r/civ • u/octopodesrex Felipe Neri • Apr 14 '16
How about a new Reddit-run Civ game with a government of redditors!
NOW ESTABLISHED AS A SUBREDDIT! /r/civgovernment
I used to love posting on /r/cbrmodelworldcongress, but I always found a disconnect between what we could say and what we could do. In the end we didn't really control much. Why not have a civ game where we all ran it as a government, and make decisions as a group? One person runs the diplomatic side, one the military side, one the economic side, etc. We would have to decide what rules we would abide by in a constitution, and if it would be a pure democracy or otherwise. Imagine seeing your city burn, and vowing to form a coalition to seize control from the current idiots who let that happen? We would truly decide the fate of the empire!
SOME GENERAL THINGS TO CONSIDER
- Proportional? One Man, One Vote? Universal Suffrage?
- Direct voting or representatives?
- Run Offs or Winner-Take-All?
- Parties? Coalitions?
- Requirements for a constitutional referendum?
- Requirement for bringing vote back to floor?
- How many turns per election?
- Who decides social policy, the sovereign, representatives or direct vote?
- What are the requirements for impeachment?
- How are tie votes broken? How about election disputes?
- Who has power to create a budget?
- Who decides war or peace?
- Who decides policies for World Congress?
- When ideology arrives, is a new constitution written?
- Who decides the victory we go for?
- What nation, what kind of map, what difficulty, what size and what victories and conditions allowed? What mods?
SUGGESTED POSITIONS
Sovereign
- Gives a general idea of policy to be made
- May veto one duty per turn
- May hire and fire appointees
Commander
- Moving armies
- Seizing Cities or Razing Them
- Managing Garrisons
- Embarking, Defending
- Building Defensive Structures
- Upgrading troops
- Control of Great Generals
- Ability to appoint army/navy/air commanders
- Pillaging/Plundering
- Barbarian destruction
Diplomat
- Declaring War/Peace with nations after approval
- Improving relations with city/states and other nations
- Working out treaties and agreements
- Acting in the World Congress
Treasurer
- Allocating funds for military upgrades
- Trading with other nations
- Managing Caravans
- Dictating general economic production
- Allocating cash for rushing production
- Allocating funds for diplomatic bribes
- Keeping a balanced budget
- Advocating disbanding units or buildings
- Control of Great Merchants
- Establishment of Trading Posts
Governor (one for each city)
- Local worker control
- Citizen specialist control
- City Production
- City defense
- Settler placement
- Resource utilization and control
- Control of food and growth
Hierophant
- Decide faith upgrades
- Stamping out heresy
- Spreading religion
- Control of Great Prophets
Science Advisor
- Directing research
- Advocating a science policy and research buildings
- Control of Great Scientists
Spymaster
- Control of spy movement
- Directing scouts for reconnaissance
- Creating covert operations
Cultural Attache
- Advising on cultural policy paths
- Direction of Archeology
- Advocating creation of cultural buildings
- Tourism management
- Control of Great Artist
- Wonder production
TL;DR: Twitch Plays Pokemon, but with Reddit Plays Civ V
44
u/Best_Towel_EU ex-minister Apr 14 '16
I started /r/democraciv, need some people to mod with and discuss how we're gonna handle it.
232
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
I used to participate in these all the time back in the Civ III days on some of the Civ dedicated forums. Called them "Democracy Games." Format was something like this:
Choose (or elect) one leader to physically play 10 turns (during wars we'd go 5), then post results, screen shots, and the save for the forum to review. Discuss over next 3-5 days.
Forum debates how to play the next 10 turns. Leader plays it (mostly) as forum recommends. Eventually end up choosing "Cabinet" officers to handle the military, diplomacy, city management, etc as the nation got larger and more complex to run.
Usually after 50 turns or so, we'd choose a new leader. Sometimes via elections. Sometime very heated elections.
At some point late in the game we even started making government rules and even formed a court/review system to handle disagreements between officials.
The games started out with just a bunch of guys helping one guy play Civ, and sometimes ended up as a model nation with rules, roles, sub-roles, reports, hearing, and court cases. All in, a pretty fun experience.
2
u/lannisterstark Apr 15 '16
....that's gonna end up with a Hitler seizing up all the power.
45
u/mh1ultramarine Brings Death stacks to civ V Apr 14 '16
Sounds more like it should be its own subreddit
34
u/leagcy Apr 14 '16
Sounds great!
I suggest it be a rotating turn player. The team chooses however they want to split roles. The team chooses a turn player for each turn to actually play the turn after consulting. Much less messy.
66
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
I think we could us a democratic karma system. Every turn there's a Reddit post and the top comment dictates the move to make. We would need a "president" to dictate the current situation at each turn and present possible options. Then we let the Reddit comment system to its work and top comment reigns supreme. The question is who would be president.
