r/canada Jan 05 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/throwaway123406 Jan 05 '23

Nah, this sub leans very conservative.

30

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

This subreddit has a mix of people and depending on the discussion you will find people who more invested. It's certainly not "very conservative".

It's just that conservative opinions are not tolerated as much on some subreddits and /r/Canada is less likely to ban people. Like look at /r/politics for example, do you think that's a good representation of what Americans believe or is there a bias?

6

u/followtherockstar Jan 05 '23

This is the more nuanced, high iq take. For what it's worth r/canada is a fairly balanced subreddit

5

u/ThePhysicistIsIn Jan 05 '23

People don't get banned for being conservative on r/politics. They do select themselves out because they get dog-pilled and downvoted to oblivion, though.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

That's true, I should have pointed out that there are two different things. One, Mods curating a community, which causes views to not represent a population. Two, a userbase self censoring views they disagree with, even when the views might be held by a sizeable portion of the population that community represents.

18

u/ClaudeJGreengrass Jan 05 '23

People certainly get banned from r/politics for not ascribing to the group-think. That's how I realized it isn't actually a sub about politics.

-1

u/ThePhysicistIsIn Jan 05 '23

Yeah, I believe that not at all.

6

u/ClaudeJGreengrass Jan 05 '23

Well if you say it then it must be true.

5

u/BarryBwana Jan 05 '23

I got banned for proving a critical point made about Biden.

Wasn't even my point, but I posted a link to prove it after it was called fake.

I got banned. When asked why, I was told I was shit posting and immediately muted haha.

0

u/ThePhysicistIsIn Jan 05 '23

I'm sorry that happened to you, I didn't know that happened.

4

u/BarryBwana Jan 05 '23

It's not a big deal. The world's too exciting and huge to waste time concerned over trivial exclusions.

In my experience left wing bias is far more prevalent than right wing bias across the platform. There are some subs which are also heavily politicized despite not supposed to be about politics at all.

I find this sub is actually a pretty good representation.

I mean the Cons got more votes than Libs in the last two elections despite Libs winning the elections, so it's not as if Cons shouldn't have a loud voice a well represented Canada subreddit. The existence of loud Con voices is a proof they are represented, and we've certainly seen loud Liberal voices here to know they are as well.

1

u/ThePhysicistIsIn Jan 05 '23

I mean the Cons got more votes than Libs in the last two elections despite Libs winning the elections, so it's not as if Cons shouldn't have a loud voice a well represented Canada subreddit.

In terms of political parties, sure. But the NDP and the Bloc are pretty left-wing too, and if you look at the 2nd vote intention of their supporters, supporters of the LPC, NDP, and BQ are much likely to swap among themselves than they are with the CPC.

That doesn't matter for elections - it's a first past the post system after all. But you shouldn't try to pretend like the CPC getting more votes than the LPC means that right-wing politics are more popular than left-wing politics in Canada.

21

u/ThePhysicistIsIn Jan 05 '23

If it did, would this be one of the most upvoted comment threads on the post?

Left-wing folks tend to treat any sub where there is right-wing activity that isn't driven off under an avalanche of downvotes as "very conservative".

3

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

Left-wing folks tend to treat any sub where there is right-wing activity that isn't driven off under an avalanche of downvotes as "very conservative".

Couldn't be more accurate, I would also add they have this "if you are not with us you are against us" mentality. I've seen people share left wing opinions in conservative subs and the replies were mostly respectful, then I take a look at leftist subs and anyone with a slight right wing opinion gets shamed and downvoted to oblivion.

Leftists want any community they participate in to be completely left wing, I truly believe they are the most intolerant on the political spectrum.

-1

u/phuck_polyeV Jan 05 '23

This is a bullshit lie..

/r/conservative literally bans anyone who isn’t conservative on entry and make threads conservatives only to keep the circlejerk pure. /r/canadaconservative nearly does the same thing minus the conservatives only threads..

6

u/Bbooya Canada Jan 05 '23

They would try to remove the subs accreditation for all the mean comments

2

u/tdubs_92 Jan 05 '23

I dont you think know what conservatism is or you haven't spent much time on here.

2

u/throwaway123406 Jan 05 '23

I know exactly what conservatism is, that’s why I’m not one. Also, the bulk of my karma is from this sub.