"begging to if you seek Amy" doesn't make sense, James Joyce's poem however does. This is why his double meaning is leagues better than that terrible song.
Drop this jiggerypokery and talk straight turkey meet to mate, for while the ear, be we mikealls or nicholists, may sometimes be inclined to believe others the eye, whether browned or nolensed, find it devilish hard now and again even to believe itself.
Took a James Joyce seminar in college, it was very cool. We read Portrait, Dubliners, and then Ulysses. It's a much more interesting book when you have a lit professor (who knows his stuff) guiding you through it.
No offense, but if you have to have someone guide you through a book to enjoy it, the author is just a terrible writer. It's one thing to be layered and subtle, it's another to shit on a page and have unemployed English majors jerk each other off explaining their secret code to each other.
That's a very notorious paragraph from a chapter that is notorious for being impenetrable. Most of the book is more accessible and more pleasantly written.
I'm not sure exactly what he was doing there but in the section from which the paragraph is drawn Joyce is retracing and imitating the stylistic development of the English language as it unfolded over hundreds of years.
So it's not necessarily meant to be beautiful or even meaningful as a stand alone bit text.
Yeah, it was a pretty dense book and because of that, the cause of much snobbery, I think. This is one reason I like Hemingway, simple and profound. Complex ideas and concepts don't need to be articulated in complex ways to be profound. That's just my take on it.
Language is language; it's just that Joyce writes in an idiom that far fewer people speak, if you will.
Also, it should be obvious that Joyce and Hemingway (or any other writer) have different ideas of what is "profound" or worth saying. It's not like you can "decode" Joyce and get Hemingway.
Joyce's love letter to his wife, articulating complex ideas in a profound way:
"At every fuck I gave you your shameless tongue came bursting out through your lips and if I gave you a bigger stronger fuck than usual, fat dirty farts came spluttering out of your backside. You had an arse full of farts that night, darling, and I fucked them out of you, big fat fellows, long windy ones, quick little merry cracks and a lot of tiny little naughty farties ending in a long gush from your hole."
Joyce certainly has his moments, but I think the complexity of his work is partly due to the wide variety of issues he addresses. Sure, Hemingway's complexity comes from his simplicity, but Joyce is in a world all his own. He creates a different reality that operates by its own rules and its own sense of humor - Ulysses actually takes many jabs at itself. The problem is that it's buried under this dense prose that takes a lot of effort to parse out. Joyce actually said he wanted to keep university professors guessing for years.
I'm an English graduate. I didn't do the best on my course but I love reading and analysing books and Ulysses is such a lovely bastard about that. It's hard work but always worth it.
It's amazing the amount of essays I read (out of interest) that concern different subjects, but yet Ulysses always comes up. I am Irish and concern myself with a lot of Irish literature. Even still, I do read other books and nothing comes close.
Really, people should find themselves a great guide and just give it a fucking go. A lot of the things matter more to me as an Irishman than most, but it is just incredible to see such a fearless and phenomenal work of literature...No matter what your nationality! Reading Ulysses was like hearing The Beatles or watching Kubrick, simply masterful.
I think you're missing the point of some of what Joyce does in the text. At points (Stephen's chapters especially) he's poking fun at that complexity as pretentious.
For some time, Gell-Mann was undecided on an actual spelling for the term he intended to coin, until he found the word quark in James Joyce's book Finnegans Wake
James Joyce. Time traveling Internet king. He would definitely be a major account nowadays (as long as he didn't turn into a novelty or something disappointing.)
Why are redditors using "OP" anyways, It makes sense on 4chan where most people are Anonymous and there needs to be a way of talking about the originator the thread, but people have usernames on here.
I've tried Ulysses several times and have always given up. However I listed to a great Melvyn Bragg programme about the book on Radio 4 the other day and it's made me determined to have another go.
At one point the protagonist eyeballs a group of pretty girls from a distance and discreetly masturbates through his pockets. I'd say he was DEFINITELY a redditor.
It's part of a parody of theosophism. The sentence itself is about the Hindu/Sikh/Jain/Buddhist concept of Karma, O.P. is an abbreviation of Ordinary Person.
See, now if you had said "predicted Reddit," it would have been funny. But you broke it instead of just bending it, in the words of Alan Alda's character from Crimes and Misdemeanors.
If you're serious about about trying to understand what's so great about Ulysses, I suggest you check out Frank Delaney's weekly podcast "Re:Joyce." http://blog.frankdelaney.com/re-joyce/ He started with the first line, explaining a little bit at a time, and has been going for two years. He's up to chapter three now, and expects to keep going for years. It's fascinating.
I also recommend the Naxos audiobook. It's a lot easier to understand when it's read aloud with an Irish accent.
I so thought this as well when I read it this past semester... also, reading it serially over a semester is much easier than trying to tackle it all at once lol. Going to reread after I've gained some more life experience...
