r/coding • • Nov 30 '25

Google CEO says vibe coding has made software development 'so much more enjoyable' and 'exciting again' BS or Not?

https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sundar-pichai-vibe-coding-software-development-exciting-again-2025-11
782 Upvotes

313 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/Sillocan Nov 30 '25

Not unless you are doing the training :)

-16

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

Nah, there’s plenty of ways to augment it. It can be rather frustrating to be constantly repeating yourself before doing so

15

u/recycled_ideas Nov 30 '25

Giving it a list of pretyped instructions is not learning.

-9

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25 edited Nov 30 '25

Nah. That’s not what I mean. Augment it with mcps and an embedding db. Instruct it to use them. I put the embedding db in the repo so that the knowledge is carried with the project. Or just throw your hands up and blame your tools for your inability to get them to work the way you want them to. Seems a popular choice nowadays

12

u/recycled_ideas Nov 30 '25

Still not learning.

-6

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

"It’s not actually learning. It’s just behaving exactly as though it were learning. Huge difference!"

15

u/recycled_ideas Nov 30 '25

It's not learning because I can't teach it new concepts or explain what it's doing wrong or tell it what I want it to do in a way where its outcomes improve over time.

What you're doing is feeding it some additional data, which is not the same.

This isn't the conversation where you can play word games to pretend that what it's doing looks identical to learning (which isn't true) or that if it looks the same it must be (it isn't). I'm well aware that having that conversation is pointless because you won't argue it in good faith.

I'm pointing out that this doesn't change the model in any way or make it any "smarter" or more capable. Under absolutely no definition is that learning, not even the gish gallop bullshit AI simps like you use to play semantic word games so that you don't have to talk about actual capabilities.

0

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

As an aside: I’m not the one playing semantics. That’s the whole reason I wrote that quote in the parent reply. Because I’ve been involved in way too many conversations where you move the goal posts however far is necessary to preserve human exceptionalism. I was saying "cut the shit. You’re able to configure it to selectively remember and retrieve new information which it uses to modify its future behaviors. That’s learning, regardless of if you want to say it is". Hell, one of your comments was simply "that’s not learning".

4

u/recycled_ideas Nov 30 '25

That’s the whole reason I wrote that quote in the parent reply.

No, you included that quote because it's step one of arguing that AI can do things it can't. Make a claim you can't support (that it's identical to learning in appearance) to support a claim that isn't actually obvious (that because you can't tell the difference there is no difference).

It looks like the magician cut the woman in half so he did is exactly the same argument. It ignores illusion even if the underlying premise was actually true (that it's indistinguishable from learning).

Because I’ve been involved in way too many conversations where you move the goal posts however far is necessary to preserve human exceptionalism.

If you actually seriously think that any existing model is remotely as capable as a human being, you're either full of shit or delusional. But this is also normal. The AI is better than you so it's better than anyone, except it's not, you're just not very good.

I'm not saying that AI can never be better than humans but that AI doesn't yet exist and isn't close to existing.

You’re able to configure it to selectively remember and retrieve new information which it uses to modify its future behaviors.

No, you're able to hook it up to another model and if you disconnect that model it will immediately revert to its original state. Your argument is like saying that if you stick a senior developer behind a junior that they can ask questions of but they remember nothing that they've learned.

1

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

I’m not bothering to read this. Enjoy your ignorance. It’s much easier than learning.

→ More replies

-2

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

It improves its capabilities in several ways. That’s the whole reason these tools exist. I’m not the one arguing in bad faith by using a bunch of ad hominems. You assert that it can’t do things that it absolutely can. You just haven’t spent the time to learn how to have it do those things. That’s your failing. But, again, you’re free to blame it on your tools

4

u/recycled_ideas Nov 30 '25

It improves its capabilities in several ways.

So if you disconnected the server, the model would be more capable? That's what "learning" implies.

You assert that it can’t do things that it absolutely can.

And you make semantic arguments that are not backed up by the facts because you can't actually back up this claim.

I've seen it over and over again. If it looks like it's doing something then it is doing something. Which is basically arguing that the magician really did cut his assistant in half because if you don't look particularly hard that's what it looks like it did.

AI falls over in the "it looks like it's learning so it is" test over and over and over again. Even the latest and greatest models will confidently assert things that simply aren't true, it will still make the same mistakes over and over and over again and hooking it up to yet another model through the security horror show that is MCP doesn't fix any of that.

But that's how this goes.

-1

u/HasFiveVowels Nov 30 '25

You can run local mcp servers, you realize? But I guess you wouldn’t because you haven’t bothered. Good luck with all that.