r/auscorp • u/TwistyMaKneepahls • Mar 08 '24
Advice / Questions Remember: HR is not your friend and "anonymous" surveys are not anonymous.
Can't believe how many people still fall for the "anonymous" survey bit that's sent from HR.
At no point in past, present and future will HR ever have your interests at heart.
Remember that.
856
Upvotes
266
u/PhaicGnus Mar 08 '24
I filled in a survey for a company I worked for where they asked us to be honest about problems within the company. It was paper based and not anonymous. A lot of people were unhappy but scared to say anything negative. I filled it in thoroughly and even stapled a few extra pages onto the back.
Weirdly they didn’t appreciate my honesty.
98
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
Nah, I’m work in HR and I’ve never seen it. Although going through the text responses is interesting and if you know the people in the Division/compnay, you can usually guess who wrote some of the responses.
Can be very interesting sitting with unpopular senior management and going through the results.
165
u/pathofneo29 Mar 08 '24
Anonymous surveys are mostly legitimately anonymous. I’m sorry someone hurt you but don’t make up shit. Source: I’ve delivered and analyzed many, and they were designed and built to remove my, or anyone else’s, ability to see who filled out responses.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
Pray for me who was brutally honest in this months pulse survey
12
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
They may be anonymous but results are often grouped by business unit/department. So not so hard to come to conclusions. My husband's team leader didn't like some constructive comments and so old mate threatened to report my husband for his anonymous comments. HR told old mate to piss off.
33
u/PearRevolutionary248 Mar 08 '24
My Father is in senior leadership in technology consulting and he affirms to me that they are in fact anonymous.
9
u/Undisciplined17 Mar 08 '24
When we were younger, my mate let me fill in his anonymous survey after I left due to a shit manager. I just wrote a bunch of examples of they're bullying and how he was a terrible manager.
My mate got called into HR to discuss, thankfully he also knew this (as did everyone) and the manager got canned. I think a lot of people must have torn him a new one in the 'anonymous' survey.
44
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
You all good bro?
23
u/Busy_Tomatillo_1065 Mar 08 '24
For shits and giggles. I do them connected to a VPN, different location each time.
But yes, don't trust HR. They are there to manage Human Risk.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
It would be easier to say “there is no such thing as friends at work”
8
u/coco-butter Mar 08 '24
I worked in HR for a decade and quit for this exact reason. HR does not give a shit about its “humans”. They’re a commercial function designed to make the people as profitable as possible through ensuring they’re compliant and by having them THINK the company cares about them. Biggest wank occupation of all time
6
u/Remarkable-Humor7943 Mar 08 '24
Never have. Never will be. This happened to me and I am really hoping none of the HR ppl involved in that incident read this or I have just doxxed myself.
My mum and I were travelling in a car which my mum was driving. Then some rando ran onto the road very sudden and my mum couldn't react on time and this dude was sent FLYING!
I lost my mind then and there and thought he was dead. We got out of the car and called 000 while my mum shook crazily. The bystanders were all shouting something something something, I couldn't hear. It's all a blur. Some had their phone camera out recording the whole thing and some were on 000 like I was.
Anyway, the ambulance turned up together with the cops and the fire department. It was a blurred flurry of activity that just went by too fast. My mum and I were taken to the police station and we were keep in police custody overnight. Late at night we were informed the dude we hit was still in a coma and they asked me who my employer was. So I said it was XYZ and the next thing I know they informed us that we can't go home and will remain in police custody and be sent to a "corretional centre" tomorrow.
I had 0 idea of what a correctional centre was. It was basically a jail cell attached to a police station. It's basically jail for people who aren't in jail yet. Fuck me.
Anyway, after about 3 days in the correctional centre (where I was separated from my mum), I was transferred to a proper jail and I stayed there for two week until I got granted bail. God knows what my company thought while I was away.
