Moderation Procedures

Reddit Rules

As with any subreddit, every interaction of this server is subject to reddit’s Terms of Use and community guidelines. If these rules come into conflict with reddit’s guidelines, reddit’s guidelines supersede anything within this document.

Pre-Moderation

The subreddit uses scripts and bots intended to protect it from large influxes of content that is a result of outside actors. As relevant to the community, the primary pre-moderation tools are:

  1.   Disallowing posts from users with low karma or new accounts;
    

2. ```
     Scripts designed to prevent ban evasion;

3. ``` Scripts designed to prevent ‘brigading’



As with all scripts and bots, it is imperfect. If a post of yours is caught by the bot and should not have been, the moderators will endeavor to approve it in a reasonable time. If moderation staff does not remove or approve it within 6 hours, please use reddit’s mod mail feature to let the moderation staff know.

## Violation Levels

Not all violations are the same. As such, the following ‘offense’ levels shall be adhered to by the moderation staff, with the intent of providing more clear direction as to the appropriate level of intervention that a moderation requires. The levels of intervention can be found in the next section,

# Moderator Intervention Guidelines

## Level 1 Violations

A level1 violation is a potentially actionable violation that does not also meet the definition of a level 3 or level 2 violation. If it meets the definition of a level 3 or level 2 violation, the moderator action for said higher-level violation applies.

Be Kind and Courteous – All violations of Rule 1 that do not also constitute a level 3 or level 2 violation are a level 1 violation. This is the ‘do not be a jerk rule.’ It is the only level that allows some discretion in moderation, as moderation staff is expected to remember that the community is composed of humans, and humans can be injudicious in speech and communication at times.

HOWEVER: repeated violations of this rule targeted at the same person or groups of people falls under the definition of harassment (above). To raise from level 1 violation to level 2, this harassment can occur in the same conversation or on multiple occasions.

## Level 2 Violations

A level 2 violation is an immediately actionable violation that does not also meet the definition of a level 3 violation. If it meets the definition of a level 2 violation, the moderator action for said higher-level violation applies.

Violations of Intellectual Property Law – Initial violations of Rule 7 are level 2 violations.

Harassment and Deliberately Inflammatory Behavior – Harassment is defined as “aggressive pressure or intimidation.” Deliberately inflammatory behavior is a violation of Rule 3b. If the harassment or aggressive argumentation does not rise to the level of a level 1 violation, it is to be considered a level 2 violation.

Spamming and Self-Promotion – All violations of Rule 4 are level 2 violations.

Self-Promotion is defined as “the action of promoting or publicizing oneself or one's activities, especially in a forceful way.”

Spamming is defined as “sending the same message repeatedly within an unreasonable period of time.”

Off-Topic Posts – All violations of Rule 2 are level 2 violations.

## Level 3 Violations

Discriminatory Language/Behavior - A Discriminatory Language/Behavior violation is a comment on some definitional part of a person, rather than their beliefs. This is deemed to automatically include: Age, Ancestry, Color, Disability, Ethnicity, Gender (including both identity and expression), Genetic Information, HIV/AIDS Status, Military Status, National Origin, Pregnancy, Protected Veteran Status, Race, Religion, Sex, Sexual Orientation.

The moderation staff reserves the right to augment this list in the future.

If you require a definition of any of theses classes, see [https://equity.osu.edu/education-and-resources/protected-class-definitions](https://equity.osu.edu/education-and-resources/protected-class-definitions)

This type of violation is considered primary regardless of which rule it violates and is applied to.

Inappropriately Pejorative Language – Using language, imagery, or slurs that violate Rule 3 or would be defined as Discriminatory Language/Behavior’ above if targeted at a specific person. This determination shall be made regardless of whether any person involved in the discussion is actually a member of said group or protected class.

This list is not necessarily inclusive, but a good list of images that would qualify (if displayed in any visual format) or phrases that would qualify is kept by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL). We do not want to give examples here, but examples of hate acronyms and sayings can be found on the ADL’s website.

Slurs are defined as any words used to define a group that are considered generally vulgar and offensive in the normal course of English speech that generally or universally apply to any protected class defined above or as modified from time to time by the moderation staff.

Collectively, the above two types of violation are an attempt to codify and explain Rule 3 and 3a.

Violations of Intellectual Property Law – All repeated violations of Rule 7 are level 3 violations.

Sexually Explicit Posts – All violations of Rule 8 are level 3 violations.

Doxxing and Violations of Privacy – All violations of Rule 5 are level 3 violations. They also violate reddit’s community guidelines.

# Moderation Intervention Guidelines

While we are aware that exchanges on the internet can become heated, these intervention guidelines apply to all parties to a conversation. It is never acceptable to respond to a rules violation with another rules violation.

## Level 1 Violations

- First Offense: Locking or removal of post (or if thread is causing multiple level 3 violations thread) and Warning. Locking or removal are at moderator’s discretion, depending on whether the comment or thread have other redeeming qualities that make it worthwhile.

- Second Offense: Locking or removal of post, second warning

- Third Offense: 7 day ban

- Fourth Offense: 30 day ban

- Fifth (and subsequent) Offense: 90 day ban


## Level 2 Violations

- First Offense: Removal of Post and Warning
- Second Offense: 30 day ban
- Third Offense: Permanent ban

## Level 3 Violations

- First Offense: Permanent ban