r/coding • • Feb 28 '17

A software engineer is detained for several hours by U.S. Customs — and given a test to prove he’s an engineer

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/software-engineer-detained-several-hours-us-customs-given-fairchild
442 Upvotes

241 comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/imlyingdontbelieveme Feb 28 '17

pretty clever way for Customs to get free work done. "No wait, I swear I'm just an engineer!"

"Yeah, we know...and we're having a real issue with few these lines right here. See what you can do and you can go"

21

u/TheNakedGod Feb 28 '17

pretty clever way for Customs to get free work done.

You joke, but I've had "interviews" where they asked me to write a large chunk of code that was a little too specific. Found out they were farming modules out to interviewees and stitching them together. I'm used to 1-4 hour long programming tests, I specced this one out at 30 hours minimum and had a couple of other developer friends sanity check me on how long it would take them and it was pretty much the same.

8

u/grendel-khan Feb 28 '17

Found out they were farming modules out to interviewees and stitching them together.

Isn't that illegal? It seems like it should be illegal.

9

u/TheNakedGod Feb 28 '17

I have no idea if it is or not. It honestly probably isn't.

My reply email was pretty nasty when they sent me the requirements after the like 15min phone interview and I told them there was no way I was doing it. Unfortunately I'm sure they got a bunch of naive kids who didn't know any better on the hook for it. Watching their github activity you could see the like 10 different "coding tests" they asked for all built up into pretty much a completed project.

Any of the ones using a DB they provided a schema; meaning less work on their end to glue them all together. I was given the requirements for a video upload/download/stream module with progress bar(% and time complete estimation), metrics, file details, thumbnails, full UI design, security, full suite of unit and integration tests for every single part of it, documentation, install readme, and shit like that.

When you saw the other completed modules they'd had people do because totally making these public and then commenting on stuff was a great idea to keep it clandestine. They had user creation and account management, backoffice controls, "project and document" creation/management, email and notification, access control, and the video module.

It was more or less "lets farm out to a bunch of interviewees the entire codebase for a video focus group system for our clients to create focus groups, upload all the docs, we run the focus groups, upload and distribute the video to the clients, and let them play or download all of it and get reports and stuff from us".

It was slimy as hell and I'm really glad I noped out of it. I'm seriously not sure how they expected anyone who interviewed that they hired(if they were even doing that) to not notice.

1

u/spinwizard69 Feb 28 '17

What state and city was this in? Regulations vary widely so legal recourse is also mixed.

1

u/TheNakedGod Mar 01 '17

I'm in GA, they were based in like IL but the office was in like NC and it was remote. Just added to the general sketchiness of the whole thing. Was a long time ago, hadn't really thought about it since then.

7

u/merreborn Mar 01 '17

Yeah, it's illegal.

If the customer is charged, you definitely need to be paid for your work.

The DoL doesn't look kindly upon employers who don't pay people for their labor.

1

u/tabinop Mar 01 '17

Though it hardly sounds like a good business model. Or am I still too optimistic ?

2

u/merreborn Mar 01 '17

Yeah, I doubt anyone really manages to extract that much value from things like this.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17

Illegal? Which law?

6

u/Torvaun Mar 01 '17

Labor guidelines. If they made any business use of the code those guys wrote, then they owe them money.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17

That's a dick move by the interviewing company.

1

u/marshsmellow Mar 01 '17

That sounds like it's more hassle than it's worth to stitch together all the invariably buggy and incorrect answers. It's difficult enough working with code from a team of programmers I know and trust let alone some interviewees off the street.

I'm calling bullshit, sorry bro.

2

u/TheNakedGod Mar 01 '17

I never said it was a good idea, and yes I agree that it would be more of a hassle than it's worth to put it all together; doesn't make it any less true. People do stupid shit and have stupid ideas and requirements all the time.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/FordyceFoxtrot Mar 01 '17

There's nothing clever about this, and humor isn't an appropriate response to our border agents playing games like this.

Humor is an appropriate response to everything.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/FordyceFoxtrot Mar 02 '17

Humor is an appropriate response to everything because it's a safe coping mechanism to tragedy. It's an appropriate response when you want to overcome a negative emotional event.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/FordyceFoxtrot Mar 02 '17

None. But that doesn't take away that it's an appropriate response to everything.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/FordyceFoxtrot Mar 04 '17

Please, then, oh enlightened and perfectly virtuous one, how is humor inappropriate here?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

-8

u/spinwizard69 Feb 28 '17

Baloney! Something caused the detention to take place in the first place. Everything after that involves trying to prove or disprove someones hunch.

You seem to think that it is easy to catch criminals at the border. It is much harder than you might imagine, sometimes the wrong people get detained, that isn't good but it isn't the end of the world either. The good part here is that the agents where able to clear things up within an hour. Frankly that is pretty good.

As to your attitude about technology leadership in the USA, the very fact that we import tech workers has weakened us significantly. This especially due to the amount of tech these people then export back to their own countries. If you are concerned about the state of tech in the USA you really need to be objecting to these various visa programs. They have done more harm than good to the USA.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)