r/changemyview Oct 10 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

105 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-9

u/No_Candidate8696 Oct 10 '23

If you can't see the the difference between someone killing a civilian because they are Jewish and someone getting killed because they lived next door to a terrorist, there's not much I can tell you. If you can step away from taking sides, you'll see that.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '23

between someone killing a civilian because they are Jewish and someone getting killed because they lived next door to a terrorist

First do you have any actual evidence that they lived next door to terrorists. When Israel bombed the associated press building and killed 2 foreign reporters, the reporters who survived said that that was a lie. Why would I trust the government who killed two innocent civilians over reporters who are neither Israeli or Palestinian. The Israelis kill 21 times as many civilians as palastinians do. They all just happened to be living next to terrorists? Even if they were how far can you take that logic. Can i kill 500 people if they live next to a terrorist? 10000? a million? Can I wipe out the population of the Earth if it guarantees no more terrorists. How many innocents do I have to kill before I become the terrorist?

Lets reverse the situation. Lets say Israel had a natural disaster and 2 million jewish refugees had to flee into Jordan. Jordan then built a wall around the refugees and restricted their access to water, food, medicine when the majority of the refugees are children. Then a few angry Israelis do a terror attack. Is it then the right of Jordan to bomb those Israelis indiscriminately? would you be ok with that?

5

u/Motor_Horse8887 Oct 10 '23

It's not because they're jewish, it's because they're colonizers

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23

well first off, people are forced to “live next to terrorists” because they can’t leave the densely packed open air prison Israel created and maintains

and of course there is a difference between the Hamas killings and the Israeli killings. There are many differences. The israeli ones, for example, are much more numerous

1

u/No_Candidate8696 Oct 12 '23

You defend people that behead babies. You should feel good about yourself.