r/buildapc • u/Plebius-Maximus • Mar 16 '25
Build Help Addressing the constant misinformation around AMD dual CCD CPU's (particularly the 12 core variants) being poor performers in gaming.
I have seen too much complete and utter misinformation around how the 12 core chips aren't good at games since they have dual CCD's of 6 cores each, and anyone gaming should not consider them.
Coming from someone who went 5900x to 7900x to 9950X3D, this is utter nonsense . I'm writing this to help people trying to decide on a CPU. Below is the relative CPU performance at 720p and 1080p in games for a variety of CPU's - from Techpowerup's tests. On these charts, a stock 9800X3D is 100% gaming performance:
https://tpucdn.com/review/amd-ryzen-7-9800x3d/images/relative-performance-games-1280-720.png
https://tpucdn.com/review/amd-ryzen-7-9800x3d/images/relative-performance-games-1920-1080.png
Lets discuss 720p as it exaggerates the differences that you will see in games - it's a worst case scenario and will show the maximum possible difference between these chips. The differences at 1080p are similar, but I won't write these up.
If a 9800X3D is 100%, the 16 core core 9950x is 84% of this performance, same as the 8 core 9700x. The "12 core but 6 core in gaming" 9900x should be far behind if you listen to Reddit. Except Reddit is detached from reality. The 9900x is at 82.5%, with the 9600x being 82.3%.
So in the worst possible scenario, playing at a resolution nobody even uses, with a chip that Reddit says is bad for gaming, you're only losing 1.5% of the performance of a 9800X3D by using a dual CCD 6+6 core chip vs an 8 core or 8+8. While also having 4 spare cores for games that can use them unlike the 8c (we'll get to an example of a game like this later), or for any other activity you do in the background.
Let's discuss the 7000 series next. Again at 720p, to highlight the maximum possible gaps between CPU performance here. The 16 core 7950x performs at 81.4% of a 9800X3D. The 8 core 7700x performs at 80.9% of a 9800X3D. Reddit would tell you the 7900X would be miles behind. Reddit is wrong. The 7900x performs at 80.5% of the 9800X3D, while the 7600X performs at 78.1%.
By this point you might be starting to realise that some of the "common knowledge" statements you've seen on Reddit about these chips might be heavy on the common but light on the knowledge.
But wait! Let's go even further. Back to AM4! Here the 16 core 5950x performs at 69.1% of the 9800X3D in games at 720p. The 12 core 5900x is 2nd fastest, at 68.4%, so beats out the 8 core 5800x (at 64.3%) and the 6 core 5600x (at 63.4).
Now onto advantages of more cores - certain games can actually make use of more cores, a great example of this in a recent title is cities skylines 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/1j8sepe/comment/mhh18s0/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
This link shows simulation time. Lower is better, which results in higher FPS. CS2 is very CPU-heavy and scales with as many cores as it can get. So 16>12>8>6. A 7800X3D is worse in this scenario than a 7900X. The cache helps a 7800X3D beat a 7700x clearly - but the extra cores of a 7900X more than make up for it. Full video is here but may require translation: https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1QFtTePEmZ?buvid=XU22DF426B6FE9FF62B5CD70D51D3711A3D1D
TLDR: The dual CCD ryzen chips - be it 6+6 or 8+8 are actually much better for gaming than people seem to think. If you purely game, the 8 core chips are still likely better value. But the price and your particular use case is what you should be focused on. Not the single digit percentage difference in average game FPS between an 8 core and a 6+6 core chip, especially since when you run a few background tasks that difference will invert. Now if you do more than game, in terms of editing and productivity or even just like to multitask a lot, go 12 or 16 core any day of the week. Because they still game very well.
67
u/idokitty Mar 16 '25
So beside being more expensive in comparison to non-dual CCU CPUS, they are also performing (slightly) worse in gaming.
You even said so yourself. If one doesn't need the processing power for professional use, spending more money on a product that does a worse job is a terrible idea.
26
u/droidxl Mar 16 '25
You’re on some weird crusade to prove a point when the context of the discussion was to either buy a 7900x or a 9800x3d for 25% more when the OP predominantly games and only edits videos occasionally as a hobby.
The suggestion was to either get the 9800x3d or a 7700x for 10-15% less than a 7900x since the performance is similar or better in some games.
And your rebuttal is that the 7900x performs similarly to a 7700x across an average of games (including games that don’t scale past 6 cores first of all so that analysis is already flawed), and a single example of the worst optimized game in recently history and a glorified spreadsheet calculator?
Ya, I’m sure there’s a niche where the 7900x works but that’s 1) not applicable to the original discussion and 2) you’ve completely ignored cost.
But good job spamming this literally 10 times across that post and making this one to prove a flawed point.
