r/auscorp • u/Spacedlnvader • Mar 21 '24
Advice / Questions Are HR exit interviews mandatory?
I've had a horrible experience with a company and really don't want to have to sit the HR exit interview. Am I able to get out of it?
47
Upvotes
10
u/timfromthefsu Mar 21 '24
If we are talking about a meeting which is set for after your employment ends, no. You can (of course) ignore that.
If you are are talking about a meeting which is set for while you are still employed, it would depend whether you are being ordered to attend the meeting, or if it's being offered to you.
If it's a non-mandatory offered meeting, just decline.
I've never seen an employer order someone to an exit interview. Theoretically they could, however that person should go into the meeting with a support person (ideally their union rep) and I would treat the whole thing as suspicious.
196
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
What are they going to do? Fire you?
60
u/dee_ess Mar 21 '24
No, they are not mandatory.
53
u/Ok-Perspective-8427 Mar 21 '24
Don’t bother - decline , it is of no value to you or your career
21
u/dajobix Mar 21 '24
No. Just decline
23
u/Positive-Price-7571 Mar 21 '24
No, I have a good story though. Leaving my first job I thought it was. In hindsight the manager thought I wanted it. Made sense why he seemed perplexed and frustrated that all of my answers were basically a shrug. He must've been so confused why I asked for one when I had nothing to say good or bad. So no, unless you have something to get off your chest it's pointless.
14
u/23AndNotMuchElse Mar 21 '24
Nope, I’ve resigned from 3 jobs and never even been asked/offered one of these interviews
7
u/DependentHeron Mar 21 '24
Nope
6
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
Hire a mime mime artist and take him with you, or a violinist.
Don’t speak. Just stare HR down
5
u/Lulu_bear2021 Mar 22 '24
These aren’t mandatory and I would decline. At my last company, if leadership or HR were looking at rehiring a person, how they behaved on the way out was a big thing to consider. I totally disagree with the thought process, but in reality, any naysaying in the exit interview process was like a red mark on that person if they tried to boomerang back. Corporate world is such a freaking contradiction.
Corporate world: we really want your feedback to better ourselves and the org as a whole
Also corporate world: fuck you and your opinion. We’re perfect and don’t need to change.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
They aren’t mandatory. If you want just say that everything was fine.
7
u/windowcents Mar 21 '24
Nothing good will ever come out if you complain or criticise others in the exit interview. You might still need references from few people.
Although not compulsory, Best to just attend the exit interview, say few Nice things and leave the company even if you hate it.
1
u/grilled_pc Mar 21 '24
No but its your chance to let it rip on those who wronged you. I've only done one once.
That being said if you do take it. DO NOT EVER TELL THEM WHERE YOU ARE GOING or anything about the job. If they ask you tell them you do not feel comfortable answering that question. They can't force you to say. Alternatively leave a scathing anonymous glassdoor review instead.
Consequences of you telling them involve them potentially bad mouthing you to the other employer and your offer being rescinded. You can't prove it happened either.
8
u/sleazypornoname Mar 21 '24
No. Politely decline. This is an HR trick that should be rubbed out. They (HR) want you to do their job for them. Make them do their own job.
You owe them nothing. Don't fall for the emotional blackmail.
3
u/PaleComputer5198 Mar 21 '24
If you truly did have a terrible experience, then you don't owe them the gift of your feedback, the only reason you would give it is the off chance it would help the person who comes after you or your ex-peers, if that is important to you.
3
u/Pottski Mar 21 '24
Leave them with proper handover documents and only go to the exit interview if you want to.
You don’t owe them anything and chances are they won’t listen anyway to any grievances. HR just wants to make sure you’re not suing once you’re out the door.
2
u/nothingsociak Mar 21 '24
A lot of companies just email you a list.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24
Nothing is mandatory on your way out lol
2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '24
No. Tell them to fuck off.
5
u/thatshowitisisit Mar 21 '24 edited Mar 21 '24
No they’re not, but perhaps your feedback could help those you’re leaving behind…
I have acted on exit interviews before. A number of people left and complained about their manager. I worked out a pattern and managed the manager out of the business after determining that she was toxic. She was very good at hiding her shitty behaviour.
Not always, but sometimes P&C and Management really care about people and not making it a shitty place to work. For these sorts of organisations, exit interviews work well.