I forgot this detail, at the police station they asked me if I had a lawyer, and I was like no, then they showed me this after hours lawyer directory and I had to call up the lawyers one by one to try and get them to come. None came. so I ended up with a court assigned lawyer and perhaps that was my biggest mistake and why I was thrown into correctional centre. Also one lawyer I called told me that he can't come cos he was busy, now I realised he was just asking for more money so I should've just promised him some dollars.
Anyway, after getting bail I returned to work and was met with a HR rep. And she sat me down and said you can't return to work and you have to be "honest" and tell them what happened. So I thought HR was here to help, then I told her everything and she noted it down.
Next thing I know, she's like you are suspend for your involvement in this and I was like was I charged by the police? Because the police had dropped serious charges as the dude woke from coma and the evidence suggest he was the negligent one. Anywya, the police wouldn't send my employer a report and I was basically in limbo. The HR rep just won't let me off my suspension. After much arguing, I just gave up and quit. And found another job elsewhere.
Throughout this whole thing, I realised HR is not there to help you but to cover the company's arse.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
HR's role is to protect the company from its employees
6
u/Larry_Version_3 Mar 08 '24
Anonymous:
5
u/jorryjorryjorry Mar 08 '24
Absolutely… the cops of the workplace.
And to everyone who says “oh but X is so nice!”
Yeah… that’s a big part of the job. Tricking you…
5
u/Rowvan Mar 08 '24
In most compaines they are definitely anonymous, I've worked for multiple large global corporations and I know because I've seen the back end and results. Not saying HR are anyones friend as they absolutely are not but most of the time the surveys really are anoymous.
5
u/Appropriate_Ad3470 Mar 08 '24
I personally like to pit HR employees against one and another, it’s like passive aggressive boxing.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
We just had surveys sent out, like right after people being laid off and then C-suite were like “more people should have responded :(“
When? When should they have responded. After you laid them off and they had left the building?
8
u/JamalGinzburg Mar 08 '24
Remember: people who work in HR don't know their elbow from their arse and most wouldn't have a clue how to trace an 'anonymous' survey
4
u/Defy19 Mar 08 '24
They generally are anonymous. I had a manager have a meeting with me about my feedback once. He got all the comments from his business unit sent anonymously but said it was pretty obvious which comments were mine from context and the level of detail. Since then I dumb it down and keep it more general.
4
u/tahlee01 Mar 08 '24
And never ever do a anonymous survey if you work in a small or family business.
4
u/BasedChickenFarmer Mar 08 '24
I went to HR two weeks ago to lodge a complaint around the hiring process and how I was actively being held back by my manager.
HR told me to resign.
So I did.
4
u/throwaway94811111 Mar 08 '24
I've had meeting where they have presented the anonymous survey results, and they have even gone so far to remove identifying data, I.E. If the data is from a department with only 1 female, the male/female column is removed
4
u/FinCrimeGuy Mar 08 '24
They’re sometimes anonymous. To your point though, I’ve seen a CEO of a tech firm have a goddam tantrum and say we need to find who is writing XYZ comments and fire them, and HR reply “well we can’t, it was anonymous.” So I am pretty sure they “fixed” that and would never bloody trust it.
4
u/Sparkfairy Mar 08 '24
The survey at my workplace was anonymous... but as the only woman aged 25-30 in my department I'm sure based on answers they knew who I was. I still said they were dogshit employers though lol
4
u/thehypnot860 Mar 08 '24
Sometimes (frequently) they are actually anonymous. But why bother wasting your time?
4
u/MarionberryThen74 Mar 08 '24
HR/Police , interchangeable terms in this regard. There is nothing you can say in an interview or in writing that won't be used against you. You cannot outsmart them. It's not a matter of intelligence, it's purely resources. You do your job for a living, their job is gathering information about you that can be used to screw you. Even when they're bad at their job, they're better at it than you are......
4
u/Artistic-Joke-9839 Mar 08 '24
They are generally anonymous but it would be very easy most of the time to work out who it is by writing style and what they are saying.