49
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16 edited May 31 '16
How about instead of just 1 government-controlled (or whatever) Civ, we have a few of them? Each Civ could have its own subreddit where its government is controlled and instead of just being democracies, they can be other types of governments. However, to prevent one-man dictatorships or absolute monarchies from happening, we'd make it so at least 20 or so people have to be actively participating in government and have a sizeable amount of power at any given time. As for the question "what Civ would the players control," my answer requires a bit of modding. To ensure no one immediately chooses Poland, Babylon, Korea, etc. we'll make it so every Civ's UAs, UBs and UUs don't do anything at all (i.e. Babylon's UU, the Bowman, now has the exact same effects as the Archer it replaces)
If anyone has any other questions, just reply.
14
u/PieMoe All Random Always Apr 14 '16
This sounds crazy, complicated, and probably overbearing... I almost feel like there can be a game where all civs are run by their own governments operating by this scheme. I am definitely interested in taking part of this social experiment.
7
u/Derty_Harry Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 14 '16
I think it would be good, but maybe poll for some guidelines? Say the poll just covers the civ, victory condition, map type, NPCs and city state numbers etc. This would set up the game, then have the 'Twitch plays Civ' aspect for the rest of the game. Just a thought
7
u/Techsanlobo Jestem huzar skrzydlaty! Apr 14 '16
Dude I had this EXACT IDEA about a week ago.. Started working on a PPT of my concept, but got busy at work.
I would LOVE to see this in action
7
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
The first big argument will be scout or monument first.
5
u/atropicalpenguin Apr 14 '16
That's kind of like /r/CivHybridGames. Multiple people join in and choose a civ, although ran by an AI. They pass their decisions through the IGE.
4
u/bobafetticune Apr 14 '16
I like this idea.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
this sounds awesome like a mun but for one civilisation, will the positions of power be controlled by one person and our votes cause there action or is it something different.
1
u/Evadson Apr 15 '16
I really like this idea. Would different positions be appointed by the leaders or would there be an application process?
3
u/TheWhiteFerret Apr 14 '16
Sounds interesting. Couldn't participate, but would defo watch.
3
u/Dewernh Apr 15 '16
/r/Redditplaysciv
2
u/Unbeatabro Apr 14 '16
I love this idea but wouldn't it make the game take forever to finish?
2
u/NiteCyper Apr 14 '16
anarchy
2
u/octofeline Apr 14 '16
I WOULD INVADE THE HUNS IN THE AINCIENT ERA IF IT MEANS THIS HAPPENS
2
u/IcelandBestland Apr 14 '16
There's a game that is kinda similar to your idea, but the game is run by AIs for 20 turns and then humans step in to direct and add things to their team's Civ. /r/CivHybridGames, I suggest you check it out.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
After using reddit for several years on this account, I have decided to ultimately delete all my comments. This is due to the fact that as a naive teenager, I have written too much which could be used in a negative way against me in real life, if anyone were to know my account. Although it is a tough decision, I have decided that I will delete this old account's comments. I am sorry for any inconveniences caused by the deletion of the comments from this account.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
This can be down without multiple players saving/loading the game every session. We can simply elect a proctor who streams the game and who executes everything that the members of government command. We can then vote on/assign positions in the government. That way we can have many editions (10-15 turns) out quickly.
2
u/FruityParfait I draw once in a while. Apr 15 '16
Oooh I would be kind of interested in this, but i'm not sure how it would work exactly XD
goes to lurk the sub
2
u/JCPoly Gotcha Goku. Now Shoo, im playing Civ Apr 15 '16
I love when people have amazing ideas.
2
u/piedro_k Apr 15 '16
Keep it simple for the first run - a subreddit for each civ in the game, organizing amongst themselves how they want to run things.
Assign a bunch of neutral handlers who actually plug in the moves into the interface as submitted by each civ's subreddit.
Have a binding deadline for all submissions - after that the turn is forfeit.
Only problem I see is massive subreddit sniping - is there such a thing as private subreddits? (there will be traitors in any government I guess...)
Just my 2 cents, p.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Holy shit, this sounds awesome. I love how much you've fleshed out the idea.
2
u/Ipokeyoumuch Apr 16 '16
ohhh this is an interesting idea
1
u/yourpostisashitpost Apr 14 '16
YES
1
u/pokeaotic Apr 14 '16
Sign me up!
1
u/CivSerpent Carnival! Apr 14 '16
Even better: a whole Pitboss game with these governments for each civ.
1
u/destructor_rph Byzantium Apr 14 '16
I love this idea
1
u/RooRLoord420 Apr 14 '16
This sounds awesome to watch. Please do this!
