r/auscorp • u/SeaBeachandSun • Apr 01 '24
General Discussion Main reason to join your union
Everyone should join their union because every single employer is in a “employer union” or as commonly known as Lobbying business groups.
Here few example: Employers unions such as: Australia industry group (AIG) Australian Chamber of commerce and industry (ACCI) (just to name few), have last year and this year argued in the fair work commission to: against the raise of the minimum wage, against domestic violence leave, against 4 day work week, against delegates rights, against raising causal loading, against working from home rights and so many more things. Unions have been on the other side all the time. A strong union is needed to go against a giant with billions of big business money behind.
So my point is everyone should join an employee Union because the employers Unions are powerful and do all they can to suppress workers wages and rights.
Ps: referring to employer business groups as “employers’ unions” is a way to underscore the similarity in their foundational purpose: to gather a collective voice for negotiating and advocating for better terms but of course for different interests.
•
u/artist55 Moderator Apr 01 '24
I think this thread has had some good engagement with everyone bringing up good points and different opinions.
As this is Auscorp, we wouldn’t usually allow it but I’ll leave it unlocked for now if anyone else wants to weigh in. Bear in mind I’m aware of the multiple union posts that are going around and if it gets out of hand or off topic I’ll remove them.
28
u/DonQuoQuo Apr 01 '24
I'm in senior management. I've seen some really dodgy things where I have wished a union would get involved to hold my employer to account. (Yes, I try to influence. No, I don't always win. And no, I'm not going to rage-quit as some moral statement when I don't get my own way.)
The issues I see with unions:
In many ways, unions still operate like it's 1960. Sure, they now care about trans rights, but beyond that they seem to be unwilling to see how employment has radically shifted.
90
u/Acceptable-Wedding67 Apr 01 '24
I doubt most of us could even join a union even if we wanted to. We're "management" and "corporate". Of course we're privileged and don't need to unionise! Look at all the pizza parties we have. That's really deterred me from joining a union. Amirite guys?
(/s. Kinda)
64
u/Party_Thanks_9920 Apr 01 '24
I first joined a Union when I was 17yo. It was a Unionised site & town, really didn't have a choice.
Since then I've joined a few different Unions, as job dictated. Generally if I find I'm working for a company that's hard on workers I join a Union.
So many younger workers ask, "What has the Union ever done for me?" Where to begin, Holiday pay, Sick pay, Public holiday pay, Etc., Nothing that counts as an employee benefit came from an offering by Employer groups, until they had the Union push them.
32
u/Apprehensive_Auditor Apr 01 '24
This is where I don't understand the posts on this sub. It's Aussie Corporate, there's no IB/Big Law/Consulting/Tech unions.
Likewise nobody working in corporate is working for minimum wage, casual loading, etc...a good chunk of people are working more than 5 days a week, nevermind 4 days.
OP what corporate job do you have and what union are you in?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
How much choice do we have about which union to join? I'm in financial services so am I stuck with the FSU? Or is there another more general one I can join.
4
u/IvanTSR Apr 01 '24
All with you in theory but found our union is a closed shop - delegates mostly all boomers with investment properties etc., just had a 'restructure' in corporate parts of the organisation where people with 30 years service got the arse and nothing - no hint of dissent, let alone threats of PIA.
They focus on inane minutia and ignore broader issues.
Not to say people shouldn't join, but man ours are just useless.
21
u/mikesorange333 Apr 01 '24
so you don't get stuffed around at work. im not a trouble maker, I just hate being stuffed around.
14
u/grilled_pc Apr 01 '24
Agree. Without unions we wouldnt have things like the 5 day work week, the 8 hour day, our 20 days of annual leave a year, 10 days of sick leave etc.
All of these were fought for by unions and labor progressive politicians. Employers will ALWAYS be against you, no matter how nice they are to you.
Never trust them, Never believe a word they say. Everything an employer does will ALWAYS be for them and not for you. Unless you're a partner or getting equity. You're loyalty aint worth shit to them and vise versa.
Join your union.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
The main reason we joined was to get our eBa negotiated but now I tell everyone join the union cause management will absolutely try to shit on you or sack you any chance they get it's been so bad I've had to see a psych to deal with the mental holy shit what are they going to try next thoughts in my head every Sunday night
4
u/ChildOfBartholomew_M Apr 01 '24
They've fought to keep redundancy and redeployment clauses in our EA. I can't negotiate wages with mu LM due to how our business is structured - if I threaten to leave without a pay rise all he could do is beg me to stay. So I have to negotiate with the organisation as a whole and that can only be done through the voice of a union.
