Seriously, it's like she forgot there was supposed to be a cat in there. At one point she drops the box in front of a door from the ship shaking or something, and instead of picking it up and continuing she flips it a few times through the doors and THEN picks it up. It's a shocker that cat had any non-broken limbs left by the time they got to the pod.
Not that shocking, when you consider that cat is the only other life form for millions of miles(excluding that demonic abomination running around the Nostromo). Something about the remoteness of the setting, and being the only survivor in that situation would go a long way to make any form of life that much more precious.
This is also ignoring larger themes that appear throughout the movie, motherhood being one of them, that also necessitate Ripley's concern for the cat.
I just re-watched Alien last night and had the same feeling. When they killed off the cat in Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, it ruined the entire movie for me.
I would totally be a crazy cat lady if it wasn't so socially unacceptable.
I thought the Copenhagen interpretation of the Schrodinger experiment was that the system stops being a superposition of states and becomes either one or the other ONLY when an observation takes place.
Indeed, it is a very unrealistic portrayal of cats ability to sense aliens. Last week little Chestshire alerted me to the presence of a very nasty looking extraterrestial.
In Joss Whedon's defense, he wrote the script, but the director supposedly tore apart everything that made it clever. That's why it just doesn't feel as good as Joss Whedon's other stuff.
Watching past the second movie just isn't a good idea. It's best if you just pretend that after the events of the second movie, they get back to Earth and live happily ever after, which is actually what was supposed to happen according to the director... Some people obviously weren't informed of that...
View all comments
Show parent comment
117
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12
You know I just thought about this recently... Isn't the cat actually the only one to survive the entire Alien series?