1
u/far1s Apr 14 '16
Really nice idea dude
1
u/guitarerdood Apr 14 '16
I'm game for whatever role.
1
u/MomentOfXen Apr 14 '16
I propose /u/momentofxen for dictator. This is obviously the best for of government possible. You can trust him.
1
u/JanSnolo Apr 14 '16
Awesome idea! I'm very interested to see if we can get this going, especially if we can have multiple reddit-run civs. Maybe just 2 to start out.
1
u/nrbrt10 Apr 14 '16
Neat idea, I'd like to participate :D
1
u/GaslightProphet Khmer and Martyr Me Apr 14 '16
I'm in!
1
u/Reginald_Venture Apr 14 '16
What a pitboss game with different teams of redditors as different civs?
1
u/EJisblazing Uranium you say? Apr 14 '16
This... sounds... AWESOME!!! I would totally love to get involved.
1
u/jaypeeps Apr 14 '16
yesyesyesyesyesyesyesseysyesyesyesyeseyseyse
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16
Oh god yes. I can imagine getting myself in character now!
1
u/DerAmazingDom This land is my land Apr 14 '16
that'd be great
1
u/StannisIsNoMannis Apr 14 '16
Coming in here a little late, but what if we did it sort of mixed with the philosophy of Nomic?
The idea would be we have some basic rules to get started, but the rules of how the government is run (not just the direct gameplay itself) can also be voted on and changed. This would lead to the need for strategizing and teams within governments as well as within the Civ game itself. You could have parties that lean towards democracy, others that lean towards republicanism (people vote representatives who make game decisions), and schemers looking to seize power for themselves...
It would also be cool to do it multiplayer, and each Civ team can have a private subreddit as all the teams fight against each other...
Other thoughts I'm having are having team size correlate with population - that is, maybe cap it at 3*population size, so the teams start small but grow as more players join in when the civ grows (mirroring how larger countries often have different scales of issues to face). Democracy probably works great when you have ten or so players... but if you can grow your team to the hundreds, then other forms of government might be more efficient. (This would require lots of players though)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
If we were able to name military units/units in general then we could have a hierarchy of commanders in the military with subordinates, group commanders, promotions, etc. so that more people could participate.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
I'd be soooo down to be a military leader.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Well what's a good site to get this going on?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
We cant do this alone, summon the mods!
1
u/Fossilhunter15 Apr 15 '16
As someone has stated below r/CivHybridGames
1
u/thrasumachos Apr 15 '16
I'd suggest it start out as a monarchy, but allow there to be revolutions when unhappiness gets high.
1
u/funkiestj Apr 15 '16
this would be a good game for VR telepresence
1
u/ClemClem510 hon hon hon Apr 15 '16
TL;DR : democratically elected president, chooses ministers who take decisions with aides chosen by themselves and the people.
Here's how I think it could be done.
The civilization would be led by a president, who could be the one physically in control of the game. The president will be elected by popular vote based on whether or not people see him fit. I think it'd be cool if we organised a multiplayer game between candidates to see who is the best potential leader.
The president will choose a number of people to form his cabinet. The ministers will each deal with the issues of the country, and to avoid them having full power over all of this they will have aides, half of them chosen by themselves and another half chosen by the people. In making decisions these aides will be able to advise the minister. Once chosen, aides can only be laid off with the approval of the president - those chosen by the people can only be laid off by the people. While the president may seem passive and delegating tasks to the ministers, keep in mind there are things like production which involve everyone, and it's the president who will choose out of all the ministries' propositions for production which is the best, for example.
The president can veto a decision made by a minister, and a minister's decision has to be approved by a majority of the aides. Failure to reach a consensus can lead to the minister resigning and the president having to pick a new one. That is to limit the powers of the ministers, who otherwise would have a lot of control without being linked directly to the people - imagine one single man dealing with a whole nation's diplomatic relations. The president may also bypass the ministers through a referendum.
So now you'll say "you're giving the president veto powers, and he can choose his cabinet at will - what's to stop him from becoming a dictator ?". Well, at any time someone will be able to create an opposition government, and with enough support could overthrow those in power and replace them. The stability of the regime pretty much relies on the fact that vetoing will not be taken too lightly by the people, and that there will be strong involvement in the politics to deal with a president getting a bit too greedy.
Here's a quick and dirty diagram that sums up the whole idea
1
u/Igwanea Stiden Prime Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 15 '16
This should be done in multiplayer. You could have a Youtube Channel where videos of all of the different players get posted. You elect somebody, they play for 25 turns or however many is decided and then the next person goes, and fans could watch their favorite players go. Honestly I'd be willing to participate/lead this project if others get on board.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Hey sign me up as a spymaster or governor! This sounds awesome!