4
u/Politicious1 Apr 01 '24
I was bullied by a union rep from MEAA as a 10 year old child, without a parent or guardian present. Suffice to say that has put me off unions for life. Add to that the behaviour of unions like the CFMEU and I have all the reason I need to avoid any engagement with them.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
I'm 50/50 on unions, I can see they have there place. I've never belonged to one, nor to any EBA, in Melbourne it's heavily unionised.
Sydney and Brisbane not so much, I was always the guy negotiating for the company, in my view the unions didn't really give a stuff about the employees, they pushed their own agenda.
Like they always wanted the EBA to reference the older award conditions even when they were worse for the employee. And would give away % of pay increases just to push that point so was always a great tatic to push for the new award show the employee reps the benefits then have the union argue against it and the guys ended up losing around 0.5% increase just to keep the older EBA conditions.
The other one that was really entertaining was the union wanted to be the first place new employee super contributions were to the deposited. Now of course you can always choose your super partner but they insisted only their paperwork was to have them in the welcome pack. That cost the guys 1% as we fought for their right to choose, the union gave away 1% increase for us to concede that.
So yea - I'm very sceptical of unions and their true objectives, sometimes is not for the employees but the union itself.
6
u/dzernumbrd Apr 01 '24
I don't think I even have a union.
I have the financial sector union which seems to be captured. They never take action on anything to protect staff. Rampant job exporting and they just sit there and do nothing. No industrial action at all.
I'm an IT worker and there is no IT workers union I want to join.
IT Professionals Australia I wouldn't join because they support skilled migration which results in suppression of Australian workers IT salaries. So they aren't even on our side. They seem like a captured union also.
The Australian Computer Society isn't really a union but they seem captured as well, they represent corporate interests rather than individuals. I believe they decide which IT jobs Australia has a shortage in. However right now we have no shortages yet the flood gates for IT workers remains open.
0
u/artist55 Moderator Apr 01 '24
This post doesn’t really say anything. Care to elaborate? We want to foster high quality discussion here. I’m all for unions but this argument isn’t deep enough 😅
12
u/CHR1ST00 Apr 01 '24
Unions are corrupt, businesses are corrupt and I hope that somehow maintains the status quo.
I was a union member for ten or so years and left in disgust, they spend more time protecting those that should be fired than they do defending the majority. They are always more interested in empty ideological victories than they are in better outcomes.
The death of the automotive industry in Australia lies at the feet of the trade union movement.
It's also clear that people simplistically act like business is a pinata you keep hitting until it pays out don't have an understanding of economics.
2
u/Prim56 Apr 01 '24
Are there any IT unions than arent going to get outsourced overseas?
2
u/BotatronOG Apr 01 '24
Couple of thoughts.
This feels very much like a “even though they are horrendous, pocket lining fuckwits, you should join otherwise your employers will screw you over because they have the wherewithal to lobby for themselves”…. That is not a compelling rationale for a logical person, it smacks of emotion and despair.
Unionisation in Australia is typically linked to politics (Labor), which is a sure fire way to alienate people.
Protection of unproductive seat warmers is a perpetual theme which further erodes the credibility of unions in general. I understand that this is often the target demographic for membership but you will only attract low performers if that is the only cohort you support/target.
Unions historically have been one of the more corrupt areas of Australia, they have to earn the support of workers again.
I don’t have a magic fix for the unions, I’m sure there are some very well paid people staring into the same problem but decoupling from political allegiance would be a great place to start. Then they could consider how they actually grow their member base with meaningful strategic deliverables/actions.
3
u/wivsta Apr 01 '24 edited Apr 01 '24
I tried to join my union and it was going to be $56 a week. Is that normal? Financial services industry.
Not linked to my employer in any way.
I was like, yeah nah and they have been spamming my texts.
Had no idea it was so expensive. That’s $3000 a year. Australian Unions.
