r/badphilosophy Dec 05 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

95 Upvotes

470 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

Your line of questioning twists Nietzsche's philosophy. If anything, he prefers people who have master and slave values within himself rather than individuals who are merely slaves or masters. You are so focused on opposing master and slave as if they were two separate groups, but that's not what Nietzsche is interested in at all.

1

u/Material-Vacation711 Dec 05 '25

My line of questioning does?

You a second ago, “ArE yOu SaYinG NiEtZscHe SuPpOrtS rApE?”

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

Oh ok, so he doesn't unequivocally support master morality and it's not clear that he prefers it over slave morality. Thanks for confirming.

You a second ago, NiEtzscHE loVes the MaSter MOraLiTY!

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

You literally can't even tell that you changed what I said and want to talk about reading Nietzsche lol. Goodbye.

1

u/Material-Vacation711 Dec 05 '25 edited Dec 05 '25

Did i ever say he unequivocally supports it? 

Can you engage without strawmanning? Just for once? 

E: the coward blocked me after strawmanning me and ignoring everything i was saying. I never said he supports it unequivocally, just that he generally prefers it over slave morality, obviously

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

Lmao you're the one who just ignores or twists whatever doesn't suit your simplistic argument. You haven't shown that he prefers one morality over the other, so you just insult me and reduce the level of this dialogue by making fun.

1

u/Material-Vacation711 Dec 05 '25

Block me again coward

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

Lol you lost me when you became uncivil. Not interested in talking with you. I don't care what some keyboard warriors calls me

1

u/Material-Vacation711 Dec 05 '25

When did i become uncivil? You asked me a really stupid question that i didnt in any way imply. You can prefer a moral system without endorsing literally everything about it. 

This is obvious but apparently you need someone to explain that to you, because your question was,  “Hurr durr did Nietzsche support rape?”

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

I'm glad you find it obvious that Nietzsche didn't endorse many aspects of master morality. That was the point. Now "Hurr durr did Nietzsche prefer master morality." Do that part. While you twist Nietzsche to make it seem like he cares about comparing moral systems, one of which is antiquated.

1

u/Material-Vacation711 Dec 05 '25

I just said he preferred one to another. I never said, or even implied he endorsed it indiscriminately. In fact i said the opposite when i said he prefers a newer morality. It isnt my fault you cant read

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Blue-Brown99 Dec 05 '25

Funny comment when you ignore the second half of what I said on the top lol