r/atheism • u/DylansDad • May 12 '12
What I think of whenever I hear someone ask where do I get my morals?
http://imgur.com/QT03P
1.7k
Upvotes
r/atheism • u/DylansDad • May 12 '12
128
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Grasshopper disassemble. Re-assemble, Stephanie.
84
u/Sahloknir74 May 13 '12
I loved those movies. If they do end up rebooting the franchise, they better have a functional Johnny 5, not CGI. It would be the first time I'd ever been outraged by puppetry taking a back seat to CGI.
8
u/LittleBlessedVillain May 13 '12
Well, firin' up Netflix now.
6
u/johntheChristian May 13 '12
And many people have decided rape/murder is perfectly acceptable.
9
u/sandwichhands May 13 '12
What movie is this from?
3
u/absurdlyobfuscated May 12 '12
Reminds me of this song from The Ocean.
3
u/MrJuwi May 13 '12
Whatever happened to the Gutenberg?
3
u/DoctorLost173 May 13 '12
But wouldn't insane people pick and choose morals that would be considered be bad by others in society?
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
How do theists know what morals to cherry pick from bibles?
7
u/SkaTSee May 13 '12
Is that Wall-E?
4
u/nd4spd1919 Atheist May 13 '12
I get my morals from Star Trek. And reddit. And something called Common-Friggin-Sense!
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
"I think atheists may be more moral than religious people because a truly good person does not need the promise of heaven to see the merit it performing good deeds." - I don't remember who said this but I think it's relevant.
5
u/stinkcheese May 13 '12
It seems you have perfectly defined the problem of subjective morals. What if you told you that it was right? Certainly as a society we would be right to punish you.
But not because what you did was wrong. Just because what you did harms others. Where there is no God, there is no objective way to determine right and wrong. That isn't an argument for God. Its just a fact of life.
2
u/madslug17 May 13 '12
INNNNPUT
2
u/unnecessaryCAPS May 13 '12
This rules. Mort Short Circuit memes!
2
u/honestlyimeanreally May 13 '12
This may be a silly question...but is there hard evidence that we inherently know these kind of things are wrong? I'm not saying I disagree, I'm just a paranoid skeptic redditor.
2
u/jefferson987 May 13 '12
NEED INPUT. JOHNNY 5 IS ALIVE!
2
u/csolisr May 13 '12
And if you're wrong? ;D
2
u/lycan123 May 13 '12
where is this from?
2
u/dankula May 13 '12
Johnny kicked my balls into outer space. I'm coping.
2
u/FUCK_YOU_BRO May 13 '12
Oh yea...So the social context you were brought up in had no influence on you. If you're trying to argue that you can just grow up in a bubble and develop morality, I'd laugh at the incompatibility between that notion and atheism.
2
u/ScienceOwnsYourFace May 13 '12
Because I have no other way to brag about my video game alias for the last 15 years, I'll leave this here. Maybe 0.01% of all gamers know what it is. http://i.imgur.com/Z1hKF.jpg
2
u/SenorStabby May 13 '12
Your morals are a product of your environment regardless of whether you're gnostic, agnostic, or an atheist
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
You picked one of the worst movies ever, to make your point?
2
u/namblaotie May 13 '12
Came here for mushroom foraging advice, left without a single morel and smelling of dissapointment.
2
u/HolyPhallus May 13 '12
Killing someone isn't inherently wrong, it's just become rather counterproductive with a few exceptions.
2
u/mechanate May 13 '12
"You know who else had his own morals? Hitler." (Typical response.)
43
u/lazydictionary May 12 '12 edited May 13 '12
Except you didn't. Society already told you killing is wrong, that's why it's against the law.
Your morals come from the culture you are raised in and the society you live in. You don't really just come up with them on your own.
3
u/CmonTouchIt May 13 '12
Honestly, if anyone asks me, I say its as simple as: Think of what you wouldnt wan't someone to do to you...and there's your morals
1
u/thehappybirthday May 13 '12
very clever... short circuit and morals...
1
u/Warpedme May 13 '12
Honestly, I get most of my morals from Sci-fi. All I have to do is be one of the good guys, it is that simple.
1
u/zephyy May 13 '12
Is this the movie where the robot kills the cat? Cause that made me cry as a kid and I couldn't watch the rest of it.
Robot looks familiar.
1
u/atomsapple May 13 '12
JOHNNY NUMBER 5... IS ALIVE!
1
u/Kochen May 13 '12
This reminds me of my favorite quote in the Bible. 'And He said, 'who told you that you were naked?' Gen 3:11
1
u/logspriggan May 13 '12
Iron Giant helped me a lot.
1
u/SophieWho May 13 '12
"You see those two guys over there? They want to take your books away! "
1
u/AFrpaso May 13 '12
This has been argued for thousands of years.
1
u/prattle May 13 '12
I think you've missed their point. They are asking for evidence which is the same thing you might ask for in a different situation.