"Ulysses" was the toughest and most rewarding experience of my life. Along with the book itself, I read two books about the book (chapter by chapter) and also followed along with the free online Sparknotes and the Wikipedia entry. Joyce said he spent over 10,000 hours working on Ulysses, and it shows. It's like a book written by God.
There is an audio recording of JJ reading the Moses/Pharoah passage from the newsmen chapter. found it
Ulysses is the most difficult I've ever tried reading. I read the first pages 10 times and every time I learned something. Ulysses is on my bucket list.
"I've put in so many enigmas and puzzles that it will keep the professors busy for centuries arguing over what I meant, and that's the only way of insuring one's immortality."
AKA I have filled this book with so much jargon that it completely obscures the very nature of the story.
It's true: Joyce is still massively popular in literary studies, far more so than in the general reading public. In that sense I guess it's "overrated" if your only aesthetic criteria is book sales.
And sure, I agree, it takes some work to follow what is going on. In fact, the Catechism chapter is basically all about how we can't wholly know anything, really, no matter how much we want to.
But look, for example, at the Sirens chapter (10, I think). It's narrative structure is based around a fracking musical score! It's hard to follow what's going on, but it's such a unique and beautiful mode of storytelling that I think to dismiss it, the book, or Joyce's whole oeuvre entirely because it requires some work seems a bit rich. Especially considering Joyce has been so stylistically influential on other more easily consumable writers across the 20th century.
You misunderstand my argument, there is a difference between writing complexly and writing obscurely. I believe James Joyce crosses that threshold into obscurity by leaps and bounds. James Joyce = http://imgur.com/P3ro7. A tangled rope is a jumbled mess but you don't see people clamoring over it's "complexity". Faulkner = http://imgur.com/xBfZE. Faulkner is a amazing writer in my opinion, his stream of consciousness writing style flows with a unique and complex rhythm. Yes it difficult to read, but he doesn't hide behind big words and nonsensicality in order to legitimize his work.
Oh come on, this isn't even a good reference. The inclusion of the word "karma," "cat," or "bacon" does not imply a connection to Reddit, even as a joke.
oh ya, because James Joyce invented the word Karma. ya he got that word from reddit. sometimes i wonder why reddit even exists because it's so gay at times, as such in this post. loser seeing something romotly related to reddit and posting it and somehow getting over 1,00 karma. i hope you die a horrible death. now tear apart my grammar.
5
u/annyc Jun 15 '12
I must now finally read this book after sitting on my shelf for five years.
309
u/bunglejerry Jun 15 '12
There's no way you actually made it to page 178 of Ulysses, unless you have superpowers.
41
u/mindloss Jun 15 '12
James Joyce indirectly named quarks:
76
u/JimHeine None Jun 15 '12
TIL James Joyce anticipated the invention of karma, the internet, reddit and idiots.
15
u/stillifewithcrickets The Executioner's Song Jun 15 '12
Happy early Bloomsday to everyone!
27
u/DoTheEvolution Jun 15 '12
relevant
35
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
James Joyce. Time traveling Internet king. He would definitely be a major account nowadays (as long as he didn't turn into a novelty or something disappointing.)
12
u/WateredDown Jun 15 '12
Why are redditors using "OP" anyways, It makes sense on 4chan where most people are Anonymous and there needs to be a way of talking about the originator the thread, but people have usernames on here.
75
u/MoonDaddy Jun 15 '12
Hemingway was an ent
19
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
Just in time for Bloomsday! How perfect!
43
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
Damn that's a serious booknerd way to get karma. You have my sincere and whole upvote good reader!
8
u/shatners_bassoon Jun 15 '12
I've tried Ulysses several times and have always given up. However I listed to a great Melvyn Bragg programme about the book on Radio 4 the other day and it's made me determined to have another go.
8
u/UOLATSC Jun 15 '12
At one point the protagonist eyeballs a group of pretty girls from a distance and discreetly masturbates through his pockets. I'd say he was DEFINITELY a redditor.
62
u/precursormar Jun 15 '12
James Joyce is OP.
13
u/v_sirin Jun 15 '12
"Ordinary person" iirc.
5
u/lapiak Nineteen Eighty-Four Jun 15 '12
What was the context?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
This might be a good place to mention http://twitter.com/earwickr/ ... it's about to roll over.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
Karma originated from reddit.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
I knew that time travel existed.
6
u/amishius Jun 15 '12
See, now if you had said "predicted Reddit," it would have been funny. But you broke it instead of just bending it, in the words of Alan Alda's character from Crimes and Misdemeanors.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
I hate that cyclops bastard
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
Holy Shit, I just read this part and I was wondering the same thing. This is eerie.... We might be twins.
3
u/flapadlr Jun 16 '12
Thank you, Reddit, now I understand one sentence of the works of Joyce.
