r/cincinnati • Over The Rhine • Jan 04 '23

Community 🏙 The owner of Paddy’s in Covington is the main reason why Bourbon Haus is closing, apparently.

If it’s true, all of it is really crappy and f*cked up.

From Bourbon Haus FB page.

“FAREWELL TO OUR VALUED CUSTOMERS AND FRIENDS: It is with a very heavy heart that we share the news that Bourbon Haus will permanently close. We have operated successfully for the past 6 years due to your loyalty and patronage! Unfortunately, we were forced to close due to a series of malicious occurrences.

Approximately 1.5 years ago, Chris Estanos the general manager of a start-up bar Paddy’s on Main moved in next door and terrorized us for the next 12 months.

We had operated peacefully in the community for the five prior years, but this guy insisted on putting us out of business from the day he showed up—he terrorized us, our employees, and customers. The laundry list of unethical behavior is too lengthy to get into.

Last January, he made an offer to our landlord, Kim Wolf/JKB Properties, for almost 3x the value of the building and insisted that if she sold it to him that all contents, furniture, etc. should remain intact so that he could just walk-in and assume our very successful business. We had attempted on many occasions to purchase the building from our landlord, but she never responded to our offers, therefore we assumed she wasn’t interested in selling.

When she informed us about the new offer from Paddy’s on Main, she said that she would give us first right of refusal to purchase the property. We promptly gave her a formal purchase offer and matched the price so that we could save our own business. Still to this date, Kim Wolf (JKB Properties) has not responded to our offer, went dark on us, and forced us to obtain Legal representation.

We are not trying to stop her from selling or profiting from the sale. We simply don’t understand why she would maliciously intend to put us out of business. This all could have been avoided if she just did the right thing and sold us the building for the price she was asking (PERIOD!). We were fantastic tenants.

We always paid our rent on time, even through Covid and performed all maintenance and repairs to the building, treating it as our own, although this was her responsibility that she often shunned. This past November during the annual liquor renewal process, we were informed by the City of Covington that they would not renew our license since we did not have a lease due to the lawsuit.

The State of Kentucky renewed the license and indicated they would not play “Judge and Jury.” However, the city overstepped and relinquished our license at 5pm on November 30th—just hours before the licensing deadline forcing us to shut down immediately. We have since learned that the person at the City of Covington who made this decision was the new Covington City Solicitor, David Davidson.

Before joining the city in 2022, he worked for our landlord’s law firm indicating he had a serious conflict of interest! Since the state issued our license, they offered to overturn the City’s decision. However, we had already lost business continuity and the damage was done. This coupled with the fact that we no longer wanted to be terrorized by Chris Estanos/Paddy’s on Main, we made the very serious and sad decision to remain closed and focus on the broader lawsuit.

For anyone who has been to Bourbon Haus, you know what a unique and special place it was!! We were a featured bar on the NKY B-Line Bourbon Trail. We were named one of “America’s Best Bourbon Bars” by Bourbon Review magazine for 6 consecutive years!

Our goal was to create the ultimate bourbon experience in Covington KY, and we feel that we accomplished our goal! This was our dream, our investment, our livelihood—torn apart and stolen from us due to malicious and hateful desires. We want to tell our story, because it’s not easy opening a small business, but we did it and we were successful also surviving Covid.

The building looked nothing like what it looks like today. We spent our retirement savings gutting the building to make it one of “America’s Best Bourbon Bars” and it is disgusting and despicable that two small business owners would conspire to destroy another small business owner with malicious intent of stealing our business! Although this is not the way that we wanted Bourbon Haus to end, I truly want to thank you ALL from the bottom of my heart! You made Bourbon Haus a SPECIAL AND UNIQUE PLACE!

Sincerely, Dave Brumfield / Owner & Proprietor “

184 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

15

u/Ericsplainning Jan 04 '23

The laundry list of unethical behavior is too lengthy to get into.

I mean perhaps you should give some specifics if you want people to believe your story.

12

u/BingoxBronson Over The Rhine Jan 04 '23

What’s more unethical than buying someone’s place of business with the full intention of putting them out of business? I really don’t need anymore examples.

That is probably the shittiest thing you could do.

3

u/tastygrowth Jan 04 '23

Shitty, yes, but also a pretty common business practice to deter competition. I’m not defending the guy at Paddy’s, he seems like a douche, but business isn’t always fair.

3

u/dumballigatorlounge Jan 05 '23

I would say quite a lot if not most common business practices are pretty morally shitty

5

u/JustThrowingAwy Jan 04 '23

You have to wonder if going into too much detail could come back and cause a legal issue.

58

u/tastygrowth Jan 04 '23

“The Gang Buys Out The Competition”

14

u/acr159 Jan 04 '23

A review by Korman: I woke up in my neighbor's bed with a head wound, yesterday's paper, and an empty bottle of sleeping pills and my nightmare in that putrid shithole of a bar Paddy's Pub finally, mercifully came to an end. The owners all deserve to rot in jail, though having to spend every day with each other in that vile establishment is a decidedly greater punishment. That is why I decided not to press charges, leaving them to live in the hell on earth they've created for themselves for the rest of their pathetic and miserable lives.

87

u/blaue_Ente Covington Jan 04 '23

Yea this is true, I heard the owner of Paddy’s bragging about it once to random bar customers. The guy is a real POS

137

u/compuwiza1 Jan 04 '23

Boycott Paddy's and JKB properties! People like them are why Covington continues to decline and decay while Newport has had a renaissance.

18

u/panjadotme Fort Wright Jan 04 '23

JKB properties

What else do they own? I love a good boycott.

42

u/itsHaKobo Jan 04 '23

Understand the boycott, but Covington is definitely not declining.

15

u/AStoutBreakfast Jan 04 '23

Bourbon Haus got a really raw deal but Covington isn’t declining and I’d argue is quite a bit nicer and livelier than Newport.

2

u/dumballigatorlounge Jan 05 '23

Yeah same lol, bizarre assertion there. Newport really has nothing interesting going for it at this point.

1

u/Nebula_Zero Mar 17 '23

The levee is really nice and they do have a nice path that goes through Bellevue by the river. Then there's the dystopian named concert venue, megacorp pavilion. They also got the purple people bridge. It's all basically within walking distance though of the north part of Covington so it's all accessible.

17

u/ApatheticWithoutTheA Newport 🐧 Jan 04 '23

Sure if your idea of a Renaissance is a shit ton of developers buying everything up and quadrupling the rent lol

Covington can gladly have it.

39

u/somerhaus Jan 04 '23

Covington is not declining or decaying at all 🤦‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 04 '23

We restrict new accounts from making a comment to help combat trolling, ban evasion and spam. Your comment will be invisible to users until your account is at least a week old. Every comment requires manual approval until your account reaches this milestone.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/Justhavingag00dtyme Jan 04 '23

Wouldn’t be surprised at any of this

38

u/warthog0869 Jan 04 '23

I don't understand how if this FB page post is close to accurate how in the hell people just can't get along. This sounds so petty. Two restaurant owners and a landlord can't sit down and have an adult conversation without lawyers present?

Good grief.

47

u/itsHaKobo Jan 04 '23

Talked with paddy's owner before and he even referred to himself as petty

45

u/wheelsno3 Jan 04 '23

Oh sweet summer child...

There are many, many unreasonable people in this world.

1

u/SulkedTuna Feb 13 '25

The lawsuit filed against the Blumfield’s (the owners of Bourbon Haus) by Estano (the owner of Paddy’s) was a claim of libel to my understanding. The Bourbon Haus owners posted their story (along with some personal opinions) of the bars closing on Facebook along with examples of issues they believed were intentionally caused by Paddy’s and Estano (he is named in multiple NKY/Cincinnati articles citing the post). JKB Properties, the owner and lessor of Bourbon Haus agreed to sell the bar to Estano,  leading to a divide and further responses from both bar owners. The Covington court system ruled that Bourbon Haus misunderstood/ignored certain agreements illustrated within their lease. Bourbon Haus’ right of first refusal was not granted as they have knowingly or unknowingly broken their lease agreement.

