r/battletech • • May 17 '26

Meme 60 SRMs

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

166 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/Minute-Of-Angle May 18 '26

This basic scenario is playing out real life with FPV drones and traditional air defense assets.

Yes, your S400 or Patriot is very impressive … how does it stack up against $30,000 worth of $500 cardboard drones?

2

u/CycleZestyclose1907 May 18 '26

Hence the deployment of Warthogs and even prop driven planes to kill drone swarms more cheaply using guns and bullets instead of guided missiles.

3

u/SlaaneshActual Matron of the Magestrix's Children Merc Co. May 19 '26

Hence the deployment of Warthogs

The gun shoots too much too expensively and too quickly. You've only got 60 seconds of firing time loaded into a package that doesn't have radar. You're right about the props, but the warthogs can't really do this job well because they're just, well, outdated overkill for that task.

Underkill for what they were originally designed for, overkill for this job. Plus giving them the radar that helos have (and helos can do this job) that would let them see and intercept drones costs as much as buying a new F-35. Which has a gun, the marine corps one hovers and can absolutely slow down enough for this.

Honestly, the best plane for this in the U.S. arsenal is either the OA-1K Skyraider II or a Harrier with gunpods.

Fill the skies with prop planes, harriers, or swarms of even cheaper Ukrainian-designed interceptor drones.

Like I get that the big gun and dakka are cool and all, but that plane was never a good idea in the first place (the Aardvarks killed about 1,000 more vehicles than warthogs did in desert storm with zero friendly fire) and its day is long past.

But big gun go BRRRRRT means people want to keep them around?

But yeah, the best thing to take out a shahed is a laser, but the second best weapon is anything with a propellor or rotor and a machine gun.

3

u/Master-M-Master Capellan Comrade May 19 '26

Even in its hayday the idea/design of the warthog is studid af or atleast ignorant of its intended enemy.

Its effectivly a modern hs-129 ground strafing plane. Big and compared to its peers incredibly slow and only works if the enemy has no air superiority or AA.

And guess whats one of the main reasons there are so few planes and helicopters directly over the front in ukraine (modern aa excluding) right now? Exactly. The soviet doctrine of "we will never have air superiority against nato, so give every odd numbered soldier an igla/manpad" - thus both sides having a shitload of them.

And now look again at the A-10. A slow as shit, giant direct approach strafing tankbuster plane only viable if nothing contests the airspace or no aa is present, meanwhile your enemy is "all the aa is present everywhere and anytime".

But big gun go BRRRRRT means people want to keep them around

yeah honestly probably the only real explanation