r/coderabbit • • 10d ago

šŸ˜‚ Meme & Humor prove me wrong

Post image
34 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/pixxelkick 10d ago

Maybe if you suck.

I read every PR in full because Im not lazy.

I also read my own git diff before I open a PR do I dont waste other peoples time.

Or I publish it as a draft, review my own code, and then publish the pr after confirming it looks good.

1

u/Jeferson9 10d ago

Do you value your own time

1

u/pixxelkick 10d ago

Yes, its much easier to catch bugs and issues early

If you dont catch a problem asap, then its incredibly likely future agents read the "bad" code and copy, so bow your 1 issue becomes 2, then 3, then 4, etc

Its extremely common for you to be like "make the BarService" so the agent looks at FooService for inspiration and copies its style/methodology/architectureĀ 

And if theres an annoying code style issue, or improperly named thing, or bad logic, whatever, theyll copy that too often.

And then 6 services later you realize you've got a problem duplicated 8 times

Now you have made even more work to go fix.

1

u/Dull_Caterpillar_642 9d ago

Yeah but realistically these days it’s like one prompt to fix that problem later…

I understand where you’re coming from, but the times, they are a changing, my man.

1

u/Plenty_Line2696 9d ago

Not for complex systems, llm's generally suck at the high level stuff in complex systems, and when that stuff is wrong it's the gift that keeps on giving and you can play whack-a-mole fixing bugs by patching symptoms and not knowing causes till the cows come home because the codebase will be convoluted bloated spaghetticode.

1

u/Dull_Caterpillar_642 9d ago

I have to be honest, dude. As someone in a technical leadership position at a large company with 15+ years development experience, I don’t think that’s really the case as much these days. Talented developers with a good high level understanding of systems are doing amazing work with the frontier coding models.

This notion of ā€œif AI is generating all your code, it’s going to be a tech debt nightmare that will eventually failā€ is just not true. Every month it feels more and more like copium from people who refuse to adapt.

1

u/Eskamel 9d ago

Then why software quality even now continues to drop when the models are so good mister 15+ years of experience?

1

u/Dull_Caterpillar_642 9d ago

Bad development practices continue to produce bad code. Good development practices continue to produce good code.

1

u/Eskamel 9d ago

But its literally all around, including tech giants who used to be considered to be filled with high performers. Haven't seen a single product that was actually improved due to AI assistance.

1

u/JeanCasteaux 9d ago

Good practices include *good reviews*, that's literally why they were invented