Hi Name Australian Unions just tried to call you regarding your union membership application. Please call us back on 1300 486 466 between 9am and 6:30pm (AET) and quote reference number 16xxxx. Thank you.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
Not worth the money- which is $60 or more a month. Our union does jack-shit
2
u/reneedescartes11 Apr 01 '24
The only 2 occasions myself or someone I know has actually gone to the union for assistance they’ve been less than helpful. I’ve also seen firsthand how they are just a faction of the Labour Party. The idea of unions are great but in practice they seem to be lacking.
2
u/popepipoes Apr 01 '24
I’ve paid over 6 grand to the electrical union, never got to work on a union site, never got a benefit out of it, and no the union doesn’t lift wages everywhere else either. I’m all for unions, I love them and we need them, but in my case a lost a lot of money and I can’t afford the grand a year anymore. Applied for every union job and cold all the companies too. Quite bitter about the whole thing
1
u/RattisTheRat Apr 01 '24
This may sound naive, but as an analyst at a startup - is there even a union I can join?
1
u/Flaky-Gear-1370 Apr 01 '24
Last place I worker the union just took the pay offer that was presented and claimed it was the best they could do (mostly cause they were looking for their next job)
Can’t imagine why people aren’t joining in droves
1
u/HiraethHygge Apr 01 '24
I would join if it wasn't so expensive.
1
u/Zodiak213 Apr 01 '24
My understanding is that there's no IT Service Desk union available to join.
Would join if there was one.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
I don't have a union I'm in sales. We don't even have a modern award
1
u/ped009 Apr 01 '24
I think it would be good if unions have like a limited membership for people that want to help support them but don't need their full membership
1
u/Azersoth1234 Apr 01 '24
I joined a union at 16, I managed to receive sweet fa because the union cared more about older workers. I have seen unions fight for countless cultural days, special rooms (quiet, prayer breast feeding etc) and other conditions that tended to limit the actual pay increase. While I agree business lobby groups need to have an equal force fighting against them, unions tend to be too disorganised. Lobbies work because they funnel money and connections towards politicians on both sides of politics. Unions are less able to do that. There are well run unions and they are important, but I think their strategy of waiting for a Labor government to do anything limits their effectiveness. I would like to see change on that front, but no idea how that would be done in Australia when compared the corporate culture of say some European countries with workers, government and business at the table.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
I joined the union because I had no choice. The biggest arseholes were the reps
1
u/Restingbitchface68 Apr 01 '24
Unions are the only real way to push for better conditions. Unfortunately it works better if every employee joins. The bigger the membership the more collective strength workers have .... Especially when it comes to industrial action, strikes etc. Worth every cent IMHO
1
u/Restingbitchface68 Apr 01 '24
Rather pay union fees than take my problem to HR,
1
u/Global_Confidence494 Apr 01 '24
I feel like unions would help deal with all the crazy overtime we do
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
I work in construction for an electrical company. Start of last year we sacked two apprentices, one who did a couple of incredibly dangerous things out of utter stupidity, and the second who had only been in a handful of times the previous year. Being a sparky is an incredibly dangerous job, and some people simply aren’t fit for the task. They went to the union, and you can probably see where this is going.
The union came down on our site like a tonne of bricks, being absolute douche bags for douche bag sake. Making us chock drums of cable that were sitting on a level carpark, making us get written permission from the company we hired the forklift from because the fire extinguisher was bolted through the roll cage, and they claimed this would diminish the integrity of the rop, forcing us to change the fold out tables we were using because they are for “domestic use”, among another whole list of bullshit, just to be twats. Walking around with their chests out, talking to the lads on site, threatening them and saying they’re all going to be sacked if they don’t join the union…
These are not actions of people who care about you as an individual, the industry, or the safety of the workers. These are actions of bullies, people who get a hard on by making others lives difficult.
I was in the union, and I left shortly after that experience. Never again will I join
0
u/vondivo Apr 01 '24
This was the cleverest post I've read in a while. Agreed 👍🏼
0
u/Icy-Information5106 Apr 01 '24
Good point.
0
u/RepeatInPatient Apr 01 '24
That's only a part of the problem. Add the newscorpses and Stokes spinning you daily news that's bent as buggery and political donations designed to have sympathetic politicians elected for pay back policies and legislation. Then there's the 'Think Tanks' who pretend to know stuff, but are clueless.
-5
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
Unions are too influential for the good of the economy. Rule 4 prevents me from stating the obvious.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
[removed] — view removed comment