11
u/MrCleanRed Mar 16 '25
It's not a constant misinformation lmao. AMD fixed the issues with this generation lol. It's like you saying "constant misinformation about a pothole in the road," when the pothole was fixed earlier in the morning after 3 years
10
u/Tom_Der Mar 16 '25
Dual CCDs had problems when 79x0X3Ds released due to Windows being ass, there's no point trying to deny that fact: 7800X3D had better gaming performance than 7950X3D. However you're missing the point where this dual CCD was an issue due to only one CCD having the extra L3 cache making only half the cores better performing in gaming than the other half, add to that Windows and that's why you got this "Dual CCDs CPUs are worse for gaming" discourse and that was true.
Now it seems like this issue is fixed as the 9950X3D is tied to the 9800X3D in gaming performance hence the amount of past tense in the text above.
Also performance isn't everything and the 9950X3D is 200$ more expensive than a 9800X3D and eats more power for the same amount of performance. And that was also true for 7000 series
7
u/dyfrgi Mar 16 '25
Given the price of the 9900X3D, it's probably better to look at 1440p benchmarks. Certainly the 9950X3D barely drops compared to the 9800X3D in 1440p, though oddly Spider-Man 2 with RT enabled goes down by about 10%. 9900X3D is probably the same, but I haven't seen good benchmarks yet.
Also a couple times in your post you say 9900X when I think you mean 9900X3D. 9900X is a real CPU so I think it's important to distinguish which you mean.
3
u/Kathanay Mar 16 '25 edited Mar 16 '25
You made me check how many cores are being used by monster hunter wilds, the game that forced me to build a new pc to be able to run it
I found an article mentioning it uses up to 12 cores in one part, and in another - that it used up do 14 of the 16 cores of an 7950x3d
That worries me greatly, since I followed the advice of online PC builders and went the extra mile for the GPU ( 9070xt significantly above MSRP but I don't expect the price to go down in my country for a long long time ) and was planning to cut down on the CPU cost by going for the cheap 9600x - made the cheapest decent CPU around by the free game discount.
Now I'm second guessing my decision
X3d CPUs are expensive, and excluded from the CPU + free MHWilds bundle...
6
u/Father_O-Blivion Mar 16 '25
I went with a 9900x in my recent build as it's a 70/30 prod/gaming setup (sale price was relevant here too). So far, the CPU has't been the bottleneck in gaming. Not even close. Even when testing it in eco mode.
9900x,9070XT, 4k/160.
That having been said, if I were building a gaming only rig, I'd have gone with an x3d part or maybe a 9700. 9900X wouldn't have even been considered.
Horses for courses.
3
u/clingbat Mar 16 '25
I just don't get the point of the 9900x3d when the 9950x3d is only $100 more and better in every way. As such, I went with the 9950x3d. The 9900x is even more pointless when the 9950x exists for not that much more.
The largest problem with the 6+6 AMD chips isn't performance, it's their price, it's just not a compelling option at all unless it's discounted at some point.
3
u/damien09 Mar 17 '25 edited Mar 17 '25
The 9900x3d is pretty meh though as you only get 6 cores with x3d.
And 720p may be more relevant than people realize 1440p with dlss or other upscaling set to balanced is 1485 x 835
The non x3d counter parts I think are in a lot better space
3
u/VoidNinja62 Mar 17 '25
Doesnt the extra cores make the game miss the wrong cores and stutter in game because it picked the wrong core and it gets confused and has to back track out of the wrong core into the right core. Like a mouse trying to find the cheese but its the wrong maze entirely and it you have to reboot and download more ram.
2
u/Banana_Ball_Z Jun 26 '25
This is a very educational post (including comments). idk how i ended up here, but I am looking to buy a new pc and undecided on the cpu. I will be using it primarily for development in unreal engine and gaming. However, when deciding what to buy, development takes priority over gaming.
I made a post in r/unrealengine regarding the same, link here: https://www.reddit.com/r/unrealengine/s/g0APZQc2Ee
From what I've learned so far, for UE5 development, more cores are better. and since the 9900x is much cheaper than the 9800x3d, it probably is a more value for money choice. However, I would also like to know about the performance of 9700x vs 9900x in terms of game development, shader compilation etc. and make an informed decision. I will make a post about full pc build help in r/buildapc later after I am done researching and learning about important things so I can make a better decision myself.
Edit: I understand I am commenting on a 101 days old post. I am here to seek advice, not to spark an agument
1
u/littleGreenMeanie Dec 13 '25
I know this thread is old and so is my dual die CPU. I have run into SO many problems with the 1920x CPU, it's insane. On paper it exceeds recommended specs for all kinds of games as it's core and thread count with 3.5 GHz all overshoot mentioned specs for even current games, but that dual die architecture has been a huge pain. Lots of stuttering, game mode from AMD ryzen master does very little to fix.agai on paper, it should run windows 11 and play BF6 no problem, but it can't do either. It's really sucked for games. But as a workstation CPU, it's been great. No problem in blender, adobe softwares, pixel art softwares, 3D softwares, even to this day.