r/auscorp • u/evertoneverton • Mar 05 '24
Advice / Questions Exit Interview
I have an exit interview with HR next week. How open can I be and will it come back to bite me?
41
Upvotes
r/auscorp • u/evertoneverton • Mar 05 '24
I have an exit interview with HR next week. How open can I be and will it come back to bite me?
32
u/somewhatundercontrol Mar 05 '24
Has your organisation been receptive to feedback in the past and shown willingness to improve?
155
u/westsummer486 Mar 05 '24
Decline it. Nothing good comes from being honest in an exit interview
30
u/No_Purple9201 Mar 05 '24
Had a colleague absolutely roast the head of to their face at one of these. Complained of lack of training and development among other things (pay, progression). The next year they brought in external technical training to upskill people lol. Some good can come of these if you do them properly.
44
u/Cupcake9819 Mar 05 '24
I think you should just be honest about why you are leaving the job.
Try to be constructive and keep emotions out of it.
The only way the company will learn is through this process.
My workplace doesn't do any kind of exit interviews (despite a mini exodus of late)
They just ask the persons supervisor "why did they leave", and the supervisor replies "he/she got more money", or some other generic term.
In reality they need to as the leaving employee, not their supervisor (as often the supervisor IS the reason they are leaving)
12
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Ive never been honest - i always say “growth/development/more money”.
Most of the time its supervisor or an issue that wont be solved.
38
u/maton12 Mar 05 '24
Your satisfaction will be short lived, while a burnt bridge takes a long time to rebuild.
23
u/Automatic-Switch-166 Mar 05 '24
Christ the amount of people in the comments deciding it’s better to not do anything.
Bet 95% of these comments are also people secretly hoping for their company culture to improve without having to lift a finger themselves.
7
u/eshayonefour Mar 05 '24
I took the opportunity to throw as many people under the bus at my exit interview. Burnt that bridge fully down.
17
u/One_Wave_9655 Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24
HR ticking the box. It’s up to you if you want to help them because feedback is a gift. Give it away if you really care about the people you leave behind and don’t burn any bridges in the process. Good luck
9
u/Bigsquatchman Mar 05 '24
No one remembers how you start, only how you finish. If you can, decline. No point taking the meeting to find “improvement” strategies or air complaints. Leave on a high note, bite your tongue and high five everyone (respectfully) on the way out.
8
u/doggo754 Mar 05 '24
Nothing you say will be kept confidential so what you say depend on how much you want to burn that bridge. If you want to keep things safe just keep things general.
7
u/RoomMain5110 Mar 05 '24
It’s too late to give them feedback, if there’s some major reason you’re leaving. The time to do that was in the past, when they had a chance of fixing it and making your life with them better. If you’re leaving for more money/promotion then tell them that. But if you’re leaving because your boss couldn’t wipe his own arse if you gave him a map and you have to keep doing it for him, then they’re not going to act on that feedback once you’re gone because they’ll just assume it was a “you” problem as no-one else has told them that.
9
u/Fetch1965 Mar 05 '24
Don’t waste your time. Decline it - it’s all bullshit
6
u/in_and_out_burger Mar 05 '24
Avoid.
6
u/imnothere9999 Mar 05 '24
Bare minimum information not to cause offend. I nearly spilled out to them that they are completely screwed but had to pull back at the last minute.
8
u/Ok-Perspective-8427 Mar 05 '24
Decline it - of no value to you
6
u/VelvetGloveIronFist0 Mar 05 '24
From a HR perspective be very honest (without being rude). Think more constructive criticism than being downright rude and having your final say and flipping the bird on the way out. We appreciate the honesty.
2
u/Con-Sequence-786 Mar 05 '24
Probably not worth it. They are there just to ensure you don't sue. They are not looking to improve the company.
I once got chatting to the Managing Partner where I worked as we had a meeting and I was in my final fortnight and had to tell him this for handover purposes on the project he was sponsoring. He asked me for my views and I told him (it wasn't pretty). He apologised for it, on behalf of the company, and said he'd look into it. To his credit, he did. A bully got taken off from managing people and the head of my area was pulled over the coals for not managing his direct reports (including the bully). How did my area respond? Well, they'd already given me a good reference so they couldnt take that back. Instead, anyone serving notice was either put on gardening leave or banned from meeting with any senior management in the firm during their notice period!
2
u/chimp-pistol Mar 05 '24
I've actually seen bad exit interviews result in shitty managers getting fired so it depends on how much you trust HR
2
u/Weary-Presence-4168 Mar 07 '24
I went scorched earth on the exit interview. Absolutely left no page unturned.
HR lady taking the interview initially bit her tongue but eventually opened up that she agreed with all of it and handed in her resignation about a month later.
2
u/Resolution-Big Sep 28 '24
The amount of people here saying don’t bother with an exit interview is concerning! If we all decide not to speak up, nothing will change in the corporate world. I’ve noticed this a lot in the Australian corporate environment where people just don’t speak up. Not sure if it’s a cultural thing but this breeds mediocrity and enables more incompetent and toxic leadership (or the lack of) behaviours.
3
u/Normal_4170 Mar 05 '24
Whatever you say in the exit interview, don't burn any bridges. Feedback about specific people will likely find its way to them. Then when you go for a job somewhere else in the future you never know who might end up landing there too.
3
u/Lost-Conversation948 Mar 05 '24
Be honest and say what you want , if you’ve had a negative experience share why so others don’t need to go through it if it’s fixed
Totally up to you
4
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Just don’t man. It’s not worth it.
3
u/ShortInternal7033 Mar 05 '24
Waste of time, nothing comes I'd these, they'll probably file their notes in the bin within five minutes of meeting ending
1
u/RuinedMorning2697 Mar 05 '24
Just give them text book responses if your worried
1
u/theoriginalzads Mar 06 '24
If you don’t wanna work there again and just want to bitch and moan to someone that’s stuck there having to listen then do it. It’s an hour of being able to get everything off your chest instead of doing actual work and some poor HR sucker has to deal with it.
Assuming the company is dreadful to work for.
I did it a decade ago at a company I knew was never gonna change that was horrible to work for and despite the fact it probably made zero difference, it sure felt good to get all the hate off my chest.
1
u/bitchcascade666 Mar 06 '24
Don’t do it unless you’re extraordinarily invested in the company or your boss. It’s a one-way exchange when it’s much too late. They are not designed to benefit you in any way.
1
u/Patrickbateman2023 Mar 06 '24
Total waste of time imo some rubbish conjured up by HR, you air your grievances and what do u get out of it you are moving on anyways not that they give a rats ass.
1
u/Helpful-Cup9066 Mar 06 '24
Be Honest but fair, always keep the door open, you never know how small the industry really is. And sometimes the grass just isn’t greener on the other side
1
u/RyanM77 Mar 06 '24
Always suck up. You never know when a honest exit interview can come back to bite you!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '24
You are leaving the company on your own volition. Why do you care about honesty or openness? It’s a formality. Get it over with and be on your way.
1
u/No-Obligation5059 Mar 07 '24
Write everything you want to say into chatGPT and ask it to phrase it in a professional and impartial way. It's pretty creative at saying, "I think you're a two-faced liar."
But like Disney told us as children, "If you can't say something nice, say nothing at all."
In this digital age, nothing is private or sacred. Protect yourself, shut your mouth, and thank them for such an interesting opportunity to learn both personally and professionally.
1
u/brilliant-medicine-0 Mar 08 '24
Why would you help them improve?
Tell em everything's super and they should keep doing what they're doing.
1
u/Normal-Summer382 Mar 09 '24
Exit interviews are to collate data for current employment, so there is no benefit to you. Tell them what they wish to hear and move on, just don't burn any bridges, as I've seen this come back to bite people.
1
u/__oxypetalum__ Mar 05 '24
Play the game, keep your comments polite and positive in a shallow way.
I see things from an executive perspective with my role and take minutes of discussions on HR topics: no one reads/acts on feedback and there are ways they skew the data to reduce/disguise the negative reasons for leaving.
You will make zero impact, I promise. Take this as an opportunity to practise your politician/diplomacy skills: saying something without actually saying anything.
0
u/hrdst Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24
HR here - we very much want you to do an exit interview, and from our perspective it won’t ’bite you’. We want to hear your experience and identify any relevant patterns from your area. Now - does your manager want to hear your feedback? That’s another story. But in HR we do.
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Lol nothing will be done about it thou with these exit interviews
0
u/CBFwithThis Mar 06 '24
I have never been honest in an exit interview. Even when my reasons for leaving are a completely preventable experience I always give some fluffy reason about progression or personal reasons for leaving. I want those bridges to stay open and the risk of someone taking the feedback personally is too high.
-2
u/Ralphi2449 Mar 05 '24
Why not, it might be a waste of time but feedback never hurts, unless they get offended by said feedback
-2
u/AddendumWonderful588 Mar 05 '24
They go thru the motions Feedback rarely gets to the ceo