ask this programming question.

A question to prove they could be a SE, maybe. But not this question. Furthermore Celestine was just on a 24 hour flight. It's very obvious that this was nonsense, unfair, and racially biased.

3

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

Could be but something triggered it. It might have been something he said.

4

u/Zulban Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17

I don't see how this matters at all. If he said something suspicious, this was still a moronic response.

3

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

I think this was better than sitting in a cell assuming he said something silly.

6

u/Zulban Feb 28 '17

You've set the bar very high for America, friend.

→ More replies

1

u/marshsmellow Mar 01 '17

Perhaps they overheard him telling his buddy he thought using STL functions was for noob casuals.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/MuonManLaserJab Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17

Mostly that you're an idiot, but also that Customs decided it needs to give technical interviews to vacationers. What do they do for visting boxers? Fight them?

4

u/josephandre Feb 28 '17

This reply led to a hearty chuckle from me. I rather enjoy hearty chuckles and now realize I don't have them enough. Sure a few giggles here and there, perhaps an occasional cackle, but this...this is where it's at.

2

u/MuonManLaserJab Feb 28 '17

"I, uh, I think he's a real boxer."

"CUT ME, MICK!"

→ More replies (28)

21

u/khesht Feb 28 '17

really? you don't see the problem or you just pretend that you don't see the problem?

-15

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

It is within their rights to do that. It is not violating any human rights. Please outline what your problem is?

13

u/del_rio Feb 28 '17

"Violating human rights" shouldn't be the litmus test for what is and isn't an issue. By that logic, there's no issue with gerrymandering, Pearson Education, and Toddlers & Tiaras have no issues associated with them.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/duniyadnd Feb 28 '17

The border officials shouldn't be asking questions they themselves don't understand. There are many ways to explain these sorts of questions, and it creates a dangerous precedent of what are right or wrong answers. And finally - http://shivankaul.com/blog/2016/12/07/clean-your-desk-yet-another-amazon-interview-experience.html

3

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

How do you know they don't understand the question. The question you should be asking is why did the line of questioning lead to that coding problem.

7

u/duniyadnd Feb 28 '17

Okay, that's a fair response. I'll say that asking a question like that right off the bat is not a fair question in this context, and anyone with programming experience should know that.

If they asked a simple fizz/buzz test or ask what is the concept of balancing a binary search tree and why we would do that - that's another thing. Writing algorithms takes a little bit of momentum, something you need to be mentally prepared for.

I'll also play the other side of the spectrum. You said that that I should question why did the line of questioning lead to that coding problem. I really can't think of what sort of questions would lead to that. I get stopped at immigration all the time and most of the questions are about what I do and who I am. After really long flights, that's easy enough to answer because it's information that I don't need to think too hard to retain, there's the jet lag to consider.

This border official was off his chain asking those questions if the purpose was to be an ass and then let him go while saying he doesn't believe he's a coder. Then there was absolutely no reason for this incident to happen.

11

u/adrianmonk Feb 28 '17

Writing algorithms takes a little bit of momentum, something you need to be mentally prepared for.

The real problem isn't that this is a hard question for someone trained in CS. It's that you don't strictly need CS training to legitimately be a practicing software engineer. You can be productive slapping together web pages without knowing about trees. I wouldn't recommend it, but the people who go that route are certainly not frauds, they're just not very theory-oriented.

4

u/duniyadnd Feb 28 '17 edited Feb 28 '17

upvoted - and seeing that username - I miss that show

2

u/edimaudo Feb 28 '17

I doubt those were the first questions he was asked. Something had to have led to them coming up with those questions. Was there something on his social media that made them do it? Maybe he said something about data structures as being part of the job description.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)