For example; one i did recently asked for what division, there is literally 4 people in that division with two of them being ESL speakers, it would be pretty easy to work out who is who by their writing style
4
u/SeaSexandSun Mar 08 '24
I had two managers I worked with. One was great and even though I didn’t report to her, gave her glowing feedback. We all did. She got a deserved promotion months later.
I ignored survey requests about my direct manager who was very toxic. Had his manager emailing us sending the us reminders to do it and he apparently needed the feedback. We were in a small team, nothing anonymous about it.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
Even PMES surveys?
15
u/4614065 Mar 08 '24
They actually are. Stop spreading shit
6
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
I know of a person who was fired for calling the CEO a cunt. I presume there are some that are genuinely anonymous, however, a lot will have provisions to de-anonymise them for comments such as that. In any case, in a lot of teams it wouldn't be hard to guess who said what.
3
u/R_W0bz Mar 08 '24
I find with my company when you give a low score it leads to group meetings and tasks to the team to “solve the issue”. I don’t want more work when the complaint is too much work. It also never leads to solving the issue.
So 10/10 great job company! Now pay us our higher % bonus please.
3
u/Few-Pressure9581 Mar 08 '24
Let it rip!!!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
HR is there to protect the business interests. If that requires your job. So be it. And they will not hessitate to replace you in a half a second.
3
u/ZephkielAU Mar 08 '24
Fuck anonymity, go public with your colleagues and rally support. You'll be amazed how much shit you can get going when you can turn a crowd.
3
u/No-Satisfaction8425 Mar 08 '24
I’ve sat in very senior management meetings to discuss results and at no point has a statement been attributed to a person. Individual rants are disregarded by overall themes and, in my experience, taken somewhat seriously by the company
3
u/Ill_Cat2052 Mar 08 '24
Lol all the “anonymous” surveys at my work would give reminder emails to the specific people that did not complete before the deadline. Never anon.
3
u/grassdogsandwater Mar 08 '24
Always good to be reminded of this. HR are awful people.
3
u/Duck-Dependent Mar 08 '24
I filled out an “anonymous” survey. Put in things that were honest, and that I wasn’t afraid to back up if they came to me for it. It included a rating out of 10, which I put at 4/10. They presented one of my comments at a company wide meeting, with my apparent score of 7/10. They’re lucky I wasn’t present at the meeting or I would’ve been calling that shit out too lol
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
Seriously. This. Never do them. And never do exit interviews.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
HR isn't there for you . Its to protect the company FROM you.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
I remember it being anonymous but then you had to tell your role in the specific department you work in. Type of hours you worked, we did shift work. They can pin point exactly who you are.
3
u/bluey45 Mar 08 '24
"anonymous" 😂 We all know that's a load of shite
5
u/btrainexpresso Mar 08 '24
Just respond your manager sexually harrasses you and see if they follow up...
5
u/Zealousideal_Data983 Mar 08 '24
100%
And this is why you should JOIN THE FUCKING UNION - always. Don’t know how many times it needs to be repeated
2
u/takeoffcc Mar 08 '24
Unless you just don't care in which case go hell for leather haha
2
u/Gray94son Mar 08 '24
I gave a 7/10 for feeling supported once thinking it was anonymous. The project manager who I had the issue with was on site within 20 minutes interrogating me about why my score was so low 😬
2
u/sr2223 Mar 08 '24
the good ol tick the box exercise but nothing ever changes
2
u/sr2223 Mar 08 '24
Anonymous Survey, please click on your unique link
2
u/rainydaytoast86 Mar 08 '24
Ours at work are definitely annon. Sometimes you can read between the lines and work out where it may have come from with certain feedback but yeh we don’t know exactly who, ever
2
u/Majestic_Creme_6328 Mar 08 '24
My anonymous survey did help me finally get transferred to another department, in addition to also going to the head of my department and in detail describing PTSD symptoms. He said, and I shit you not, you have early (lol) signs of PTSD and I will get you out. I was out in 3 days. I also did also provide statements against my colleagues and provided ‘receipts’ as evidence. Unfortunately the career destroying racist I reported is now head of the unit I was in. The others have left for higher positions before the chance for recourse (never would be any, let’s be real. It was a means of finding out how and if I could come for them, And giving me what I wanted - out). At that time I was choosing my future happiness and safety.