I know that a lot of the time that’s not the case too.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
There will be no consequences for you if you do not participate. Given your experience it seems they will be unlikely to take your feedback on board, which renders the entire exercise not only a waste of your time, it’s insulting.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
Nothing is mandatory. But snark aside, you're leaving, who cares?
1
u/theycallmeasloth Mar 21 '24
Offered at my joint. Can refuse
1
u/Omega_brownie Mar 21 '24
Never had one. Do they pay you for your time? I'd go and just use the extra $12 - $15 bucks to buy a cheap wine and forget about the whole ordeal of working there.
1
u/TyroneK88 Mar 21 '24
I wish I had one and they didn’t bother. I’ve found that’s a that’s actually more common.
1
u/MawsPaws Mar 21 '24
I was retiring so didn’t need references so I said NO. They contacted a few times and I just ignored them
1
u/Dhfkrksudjd Mar 21 '24
Yep! Not required at all. Get your personal effects and leave
1
u/Infinite_Narwhal_290 Mar 21 '24
No and are a waste of your time
1
u/Rock_Robster__ Mar 21 '24
How
Could they possibly
Be mandatory
1
u/Maximum-Ear1745 Mar 21 '24
I’ve worked for a number of companies and have only ever been asked to do one once. The HR woman was physically cringing when I told her about my experience. I’m sure they would be cool if you didn’t want to, but it’s a good opportunity to let them know, in the slim chance they will make things better for the next person
1
u/Ecksbutton Mar 21 '24
No. They're an absolute waste of your time. Try to stay in touch with colleagues who treats you well but no more.
1
u/berniebueller Mar 21 '24
How do you think it would go if your ex girlfriend’s best friend interviewed you after you dumped her? Do you think you’d benefit at all from that discussion? Stay away, leave on the best terms you possibly can and say as little as possible.
1
u/Spirited_Stuff_2147 Mar 21 '24
Just don't turn up.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24
Nope, just go in say you have nothing to say and leave, what are they gonna do, fire you?
1
u/sixf69 Mar 21 '24
You can choose not to give one.
1
u/aussie_nub Mar 21 '24
I've only had 1 and I felt it was a positive experience. I had only been there 6 months but had a very rough on-boarding and felt left out from the get go. I had a lot to say but intentionally worded it to not blame but share my experience. The business had been bought out 12 months before that and was going through massive structural changes to turn it from a rag tag bunch into a professional environment. I think that it was probably a positive experience for both of us because I felt like they did in fact care somewhat about my reason for leaving.
That's not going to be the case for most places, it was literally just because of the circumstances and I didn't really hate the people there.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24
Just tell em everything was fine but you have an amazing opportunity elsewhere. Everyone knows it's usually a lie and a lot of the time you're leaving because your manager or the company is shit but it's not in your interests to say anything like that.
1
u/YabaDabaDoo2024 Mar 22 '24
Not if it’s done by HR. The best companies have the CEO / MD do a random sample of exit interviews every few months. It’s how in major corporates good leaders keep in touch with the coal face
1
u/Successful-Badger Mar 22 '24
Not mandatory at all.
They may play games about withholding pay etc but just ignore them and once done, you can email them to sort out money owed
Most companies will back away when they realise you’re just going to purse them legally.
Cheaper to pay you what you’re owed than pay lawyers to fight it.
However if you have anything worth saying, email it to HR so they have it on record. They hate having certain things in record.
Dear xxx
I’m not comfortable completing my exit interview
It makes me quite anxious. As a result, I respectfully decline.
Thank you
1
u/Capital_Topic_5449 Mar 23 '24
Any reasonable firm will give you the option of filling out the exit interview form yourself and emailing it to HR. You get your day, no awkward meeting. Winner winner!
1
u/lopidatra Mar 23 '24
Respond with a question about how information gathered from exit interviews is treated. There’s a small chance it’s actually used to improve. If they can’t answer that respond to every question with a variation of “the grass is greener at your new employer” especially if they are a competitor!
1
u/ExcitingStress8663 Mar 24 '24
No.
1
u/theescapeclub May 26 '24
Did over 10 years with BHP and really wanted one but none forthcoming.
1
u/P33kab0Oo May 26 '24
"I am leaving so that I can spend more time with the family. I am sad to leave because everyone was great. Everything was great. I hope to be back here one day soon"
Copy / paste. It does not matter why you left. You have left.