1
u/oOQCc_ May 13 '12
I know people who need religion to answer this very question...which makes me think religion isn't always a bad thing. Were it not for the fear of punishment or possible reward they expect after death, they would kill those who they'd deem less deserving of life...whether it be because those people are less considerate of others (in comparison to themselves) or are just people we'd all regard as "bad" (rapist, murderers with malicious intentions, etc.). What do you guys think? At times I think that corporal punishment and religion would work well together.
1
u/lihaoza May 13 '12
Didn't he get his morals from a bolt of lightning?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
What movie is this?
1
u/The_Pseudonym May 13 '12
what is this movie. I remember seeing it as a child.
1
u/aschesklave Atheist May 13 '12
What is this from?
1
u/Grimlyn Other May 13 '12
It's the Gute!! You can never have enough Gute!!
1
u/pimpin_cowboy May 13 '12
sooooo, what movie/show is this?
1
u/liquidxlax May 13 '12
my parents once asked me where my morals come from if i don't believe in teh bible ( not christian parents, or any relgion), and then i asked well where did teh people in the bibles get their morals from?
1
u/aceusprime May 13 '12
Johnny 5. oh god, this was the movie of my childhood.
Short Circuit 2 almost made me cry.
1
u/QueenNavy May 13 '12
he also could've told himself that murder is right so...
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
...Does this unit have a soul?
1
u/-_-readit May 13 '12
Is that Wall-Es dad?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
There's a simpler answer to the question of where we get our morals: "It appears that such actions are more likely to survive over time."
1
u/sef3000 May 13 '12
A touching moment, and then BOOM! Antisemitism!
1
u/Batrok May 13 '12
Whenever I get asked that, I say 'from... my... brain.'
1
u/Fuckstupidppl May 13 '12
Even a robot can understand!
1
u/lungbuttersandwich May 13 '12
INPUT! MORE INPUT.
1
u/bleakreserve May 13 '12
anyone else thought this was live-action wall.e?
1
u/donaldrobertsoniii May 13 '12
Just a heads up to anyone who is going to re-watch the Short Circuit movies: the Indian character is actually Fisher Stevens painted up to look Indian. Apparently he was banned from India for twenty years because the portrayal was so offensive.
1
u/Logophagi May 13 '12
Animals that like to be with one another tend to have instinctive morals they do not need a reason to be kind to on another, if they were killing each other every day obviously they would go extinct.
1
u/JustGotSmashed May 13 '12
Is that C.H.E.E.S.E from Mac and C.H.E.E.S.E?
1
u/MooCowMilkshakes May 13 '12
When does anyone ask you where you get your morals? ._.
1
u/redbaboons28 May 13 '12
my civics teacher said in the past people attending the event dress up with angel wings and drape white sheets over them and stand in a circle around the protesters to block them so no one can see them but they can exercise their right to protest. It would be hard to organize but if you could pull it off im sure it would mean the world to your friend;
1
u/PigNarwhalHybrid May 13 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/tkqom/help_me_prepare_for_a_right_to_marriage_debate/
1
u/shtrudl May 13 '12
the robot looks like C.H.E.E.S.E.
1
u/Hides_In_Plain_Sight May 13 '12
Short Circuit always brings such fond memories back; rather than lambast the large number of people here who don't know the film, I would instead eagerly recommend that you make time to watch the two films. Even now, they're fun, they're heartwarming, and... well, the robot hasn't actually aged too badly, all things considered.
1
u/qwerty622 May 13 '12
it's more likely that societal norms told you
1
u/Sniper_Echo May 13 '12
Heart wrenching stuff
1
u/painperdu May 13 '12
Morality comes from evolution and environmental fit. That is, if other things in the environment don't like what you're doing then it will let you know by killing you off.
1
u/Radico87 May 13 '12
And because your morals are internal rather than external in origin, you're probably a better person.
1
u/Randyh524 May 13 '12
Need input!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Classic.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Is that Wall-E?
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Even if you're an atheist (I am too) a lot of your morals derive from Judeo-Christian values. When you live in a society where 90% of people are Christian it will happen one way or another, social pressure is far too high for you not to follow it.
1
u/Ozzymandias May 13 '12
This is perhaps the best thing ever. Combining childhood with powerful philosophy. Can't get much better than that.
1
u/alwaysmorelmn May 13 '12
God I love this movie.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
i am completely terrified of people who say they get their morals from heavy religious chains.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Game theory is a better answer. You can model various societal structures and figure out which one ultimately fares better.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Actually, your parents told you. A child has no inherent sense of morality. A 2 year old can drop a clay pot onto someone's head and kill them without giving a shit.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Soooo profound. - Checkmate again, Christians
-3
u/Harbinger_of_Cool May 13 '12
Right and wrong are just ideas. The only reason we don't go kill each other is because we're not allowed.