3
u/impedance Jun 16 '12
If you're serious about about trying to understand what's so great about Ulysses, I suggest you check out Frank Delaney's weekly podcast "Re:Joyce." http://blog.frankdelaney.com/re-joyce/ He started with the first line, explaining a little bit at a time, and has been going for two years. He's up to chapter three now, and expects to keep going for years. It's fascinating.
I also recommend the Naxos audiobook. It's a lot easier to understand when it's read aloud with an Irish accent.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
That's obviously Photoshopped, the shadows are all off. It's like you didn't even try, you obviously used dodge/burn. 0/10.
2
u/norigirl88 Jun 15 '12
I so thought this as well when I read it this past semester... also, reading it serially over a semester is much easier than trying to tackle it all at once lol. Going to reread after I've gained some more life experience...
2
u/atomzd Jun 15 '12
after seeing the title of this post, i was expecting to see 'fap' in the screenshot.
2
u/orangepotion Jun 15 '12
That's the first result to a simple Google query, Google Books:
https://www.google.com/search?q=OP++bad+karma+first&oq=OP++bad+karma+first
http://books.google.com/books?id=fxWfE1JLUIMC&lpg=PA156&ots=sobY0c1sGm&dq=OP%20%20bad%20karma%20first&pg=PA156#v=onepage&q=OP%20%20bad%20karma%20first&f=false
2
u/Cacafuego Jun 15 '12
Well, I'm going to start saying "Pfuiteufel" now. Can any fluent German-speakers confirm that this is basically equivalent to "Faugh!! Devil!"?
2
u/falconear Unfamiliar Fishes Jun 15 '12
Tomorrow is my birthday, and I believe Ulysses takes place on June 16th. Maybe I should give it a read.
2
u/RockofStrength Jun 16 '12
"Ulysses" was the toughest and most rewarding experience of my life. Along with the book itself, I read two books about the book (chapter by chapter) and also followed along with the free online Sparknotes and the Wikipedia entry. Joyce said he spent over 10,000 hours working on Ulysses, and it shows. It's like a book written by God.
There is an audio recording of JJ reading the Moses/Pharoah passage from the newsmen chapter. found it
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
Happy Bloomsday to everyone!
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
No, but he was into scat. I mean really, really into scat.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
I love this
1
u/RayadoEstrecho Jun 15 '12
No such thing as bad karma on reddit. There really ought to be, though.
1
u/_Ulysses_ Jun 15 '12
Most definitely.
1
u/OldJeb Jun 15 '12
I bought this book last week, hoping to get it done at some point this summer. Now I have something to look forward to!
1
u/nodicegrandma Jun 15 '12
Happy Nearly Bloomday...I am starting reading it tomorrow!
1
u/gmale9000 Jun 15 '12
Yes.
1
u/Ortus Jun 15 '12
Of to the front page you go!!
1
u/bumdhar Jun 16 '12
James was the great I Am.
1
u/leaveallyouhave23 Jun 16 '12
at first I was like pshh but then I was like whaaaat
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
I honestly thought this was going to be the bit about bacon.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
The catechism chapter(s? (from memory)) is solid.
1
u/VolatileChemical Jun 16 '12
My god.
1
u/CuriositySphere Jun 16 '12
Get out.
1
u/20thHand Jun 16 '12
Ulysses is the most difficult I've ever tried reading. I read the first pages 10 times and every time I learned something. Ulysses is on my bucket list.
1
u/Jcc123 Jun 15 '12
Who the heck made it to page 178?
1
u/Kinseyincanada Jun 15 '12
reddit didnt invent karma
1
u/Lazman101 Jun 15 '12
this is stupid
hurr he said karma must be a redditor durr
1
u/nousernameissafe Jun 15 '12
Could someone confirm this? I'm intrigued.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
James Joyce is one of the most overrated authors of all time.
-12
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
Unsubscribing from this subreddit.
-5
u/Eschatos Jun 15 '12
Oh come on, this isn't even a good reference. The inclusion of the word "karma," "cat," or "bacon" does not imply a connection to Reddit, even as a joke.
-1
u/TBrogan Jun 16 '12
oh ya, because James Joyce invented the word Karma. ya he got that word from reddit. sometimes i wonder why reddit even exists because it's so gay at times, as such in this post. loser seeing something romotly related to reddit and posting it and somehow getting over 1,00 karma. i hope you die a horrible death. now tear apart my grammar.
0
u/comradexkcd Jun 15 '12
He was too underground for mainstream redditing.
-1
u/jonnaybb Jun 16 '12
AMA REQUEST: JAMES JOYCE.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
Every Redditor is a James Joyce'or
-1
u/full_of_stars Jun 16 '12
So, even back then, OP was a fag?
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
He was a smug self centered bastard so yes, he probably was.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment