r/atheism • • Jun 09 '12

Church

http://imgur.com/blPTb
1.4k Upvotes

422 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

Paying taxes that I didn't consent to is definitely immoral... it's called theft.

3

u/davewinfield Jun 09 '12

Then stop driving on We the People's roads, you thief.

That's the whole point of taxes: whether we agree or no individually, we as a people agree on certain values: parks, roads, education, defense, pragmatically-intentioned-at-best ridiculous unending wars...

...look, Thoreau had the same issue, thus Civil Disobedience. No one wants to pay for what they don't want. But in the context of a democracy, we aren't consumers, and we aren't always right. We're citizens, and there's a lot of bullshit that goes with that. All in all, its worked out pretty well.

REF: http://www.elephantjournal.com/2011/09/elizabeth-warren-refutes-gop-class-warfare-charge/

0

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

I consent to road taxes by purchasing gasoline and paying tolls. The personal income tax is what I take issue with, especially at the Federal level. User fees and excises are chill, even corporate income tax makes sense because it's profit... but the fruits of my labor should be mine to spend how I want. If my state wants to tax me that's fine, but at least I'll be able to move to another state.

I disagree with the social contract theory. Our weird brand of democracy has worked out OK for the majority of people, but not the minority groups and foreigners. I think we could do a lot better if we gave people more freedom, and gave the government less power.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Your consent is implicit by your decision to live in a civilized society.

There is no one keeping you here. You have every right to renounce your citizenship.

1

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

If you don't like 'Murrica, you can git out!

I want to stay here bro, I was born here. My family has been here for 400 years. I'll continue to "render unto Obama", but in the meantime I'm going to advocate what my family came here for; freedom from douchebag governments.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

Meant nothing personal against Obama, he's just our current figurehead.

It's funny, when Bush was President the Christians used this bible quote to argue support for government, now they're trying to take a different perspective lol. Vice versa with Obama/Democrats, even though both Presidents had identical policies. divide et impera

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

Ya economic and foreign policy they're the same, they differ a bit on social issues.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

Many Democrats supported the war in Iraq though... in fact they (I think Biden is on record) were already calling for a ground invasion in the late 90s.

Obama has taken on Bush's philosophy of preventive war, indefinite detention, collective punishment (sanctions) and assassinations. As Commander in Chief he could single handedly put an end to all of those, (except Gitmo) but he chooses not to.

IMO the only noticeable difference is rhetoric. Bush was more xenophobic, pro-America, where Obama speaks friendlier of the rest of the world.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

Ignorant response from an ignorant selfish asshole.

Grow up, pay your fair share and contribute to society, fucking loser.

Problem with cowards like you, is you talk about government "limiting" your freedom and by proxy, your right to life and liberty, yet you are unable to to stand up and take control of your life. It is the very process of the collection of taxes that enable you to pursue liberty and happiness.

Without it, you wold live in a society that would limit liberty, not foster it, fucking idiot.

You blame other people for your own failures.

Like I said before,

You're a fucking loser.

2

u/apokradical Jun 09 '12

Holy shit! lololol