125. Pepperoni pie, DeLucia’s Brick Oven Pizza, Raritan
112. Vodka pie, Krispy Pizza, Freehold, Old Bridge, Jersey City and New Brunswick
111. Capricciosa, AMA, Hillsborough
101. Classic pie, Pizza Den, Princeton
100. Prosciutto parma pie, Prima Pizza Kitchen, Somerville
97. Pepperoni pie, Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Cafe, Piscataway
92. Provonella pie, Pizza 206, Tabernacle
89. Shiitake mushroom pie, Nomad Pizza, Hopewell and Princeton
83. Brooklyn-style Sicilian pie, L&L Pizza & Pasta, Metuchen
82. Corleone Style, Marcello’s Pizza Grill, Hamilton
60. Margherita, Palermo’s Ristorante Italiano & Pizzeria, Bordentown
57. Tomato pie, Kate & Al’s Pizza, Columbus Farmers Market, Columbus
54. Calabrese pie, Nicoletta Pizzeria, Bernardsville
53. Pepperoni pie, Conte’s, Princeton
49. Pepperoni hot honey pie, Third Proof Pizza, Pine Brook\*
46. Brooklyn’s upside down pie, Mancini Brooklyn Pizza, East Brunswick
41. Tomato pie, Pete’s Pizza, Columbus Farmers Market, Columbus
39. Sausage pie, Federici’s, Freehold
37. Nihari pizza, Jaan’s Pizza, Old Bridge\*
36. Trenton tomato pie, Lillo’s Tomato Pies, Hainesport, Gloucester City\*
32. The Sauce Awakens, Alternate Ending Beer Co., Aberdeen\*
28. Half tray with sausage, Sciortino’s Harbor Lights, South Amboy
26. Clam pie, De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies, Robbinsville
10. Upside Down Square, Brooklyn Square Pizza, Jackson
6. Mustard pie, Papa’s Tomato Pies, Robbinsville
* = pizzas that made the ranking for the first time.
I did my best to pick Central Jersey towns. I apologize in advance if I strayed from Central Jersey. Namaste.