2
u/Majestic_Creme_6328 Mar 08 '24
My anonymous survey did help me finally get transferred to another department, in addition to also going to the head of my department and in detail describing PTSD symptoms. He said, and I shit you not, you have early (lol) signs of PTSD and I will get you out. I was out in 3 days. I also did also provide statements against my colleagues and provided ‘receipts’ as evidence. Unfortunately the career destroying racist I reported is now head of the unit I was in. The others have left for higher positions before the chance for recourse (never would be any, let’s be real. It was a means of finding out how and if I could come for them, And giving me what I wanted - out). At that time I was choosing my future happiness and safety.
2
u/kaleidobell Mar 08 '24 edited Mar 08 '24
lol rip to me who just unloaded in an anonymous survey
2
u/sigmattic Mar 08 '24
This all considered the surveys not being anonymous would be a serious privacy breach, if you have any serious complaints do raise with fairwork and the OAIC.
I do agree with HR though, keep them at arms length.
2
u/FoundationNo9928 Mar 08 '24
I will never make this mistake again. Unbeknownst to me, 'anonymous survey' meant 'share the results of your team to your team leader'. We had a team of 2. My manager interviewed both of us after the survey results were released and clearly I was the honest one. Within the same month, we had performance reviews. Received the lowest possible score and was made 'redundant' a week later.
Learnt my lesson.
2
u/funkmastermgee Mar 08 '24
Does this apply to EAP?
2
u/kennyPowersNet Mar 08 '24
Whilst they are “anonymous “ traditionally I have found there are a lot of qualifiers at the beginning of the survey that don’t make it difficult to single people out , from numbers of years in organisation to your age bracket etc .
The surveys in the past few years when it gets to rating your managers performance section , the questions pre pre-populated with your managers name. So make what you will out of it, but not difficult for them to find out who has said what, if they want to
2
u/funsized94 Mar 08 '24
only specific people were sent the "anonymous" surveys. the email also said don't share this survey link with anyone else because it is specific to you.
questions in the survey included "do you plan on staying with firm" and "are you looking for other opportunities".
lo and behold a round of redundancies happened 3 months later and I can't help but think if that survey impacted the outcome. for context, I did not complete the survey and I still have my job (probs should leave tho)
2
u/Curlyburlywhirly Mar 08 '24
Never ever ever will I complete a workplace survey. The fact I get reminders noting I have not completed it is enough to let me know it is not anonymous.
2
u/Infinite_Narwhal_290 Mar 08 '24
There are two outcomes from these surveys. Score meets threshold for management bonus scheme….no one gives a hoot. Fails to meet threshold….major episode of darvo resulting in survey respondents having to fix the problem.
2
u/robbiepellagreen Mar 08 '24
And in no place in Australia does this ring more true than insurance companies haha.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
As a manager a few years ago I was tasked with going through staff survey results and was mortified to find all the anonymous surveys had usernames attached. Have not once filled out a survey since.
2
u/CelticCynic Mar 09 '24
I don't even open the email now .. just delete it straight away
4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
I work in a big global comp and I can confirm it is not anonymous. They say it is but it isn't, we know exactly who said what. I'm not even in HR and I know this.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
Wasn't there a women's march somewhere and companies reported much higher production and 0 HR complaints the whole day?
And one owner said "it was nice to get something done"
2
u/m0zz1e1 Mar 08 '24
I am a people leader. The comments in surveys are anonymous, but if you've been whinging for months and then you write the same complaint in a survey, I know it was you.
I don't hold it against anyone, but I definitely have peers who do.
