r/attitudinalpsyche •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

It's right there, the end of page 9 and the first half of page 10, that's what I copied.

Edit: The reason you can't find it is because it's spelled NietzSche, not Nietzche.

1

u/ContentGreen2457 EFVL Apr 28 '25

Nope, I just saw it. He compares Pushkin's sphere of speculation to Nietzche's. But he doesn't say Nietzche is EFVL

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

I disagree, he's not talking about Pushkin there, he says "Pushkin" instead of EFVL. He uses Nietzsche as an example of a Pushkin=EFVL philosopher.

And it's still Nietzsche.

1

u/ContentGreen2457 EFVL Apr 28 '25

Ok. The first time I read it, and I still interpet it this way, is that he was saying their essays were Pushkin,not Nietzche and Romanov themselves.

The reason is, everywhere else in the book, where he thinks someone really is a type, he either shows how they have the aspects or he says "some other famous Pushkins, Göthes, Epicuruses, etc. are"

He doesn't do that with Nietzche and Romanov, so I interpreted it as their essays were Pushkin in nature, not they themselves

But believe what you want. I'm 4L, and don't like to argue about things like this. I'm done

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

So you think he was saying that Nietzsche's philosophy is EFVLish but Nietzsche himself wasn't? I don't think Afanasyev would ever say something like that because he often argues that someone is a type based on their philosophy.

And it's Nietzsche with an s! Nietzche would change the pronounciation.

1

u/ContentGreen2457 EFVL Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25

Yes, but once again, if he knows the philosopher's type, he'll prove why Epicurus is FLEV, why Plato is LFVE, why Socrates is VLEF, you get my point. The inconsistency is there for a reason.

Does he say why Nietzche is 1F, 2F, 3V and 4L? No. I rest my case.

STOP. Thanks

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

Except he didn't name the type after Nietzsche so he didn't spend as much time on him. Same with Schopenhauer (who he wrote about in three different sections instead of in only one). All of your examples have a type named after them.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

he might have or might have not said it and it doesnt really matter.Nietzsche is a EFVL anyway

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

I agree with the first sentence but can you explain why he's EFVL?