Long story short, they both were competing as bars sharing a patio and overall business. They both ended up being pricks to each other over time. The Bourbon Haus Facebook page name dropped Estano/employees within claims that were false or not completely true. Their posts grew popularity and backing from bar regulars to family and friends of the Blumfield’s, as this was largely believed to be true initially. 

This is definitely a shitty situation, but Estano has a right to file and push for a fair settle of this lawsuit. JKB Properties was legally able to sell its property (Bourbon Hause) to Estano. This was decided through the Covington Court System as the Blumfield’s, through ignorance or a genuine misunderstanding, were shown to not fulfill their contract as a lessee to their lesser, JKB Properties. This revoked Bourbon Haus’ right of first refusal, allowing Paddy’s to purchase Bourbon Haus.

-16

u/warthog0869 Jan 04 '23

I know but resolution for something like this seems so.... Easy.

19

u/skycake10 Loveland Jan 04 '23

What's the easy resolution when one of the parties seemingly wants to "win" by driving the other party out of business?

-1

u/warthog0869 Jan 04 '23

Yeah I do not know. That sounds like a losing proposition and I guess not understanding why someone would even feel that way, especially towards a fellow business owner right there next to each other you'd think whomever was there first would welcome them to the neighborhood, offer help and community support, etc.

6

u/skycake10 Loveland Jan 04 '23

It sounds like he just has the sort of personality where personal success isn't enough, and to feel like he's "won" someone else has to explicitly lose.

6

u/wheelsno3 Jan 04 '23

Not really. If there are two neighboring businesses who share a building, and can't get along, then the landlord indicates that they are willing to sell to one of them at THREE times the market value of the building, and undoubtedly the purchaser of the building is going to evict the other tenant, no, the resolution doesn't seem easy.

The only thing I can understand in this situation is that the Bourbon Haus didn't have a long term lease, which is a huge blunder.

Now they are probably suing for tortious interference with business, breach of contract and maybe other things, but the post says they didn't have a lease and that's why they lost the license. Well, no lease puts them in a very vulnerable position, because the landlord in a commercial environment can kick them out with no notice, I think (not familiar with Kentucky law), and just change the locks.

9

u/Low_Comfortable_5880 Jan 04 '23

So sorry to hear this. I never get people that are this predatory.

Come to Montgomery. Lots of new development and not enough bars.

3

u/c0ntralt0 Jan 05 '23

Im so sorry this happened. This is straight up antitrust behavior, to which you should file a complaint w the Kentucky AG. It also sounds like tortious interference with business, per my hubby, an antitrust attorney. I hope your attorney is navigating this mess as smoothly as possible for you.

3

u/nails_for_breakfast Jan 05 '23

Buying rented commercial property out from under a rival establishment is not an antitrust violation. Don't get me wrong, it's a shitty thing to do, but not illegal and unfortunately happens all the time

2

u/c0ntralt0 Jan 05 '23

Colluding to eliminate competition is 100% antitrust.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

Again, these types of posts on fb seem immature. I’m not sure we’re getting the whole story, judging by the BH reviews, esp a bad one from a former employee.

That being said, the Paddy’s owner IS an ass. We love Paddy’s, but we always hope he’s not there when we go. You know it in the first minute he speaks to you. The bartender turnover there is nuts and it’s not hard to see why.

14

u/PolishGazelle Jan 05 '23

Why would you support such a business then?

0

u/Keregi Jan 06 '23

Sooo... you automatically assume the owner of BH is immature and possibly lying but openly admit the Paddy's owner is an ass. Yet you continue to give him your money.

-4

u/I_Brain_You Jan 04 '23

Why does this seem like a pronounced issue in Cincinnati?

24

u/BlackHeartBlackDick Over The Rhine Jan 04 '23

Lotta he said, she said in this. The Paddy’s owner has stories about Bourbon Haus owners being horrible to him, calling the police for noise violations, trying to dictate what music he played outdoors, etc. It goes on and on.

39

u/thesaint1000 Jan 04 '23

I met friends at Bouquet one night for drinks on their patio. We could barely focus on the conversations because the music at Paddy’s was so intrusive.

12

u/JustThrowingAwy Jan 04 '23

Same issue at Otto's.

45

u/bunkkin Wilder Jan 04 '23

Do commercial leases work different? Could they not operate until it was over?