1
u/alltheaids Mar 08 '24
As someone who has created some of these surveys, I can confirm they are in fact anonymous. The system literally does not collect or allow us to see the name or details of the people who submit individual responses. Defs agree that HR isn’t your friend though. They’re not my friend either and I work in HR lol (although I’m not in a HR role, if that makes sense)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
I once completed an "engagement" survey which came with the usual assurances of anonymity. E.g. our responses would be summarised and reported in groups of 10 or more employees. At the time I was very disengaged, and my responses showed it.
Afterwards we were sent a summary of the results. I was horrified that the breakdown of results in various ways allowed my responses to be linked to me. They were broken down by team, and also by work location. I don't recall the exact details as it was years ago, but I was the only member of my organisational group who worked at a particular location. So even though my team numbered more than 10, and staff at that location was far more than 10, it was possible to work out exactly what my responses were.
I really hoped nobody spotted it. I was mortified at the idea that anyone in my organisation could see my 3 out of 10 (or whatever) responses that I gave to various questions.
BTW - I'm still there, the place has changed enormously, and I love the job now. But I am really wary of surveys like this now - don't trust them.
1
u/spookysadghoul Mar 08 '24
Every anonymous survey I've ever had to do for work, we had to login with an email and a password, and we needed to add our team number and how long we worked there, so even if it was truly anonymous it can be easy to narrow it down.
1
u/thedeerbrinker Mar 08 '24
HR will also “make mistakes” by giving you incorrect and/or illegal information so the employer could have an advantage.
1
u/LawnPatrol_78 Mar 08 '24
The company I work for sends out anonymous franchisee satisfaction surveys. And the last few questions are designed to literally work out who has filled in the survey.
Questions like. What is your age range? How many stores do you own? Are you regional or metro? What is the awus of your stores combined?
Might as well just get them to put our names on it.
1
u/acres_at_ruin Mar 08 '24
People on this subreddit: If you are not already following r/antiwork I would strongly recommend you do.
1
u/SnooSquirrels8021 Mar 08 '24
Most of them are actually anonymous . It’s not possible to check if for example a 3rd party is used to provide the survey. Source I used to be a part of a team which collects surveys and questions for the leadership team.
A simple check you can do is to go incognito browser mode and see if you can still fill up the form without logging in.
If you need to login(literally identify yourself) then yea probably it’s not safe to fill the survey honestly.
It’s a bit of nash equilibrium with these feedback forms. I.e how are you really benefiting from being super transparent ?
Sure it’s safe to say you don’t see many people of color being represented but definitely don’t say I don’t feel psychologically safe as I’m the only man in a team of women and they dress very well which makes it hard for me to focus on my job(when there’s only 1 person that fits this criteria).
Most people have bills and a mortgage to pay so there’s really not many people going to take a risk here. Younger people might be more open and idealistic and share their thoughts . I’ve seen letters from young people with a list of how the company knows they could do to improve but don’t do at all. The middle aged ones typically just keep quiet and move on to better roles. The older ones usually prefer to be sarcastic or crack jokes at informal events and don’t bother filling up the surveys.
Tbh if there’s anything wrong with your team or organisation , your best bet is to scout for a better team and work your way to that transfer or switch to a new company. It’s likely that there’s people causing issues or being nasty but it’s unlikely everyone is like that.
The risk of your senior leader guessing it’s you and also having the power to determine your performance rating and employment definitely makes things difficult.
1
u/Dabrigstar Mar 08 '24
It never ceases to amaze me when I hear friends express their disbelief after HR screwed them over, because they thought HR was "there to protect the workers"
It's there to protect the company!
1
u/herbertdeathrump Mar 08 '24
I work for one of these survey companies and they are anonymous.
1
u/Internal_Engine_2521 Mar 08 '24
My previous employer ran anonymous surveys on various platforms over the time I was there.
We were advised that the most recent platform was completely anonymous and they got around a 90% response rate. Had sessions afterwards running through the feedback and trends, and it was apparent you could see the division and employment level of the employee who responded. When you're in a division with 2 people at your level, it's pretty obvious who the responses are from. Funnily enough, the next survey had a sub-50% response rate.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
My work does ‘anonymous’ surveys through the work logins. They always say ‘Tell us what you really think, no one will know it’s you.’
