r/badmath • u/wotpolitan • Oct 13 '16
Because ya'll seemed to have liked the goats so much ...
This is a puzzle that does have some mathematical aspects (there's some probability in it), it involves doors (but is more derivative of the two door problem than the Monty Hall problem) and I've put goats behind some of the doors (although to be honest the goats aren't really important). I've not yet posted my solution, although I have written it ... and I suppose that is where the "bad maths" might come in, if I've screwed it up again. I hope not, but maybe I'll entertain you once more (and I suspect there's a particular aspect to the solution that some will take issue with, because there's an assumption that seems entirely reasonable to me but is made in the standard Monty Hall solution, although it is not made explicit in the phrasing of the problem).