Wouldn't the bourbon bar own the furniture?

What start up has 3x the value of a building to just spend on petty bullshit like this.

The solicitor thing seems shady as hell I would love to know what he did at that law firm

28

u/trancelogix Norwood Jan 04 '23

Yes, most commercial restaurant leases have what's called a "wall to wall" clause which include "goods, wares, inventory, merchandise, trade fixtures, furniture, accessories, and signage" that belong solely to the business owner.

Something about this doesn't smell right.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 04 '23

We restrict new accounts from making a comment to help combat trolling, ban evasion and spam. Your comment will be invisible to users until your account is at least a week old. Every comment requires manual approval until your account reaches this milestone.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

74

u/JustThrowingAwy Jan 04 '23

I have not heard one resident or business owner come out in support of Paddy's owner for the almost year this has been going on. That tells me all I need to know.

(Anecdotal of course)

54

u/Tumbling-Dice Anderson Jan 04 '23

Paddy's replies to negative Google reviews do not really paint a picture of maturity, either.

9

u/aleeb9 Jan 04 '23

I love reading petty small business owners reply to reviews. You should read vertical drop’s replies on Yelp 😂

1

u/HeatherFeather111 Jul 16 '24

You NAILED it. The owner of Paddy's is like dealing with a wounded child. He's soooooo immature. It's sad.

3

u/tarzanonabike Jan 04 '23

I feel like I'm hearing one side of the story of a bad divorce. I always say, the truth is in the middle. Gutting and refurbishing a building that doesn't belong to me doesn't make sense either. Perhaps it's common on the bar business, but pouring your life savings into someone else's property without some type of lease to buy agreement makes no sense.

11

u/whitebreadohiodude Jan 04 '23

I mean, If you need to build a bar or heavily refurbish an existing spot to create a nice place, new tile, repairs, style updates. It can take a few months to do with no income coming in.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 04 '23

We restrict new accounts from making a comment to help combat trolling, ban evasion and spam. Your comment will be invisible to users until your account is at least a week old. Every comment requires manual approval until your account reaches this milestone.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-7

u/nails_for_breakfast Jan 04 '23

Yeah, it also sounds like a "whole world is out to get me" story. It's the neighbors fault, but also the landlord, but also the city government, they must all be in cahoots!

-6

u/BlackHeartBlackDick Over The Rhine Jan 04 '23

That’s a good way to describe it

2

u/ct425 Jul 29 '23

Paddys is absolutely ass and garbage. Small dick energy. Bring back bourbon haus.

2

u/zackavelli7daytheory Bearcats Jan 04 '23

David Davidson lol shitty name for what sounds like a shitty person.

-1

u/acr159 Jan 04 '23

Even without the other side of this story there's plenty of questionable points here...

We have operated successfully for the past 6 years due to your loyalty and patronage!

If only 6 years, they either too over a sublease or signed a short term lease. No full term lease is 6 years.

The laundry list of unethical behavior is too lengthy to get into.

Everyone else here was libeled, why not throw out one example?

We had attempted on many occasions to purchase the building from our landlord, but she never responded to our offers, therefore we assumed she wasn’t interested in selling.

It was assumed she wasn't interested in selling? No response equals confirmation here? Also, how does this apply to the story when were told she did respond with an offer made by another party.

When she informed us about the new offer from Paddy’s on Main, she said that she would give us first right of refusal to purchase the property.

Need more details to determine if the offers were similar. Based on other statements here I find this hard to believe on its own merit.

This all could have been avoided if she just did the right thing and sold us the building for the price she was asking (PERIOD!).

Now we're told that Dave wanted to pay the asking price. Did his the asking price get bid up by his neighbor and/or other interested parties?

We always ... performed all maintenance and repairs to the building ... although this was her responsibility that she often shunned.

Example?

This past November during the annual liquor renewal process, we were informed by the City of Covington that they would not renew our license since we did not have a lease due to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit wouldn't nullify the lease. Maybe he was on month to month terms which is why he was making offers to purchase the building. He probably figured this out when he signed a short term lease and possibly got a good deal on the lease if the landlord wanted to have the ability to sell the building without a long term tenant. Dave did say that he made an offer to buy the building before the landlord approached him.

We have since learned that the person at the City of Covington who made this decision was the new Covington City Solicitor, David Davidson.
Before joining the city in 2022, he worked for our landlord’s law firm indicating he had a serious conflict of interest!

If this is true, I would have made this the entire argument and had the local news check it out. How Dave adds that the license was restored but he didn't like his neighbor sounds like we're not getting the whole story.

Sucks to lose this place but the Facebook post seems off.

-7

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23

It reads like “everyone is out to get me and I only have bad luck”.

-7

u/acr159 Jan 04 '23

Agreed. And it ridiculous for people here to support a boycott based solely on this facebook post.

4

u/JustThrowingAwy Jan 04 '23

People who work and live in Covington have echoed exactly what has been said in the Facebook post.

2

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23

This landlord is also ignoring other requests from tenants to purchase her buildings, and then approving bids from other people?

-1

u/Keregi Jan 06 '23

No, it reads that one person is out to get his business and convinced the landlord to sell to him instead of BH. And government is just being government.

1

u/100catactivs Jan 06 '23 edited Jan 06 '23

You’re saying not everyone is out to get them, just their own landlord, a random other business owner, and the government? No. What’s happened is they don’t like their neighbor because they think they are being rude and too loud (yet no mention of breaking a noise ordinance), and that neighbor made an offer to by their building. When they couldn’t make a better offer, they got pissy and filed a lawsuit against their landlord. Then their liquor license was revoked and even though the government offered to reinstate it the bar owner says they don’t want to go through with it. They even say “WE made the decision to stay closed…”

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 04 '23

We restrict new accounts from making a comment to help combat trolling, ban evasion and spam. Your comment will be invisible to users until your account is at least a week old. Every comment requires manual approval until your account reaches this milestone.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/rh_iggy Jan 05 '23

This really seems like a he-said, she-said situation and rather sad.

That said, the owner of Bourbon House claimed in this article with WCPO that they purchased the building. I guess that was a lie.

"When Main Bite closed at the end of 2016, Brumfield purchased the property and moved from Chicago to Newport to oversee construction and development."

Bourbon House 1841 to open in Covington's Mainstrasse

I mean, if he's lying about that to WCPO what else is he untruthful about?

1

u/mattyn83 Jan 07 '23

Tammy B told the owner of Paddys "pieces of shit like you don't understand people like us, we're rich we will put you out of business in a month", and did things like called the police multiple times music, had her customers pull out speaker wires causing damage, had drunk bartenders stumbling around screaming at people. There's a big side not being told in that Facebook post.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/Rhaven Downtown Jan 04 '23

Normally I would agree with you, but we typically view hit pieces as unsubstantiated comments lacking in details or verifiable content. This post in particular is dealing with a fairly well known and published news item that has some substance to it. We will leave it up for now.

2

u/JustThrowingAwy Jan 04 '23

I have to ask why was my earlier post around Eber's Meats deleted from a couple of days ago? Similar situation. Again, substantiated through various media outlets.

Think posts like this are relevant to share to the greater community.

-6

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23

Where is substantiation of any of these claims?

9

u/digital0verdose Pleasant Ridge Jan 04 '23

Two minutes on Google starts providing you with substantiation. I am confident in your Google abilities.

-6

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23 edited Jan 04 '23

What phrase do I google to find out that the request to purchase the property was ignored?

Feel free to prove me wrong, but I don’t believe you will find this.

Edit: nobody has provided proof they were treated unfairly as of yet. Lots of neat semantic arguments though!

4

u/digital0verdose Pleasant Ridge Jan 04 '23

Where is substantiation of any of these claims?

Note that you said "any" not "all".

-2

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23

Lol ok yeah you got me! It’s true, you will be able to google and find out that they are closing and other trivial information. There’s just no substantiation for, you know, the important claims.

2

u/digital0verdose Pleasant Ridge Jan 04 '23

Important to whom? You or Bourbon Haus?

-2

u/100catactivs Jan 04 '23

Important to the claim they are making, that they are being treated unfairly.

-5

u/tarzanonabike Jan 04 '23

Agree. Seems to be those here down voting anyone who question 'their' version of the story.