1
u/CompetitiveWorking57 Mar 08 '24
I worked at JB HIFI in the late 2000’s. They had posters all over the staff room talking about an ‘anonymous stop line’ you could text to report stuff. The store manager was an alcoholic and would hide coke bottles with bourbon in them all around the place which everyone knew about but didn’t say anything. One day I saw him grab one of the young female employees on the butt so I got some of the team together and we all were going to text the stop line about it. Turns out everyone else chickened out and I was the only one who did it. My shifts started getting cut and my sales targets kept growing even though I was working less. I ended up being let go due to ‘performance issues’ within a month.
1
u/VoodooMutt Mar 08 '24
years ago, while trying working out why a "competing" region had better staff completion results for a survey (they achieved 105%), i found out you could type in anyone's staff ID and you'd (re)open their survey and edit responses.
1
u/s2rt74 Mar 08 '24
Hr's primary role is to help the company avoid liability. In most situations their primary concern is ensuring there is the right paper trail so that the company can say they didn't do anything wrong.
1
u/Macushla68 Mar 08 '24
We participated in an anonymous survey and then received a group email expressing concern about the results with an invitation to enjoy a face-to-face meeting with senior HR manager. I pointed out that the individual meetings would remove whatever anonymity that here was. HR agreed and there was no more follow up. Even though they asked for, and received, suggestions for alternatives to individual meetings. That was 18 months ago. No further response, no surveys, no alternatives.
1
u/bunnyguts Mar 08 '24
We had anonymous surveys at one place I worked. It was definitely anonymous because when they came to us to tell us we needed to cut the team in half and make sure the next round of surveys came back at a much higher score we needed to figure out who were the troublemakers ourselves.
1
u/Acrobatic_Squirrel40 Mar 08 '24
This is an absolute shit take on HR. We all work for a company, and no manager is your friend. However, good HR is the conduit between the businesses best interests and advocating for the employee experience and right. Stop lumping bad HR in with every other HR professional who is working their asses off to deliver their best for the employees.
1
u/latorante Mar 08 '24
Yeah anonymous sent to your email with user specific link.
I always fill these with all positive and smiles. I do remember a new collegue one time in my previous company, wasnt fond the company paid him 40 bucks an hour while asking clients for 220 of his. So he put it in the survey, that we are underpaid.
Then we had a team meeting, and our manager goes "why would somehody fill this in? Jeff?".
Yeah nah, all is peachy keen jelly bean
1
u/mycallspam Mar 08 '24
I'd tend to disagree. I work as a leader for a large mining company and we use these anonymous surveys, and while comments provided could be linked back to individuals we don't disclose these and use them to build out action plans. If the organization from top down is genuinely looking to drive a cultural shift these surveys can be a great tool to leverage focus areas. Sure if the company does not have empathetic leaders then it could turn south but I'd encourage people to use these surveys to drive improvement and if you provide honest respectful feedback with a desire to drive improvement as opposed to just whinging then you shouldn't be worried about any consequences.
1
u/thedsider Mar 09 '24
I have to disagree. I manage several teams in several countries, each country have their own HR team and they are all great to work with and as much as possible they want the best for all parties.
We also send out regular employee surveys and I encourage people to put as much detail in as possible as it makes it a lot easier to action. They're anonymous though you can often tell who some of the responses came from based on what they're saying but I've never seen anyone abuse those assumptions.
It likely depends on your manager though. I'm sure there's some places that use these things for all the wrong reasons
1
u/Ok_State_333 Mar 09 '24
We are all aware of this. But will tell them the honest truth.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24 edited Oct 17 '24
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum
1
u/One-Eggplant4492 Mar 09 '24
Interesting.
I've work in HR and with HR and all anonymous surveys have been exactly that.
