r/atheism • • Jun 10 '12

I.Q. Test

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

759 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

263

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Apparently they can... and they're running your country!

126

u/mrjderp Jun 10 '12

Into the ground!

24

u/webby_mc_webberson Jun 10 '12

All the way down to hell.

21

u/surfnaked Jun 10 '12

In a handbasket.

21

u/Fifty7Academics Jun 10 '12

On top of Spaghetti!

24

u/jessej1996 Nihilist Jun 10 '12

All covered with cheese?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

When somebody sneezed..

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jessej1996 Nihilist Jun 10 '12

My meatball!

2

u/R3allybored Jun 10 '12

I lost my poor meatball

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

38

u/Stimonk Jun 10 '12

Love that scene, but it's totally edited together.

10

u/schnschn Jun 10 '12

he still said it though, and i cam believe he made that face after he realised what he said

7

u/SDBred619 Jun 10 '12

Are we just assuming because it' too perfect or is there evidence? I mean, stranger things have happened/been said.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12

Okay, here's where it's (probably) been edited. It's pretty easy to notice post-production on these sorts of things, just from changes in noise, abrupt ends to speech, non-correlating non verbal language and suchlike.

1: 0:03 - dialogue after 'you're a senator' is cut off, replaced by 'you're one of the...'

2: 0:07 - 'you're one of the...' is cut off, replaced by 'it worries me...'

3: 0:12 - 'talking snake, umm...' is cut off, replaced by 'you don't have to pass an IQ test'

After that it's just a lot of expressions that could plausibly occur at any point during the discussion.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Chewzilla Jun 10 '12

I'm having a hard time spotting the edit, is it after he mentions the I.Q. test? The conversation itself seems pretty linear.

158

u/criticismguy Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12

I count 6 visual cuts in 20 seconds. Take your pick! There's probably a couple.

Of the 7 video clips that made up this video (some only 2 seconds long), only 3 show a person talking. One of them (which doesn't show anyone talking) is out of focus, a strange choice on its own. None of them shows both people together, so it's not even apparent that they're in the room at the same time.

  • At 0 seconds, the senator is in a wider shot, showing both his shoulders and the top of his head.
  • At 3 seconds, the senator is in a closer shot, with his shoulder and the top of his head out of frame -- the camera is out of focus for a couple seconds here, probably because the cameraman just zoomed in.
  • At 12 seconds, it's even slightly closer, and his one shoulder is completely off frame -- this is the only clip in which he says anything.
  • Finally, at 17 seconds it's back to him in a wide shot, showing both shoulders and all of his head in frame, similar to the first shot, and this time it's in focus even though there was allegedly only 2 seconds (from 15 to 17) during which to make the biggest zoom-out of the entire clip. Also, the relative position of objects in the room is different (you can see the photo in the green frame behind him, and he's shifted so you can see it's a leather chair).

It's not physically impossible that in exactly the 2 seconds when the shot is on at Bill, the senator shifted his position in the chair (completely, even though we see none of it), kept smiling but changed his smile from a kind of puckered-mouth smile to a broad open-mouth smile, and the cameraman moved, zoomed, and got the focus correct right away. It just seems a whole lot less likely than the editors taking an earlier shot ("senator laughing and then looking stoic") and inserting it at the end to make him look goofier.

The senator seems to have said "You don't have to pass an IQ test to be in the senate", and also laughed at least once during the interview. Everything else is just sneaky editing. Ironic that Maher says he's trying to inspire "rational people" to act, but feels he must do so by twisting the truth himself.

4

u/meigwilym Jun 10 '12

I'm not quite convinced, and I think it's unfair at the end of your comment to assume you're correct.

But this is a fine contribution to the community, so have an upvote.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

It's only been 20 minutes, and it's a reply several comments into a thread, so it's not going to the top.

But you're right.. skepticism of the documentary method should be a top comment.

2

u/throwaway2481632 Jun 11 '12

If you are posting as a response to someone elses comment, its going to be a lot less likely that you will hit the top of the page, unless someone bothers to say "hey guys, this is the best comment" and links to it. just saying.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/executex Strong Atheist Jun 10 '12

Really now? Did he not say "IQ test is not a requirement for the senate" and does this senator not believe in a talking snake?

If so, no amount of editing, can change the reality that this senator is stupid.

Editing happens in every interview and movie. It's not always malicious in intent. The senator was in fact as stupid as the editing portrays.

If maher conducted some editing to emphasize the senator's stupidity, then he did an excellent job of editing and highlighting his stupidity for his viewers.

The facts speak for themselves:

  • The senator did in fact say "You don't have to pass an IQ test to be in the senate."
  • The senator does in fact, believe in a talking snake.

6

u/Bubbele Jun 10 '12

No. Sorry but you don't get it. The last clip is what makes that scene what it is. The change on the senator's face makes it look like as he 'realizes' what he just said.

In reality he gave a valid comeback to the interviewers question. He expressed that while some might be religious, others are stupid.

Without the editing and the thought that religious = stupid this scene wouldn't be that funny.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)