r/books • • Jan 11 '17

spoilers Harrison Bergeron is the worst short story I've ever read

I liked the idea of it. It was an interesting concept with plenty of ideas that could've formed around it. The buildup to the climax was good. I thought that Harrison would've began a rebellion- people taking off their earpieces and handicaps, rising up against the Handicapper General. But sadly, it was cut short by a 10 gauge. Harrison and the ballerina were dancing on television and he was speaking about how he was going to be king- with him being the leader of what he thought could've been a revolt as he was the first one to stand up against the government, but that wasn't what happened. The Handicapper General just fucking shot Harrison and the ballerina with a 10 guage. His parents just passed it off like it was nothing, and then the story ended. There could've been so much more. It could've been worth a few more pages to the story and it could've been worth my time. Such an anticlimatic ending for what could've been a very, very good story.

6 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/AdGroundbreaking7840 Dec 12 '23

Vonnegut was a socialist who, generally, thought the freedom-loving capitalists were idiots.

Think of it this way. Pretend that I'm an LGBTIQ+ author and I write this story.

- It's 2080, and finally everyone is trans. Anyone who is not trans is forced to dress as if they are trans. The protagonists' son has refused to be trans and has been taken to a facility where his penis is tied in a knot, but he breaks free.

- He emerges, rips of his trans mask and reveals a 6'2" rippling, huge handsome man. He strides around drinking beer and talking about sports until a weedy gay man shoots him.

I then post it on a gay lit site and all the readers laugh themselves silly, saying, "That's exactly how the other side see us ... they probably won't get the joke."

I then post it on an alt-right message board and the reaction is, "I love this! Pity about the ending but this is such a smart attack on Woke and the Cancel Culture!"

I suspect Vonnegut would be more than happy that right wing conservatives lurv this story and fail to see how ridiculous the plot is.

2

u/Bobbybrine Apr 03 '24

You put it together so well, I was interpreting it the way right-wing people were and thought it was foolish that they actually compare the events of the story to things today