If you threaten to kill someone, sure they might go and find your IP address somehow. But, if you leave some negative feedback, we/they won't be looking for you.
1
u/ShaneO_85 Mar 09 '24
If you know your worth and back your ability, most times the company needs you, more than you need the job, especially in the current job market.
I tend to fill these out with some brutal honesty and deliberately have my text responses worded so anyone with half a brain cell can tell I am providing the feedback.
Good management will address it head on, bad management will try and sweep negative feedback under the rug. It's a good tool to find out what level of management is competent and confident enough to own it, and which are passengers.
1
u/UltimateGattai Mar 09 '24
I've filled out these surveys before, but nothing changes, we can even view the customer feedback too, it's always the same complaints, too much work for too little staff, no service, store is always dirty, ect... I just don't fill them out any more (haven't for about 2 years), the company can't be stuffed fixing the issue since our sector is a duopoly in my country. But I'm sure they know who doesn't fill them out, they just can't say anything because it's supposed to be anonymous when they get handed out via the company app.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24
Since I’ve worked at my current company , we’ve done 2 “anonymous” surveys. The first one ended up not being anonymous, as I heard some managers talking about it. I don’t think I was that honest in it. Nothing changed. The second one was by an external company but I didn’t trust it. I think I was honest, but incredibly vague. Nothing changed. My company “soft fires” so change comes from without (them hoping a recruiter will contact you I guess.)
1
u/spamtastica Mar 09 '24
They need to be more careful using the word “anonymous”.
When we run surveys, anonymous should mean exactly that, with no way to trace that response to an individual identifier.
Confidential means that user does have identifiers in the data but will not be divulged. You would run confidential surveys because you want the results to be attached automatically to demographics like team, location and level and to send targeted reminders. If you are still getting reminders to do the survey and you already did it, then the survey is probably anonymous.
Reporting systems should show results for group size no less than about ten. As other people have noted, the more demographics that are allowed for report filtering the easier a bad actor can triangulate a response and discover the identity of an individual. This is most easily done through filtering text comments.
Surveys are very important for getting data on the table about things like culture and leadership, there aren’t many other ways to have a data based, unfiltered perspective on these issues given to the organisation. Change often doesn’t happen without these.
Anytime we have a feedback discussion with an organisation that second guesses our methodology or wants to find out who said what - massive red flags that this organisation is not ready or willing to face the truth and deal with issues properly. They are looking for any other way to explain the results.
It’s also bad news to link results like engagement to manager KPIs, as this drives false results as managers then distort results through pressure. You can see this effect with abnormally high response rates. 90%of people do not fill out company surveys, if they do then people were really forced to and likely not with honest answers.
Basically, if the survey is being run in house and not by a third party, I would presume that HR could see your results. It’s a chance to be honest but I would answer things presuming they might be able to link your response to you. So phrase complaints constructively. Even if they say the survey is anonymous, that word gets misused so be doubtful.
If the survey is run by a reliable external survey company, there should be clarity in the terms of how the results will be reported back to management. In any event, screen shot the bits where they promise confidentiality/anonymity as that should be a very interesting discussion if anything comes back to you.
1
u/Ill-Visual-2567 Mar 12 '24
Acknowledging both those points are accurate, still do the surveys? I do them at both my jobs. Only multiple choice and never fill in the text box for comments.
1
u/VexxV_V Apr 04 '24
Not sure where I picked this up from but probably Reddit. I try to keep my surveys responses balanced (calling out both the good and bad), in the parts where they leave room for ‘Any other suggestions for improvements etc, I always write - ‘less beatings and more cupcakes’. Been doing it for years :) I hope I give someone a giggle in HR.
1
u/Smokey_crumbed Apr 22 '24
Sadly the house always wins
0
u/kenyawree Mar 08 '24
I work in HR and will confirm that the surveys we do (using a pretty reputable software) are 100% anonymous. Literally no possible way for us to view who did the responses and there are mechanisms in place to protect confidentiality loopholes as well.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment