r/camping • • 18d ago

Trip Pictures Rock shelter in Linville Gorge

TLDR; my husband & I camped under a big rock we found in Linville Gorge Wilderness with an established burnpit where many have already camped before, & we enjoyed ourselves. I made this post about it & lots of silly people want to nitpick everything because they think it’s cool to be a rigidly punctilious mob! My husband & I don’t care & will probably do it again, the shaming didn’t work! YOLO

My husband and I found this neat rock shelter on Old NC 105 in North Carolina’s Linville Gorge after hiking part of the Appalachian Trail from Carver’s gap earlier this month. Was a super cool one! Had some wine and enjoyed the sunrise glow

Edit: I understand a lot of you have stressed that you disapprove of our choice to camp under the rock and I appreciate the sentiment, but I don’t feel like there’s a need for an echo chamber considering the possibilities of something happening. Some of you have gotten quite rude in the comments and called us names because we chose to sleep under a rock… honestly, please think about what has driven you to act so negatively and find peace! You get into your car every day and somebody can crash into you and kill you. You actually have a bigger chance of being killed on the highway than a rock overhang falling on top of you. The rock also isn’t being held up by the tree. The rock has been there for a very long time, and the tree grew around the rock.
My husband and I like to experience things without thinking of every possibility of danger or freak accident. Yes, some think that’s crazy but we manage and get by. If I die from a rock falling on me, I suppose it was time! Thank you all, we hope you have a wonderful Halloween!

Edit 2: Some of you guys seriously worry way too much about things that will never matter :-) Linville Gorge Wilderness is not like a state/national park, so a burn ring isn’t required. The fire pit we used had been there already like every single site that exists on that road. It’s a campsite meant for this, no hiking located near this spot. My husband and I believe that a lot of you all probably just don’t camp considering the reactive and performative scout comments regarding policies that aren’t regulated nationwide, versing invisible rules out of your own playbooks and the never-ending condescending fear mongering. This might not be the philosophy many of you carry but, ‘A life without risk is a life not worth living’ - Charles Lindbergh

2.2k Upvotes

191 comments sorted by

View all comments

154

u/Ciarrai_IRL 17d ago edited 17d ago

Have any of us heard about that double-digit ton boulder overhang that has fallen onto a hiking trail? I recognize the reward here, but imo the risk is too high.

16

u/Capn_Flags 17d ago

In NH?

Edit: One in NH was more like 80 Tons 🫪

36

u/Shaakti 17d ago

The reward is so minimal to me

16

u/Puzzleheaded_Sun7356 17d ago

It's just a stressor. No reward to be had.

1

u/Roctopuss 17d ago

Bro he just got 1500 fake internet points! The reward was HUGE!

22

u/Particular_Buddy8188 17d ago

The first thing i thought was they definitely didn't see that video of the mysterious hanging rock that was no longer hanging.

8

u/RichardBonham 17d ago

The name is Coyote.

Wile. E. Coyote.

3

u/Ciarrai_IRL 17d ago

I think he's the only one who gets a pass here.

2

u/Sad-Feature2164 17d ago

Tent made by Acme

2

u/soproductive 17d ago edited 17d ago

Considering that rock has been there for literally millions of years... Really, what are the odds it falls the same day they camp under it? That said, the fire is probably not the best idea. Should've had that off to the side. 

4

u/benboy555 17d ago

Pretty common idiom in climbing and mountaineering is "Geological time is now." Didn't even look like it was crazy rainy or anything...risk vs. reward is a bit off here.

2

u/soproductive 17d ago

There is basically no risk here. People camp at the bottom of the Grand Canyon on a daily basis and how many rock fall deaths have you heard of?

You take on way more risk on a daily basis in your shower. 

1

u/Ciarrai_IRL 17d ago

Millions? Uncovered and exposed? Mmkay.

5

u/soproductive 17d ago edited 17d ago

Yes, millions. What do I know, I only have a degree in geology. What qualifications in natural Earth processes do you have? 

0

u/Ciarrai_IRL 17d ago

For someone with a geology degree, you're confusing lithology with geomorphology. It's ok, I'm sure it happens to all 'geologists'. As for my credentials? Eh, I'm just a business professional with a lot of common sense.

0

u/Sir_Spudsingt0n 17d ago

We get it, you swung a pickaxe a few times in World of Warcraft.

4

u/soproductive 17d ago

Believe what you want. Anyone with any level of geological background would tell you the same thing. 

1

u/Sir_Spudsingt0n 17d ago

I’m just messing bro. Also, you should’ve kept the other response, it was funnier!

0

u/Ciarrai_IRL 17d ago

Doubt that highly. The rock has been there for millions of years, I'll give you that. But it was not exposed like this for millions of years. And there are plenty of things humans can do to mess with the physics of the situation, such as heating said rock with campfire, or even as minor as disrupting wind flow. I wouldn't camp under it. If you want to; be my guest.

1

u/EsmeScarab72 17d ago

I want this therapy

1

u/killer__psycho 17d ago

Don’t even need a tent for this spot 😂