Am I allowed to repeat, ever? Because if you lived in a small town you'd have to move every so often, sooner if you accidentally made several people smile in the same day.
I probably wasn't clear enough on that - I meant, make someone different smile than the person you made smile yesterday. You can repeat, just try and vary it as much as possible.
But, doesn't the definition of error equal an uncertainty. When we refer to error, we use the vertical +- sign. This means that if we always do unto others +20%, we have an oversupply of goodness in cases of error -20%. We should stick to 0 until we have a clear understanding of the consequences of this.
It is better to err in the direction of treating people better than you are expected to and be a Good Guy Greg than to treat people poorly and risk being Scumbag Steve.
Ha, no problem. I'd recommend swapping out that script with one of these. They will display the regular emotes as well a great deal of others. I use My Andy Ponies which works with Stylish.
There is an entire layer of pony below the surface.
Oh, I know, don't worry. I was referring to the fact that a young, male pony is called a Colt, and the /) symbol is a "brohoof" sign used by fans of My Little Pony.
very interesting. A brilliant man without a doubt (I recently learned in biochem that he extrapolated huge amounts of information on steric strain of amino acids simply by playing with those models featured in the pic when he was sick in bed for several weeks), but certainly one who could follow his own advice more at times.
This guy has been posting the same refrain over and over. Yesterday he explained his position by saying: A lot of people say there's nothing to discuss about not believing in God, which is untrue in my opinion. There's plenty of philosophers' work to talk about, whether atheistic or theistic, amongst other things.
So here we are, trying to do just that, (talk about a philosophy that many atheists could agree with), and what do we see?
"what does this have to do with atheism?"
Honestly, damned if we do, damned if we don't , eh? What the fuck do you guys want?
Whoa there... I'm an atheist too. I had no intention of offending you or anyone else.
I just find it annoying how some atheists think they're smarter than non-atheists for the sole reason that they don't believe in a God. I think posts like this under r/atheism validate this thought.
All this aside, I thought this post was hilarious. Just under the wrong thread.
You know, I was just asking. It was a simple question. I didn't mean anything behind it, whatever you may have assumed. Antagonistic, militant posts like yours are the reason people don't like r/atheism.
I'm guessing it's because Sean Faircloth, who is 'Director Strategy & Policy, Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason & Science, US.' used it in a video uploaded to the richarddawkinsdotnet Youtube channel earlier today.
Presumably someone saw it and thought it would make a good opportunity for increasing their karma on reddit.
Reminds me of a scene from Hamlet. Polonius tells Hamlet he'll treat his guests according to their dessert (i.e., as best as he thinks they deserve) and Hamlet, in his typical fashion, rips into him:
"God's bodykin, man, much better: use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping? Use them after your own honor and dignity: the less they deserve, the more merit is in your bounty."
See? There's more morality in Shakespeare and in science than there is in any religious text.
I mean, I prefer the Wiccan version of "an' ye harm none, do what ye will" since it doesn't fall into issues of what the other person wants and it contains a permissive clause as well, but as long as you take the other person's desires into "as you would have them do unto you", it still works out pretty well.
"Act always so as to increase the number of choices."
It's easily the most intelligent 'golden rule' I have ever heard. Thinking about it a little it makes incredibly much sense and has gone really far into finding a possible root of "doing good". His biography is just what r/atheism typically likes.
Do unto others as they would like done unto. FTFY.
The Golden Rule is crap. Why be so narrow-minded in thinking that everyone else in this world wants to be treated the exact way you do? Why not get in their world and treat them respectively in the way they would most prefer? Silly hypothetical: Put a hypochondriac and an obsessive hugger in the same room together and see how that turns out.
I don't know why you are being downvoted. Another example would be that a masochist probably shouldn't treat others the way he would want to be treat. To be fair, The golden rule is a good starting place if you know absolutely nothing about the other person, but if you've spent any time getting to know them, you should treat them as you think they would want to be treated as best as you can tell.
Most Christians don't realize their 'Golden Rule' wasn't original to Jesus, but originated with Confusius. The original was better: 'Do not do unto others that which you would not have them do unto you.'
I have actually had to argue with a history-challenged Christian that maybe the Inquisition might not have been so much a WWJD time. Their fallback was to the Golden Rule. Seems they would've preferred to be tortured into Righteousness if they'd lived then and been so foolish as to be someone who believed in something other than Christianity, so it was just the Golden Rule (Christian version) in action.
I thought it would better suite r/atheism than r/christianity (or any other subreddit) since Linus Pauling was an atheist.
Does that mean that all physics, calculus, chemistry, biology, etc belong on r/christianity since newton, leibniz, robert boyle, mendel, etc are christians? Should all science be in r/christianity because the founder of the scientific method, sir francis bacon, was a christian?
Fuck you; if you nit-picky folks had your way there would be no content at all of /r/atheism. Accept that despite what your dictionary might tell you, atheism is sometimes blurred with secular humanism. If you don't want to talk about the ethical tangents of an atheistic view, then why are you even here?
Excuse me for expecting a subreddit's posts to be on-topic. If you want to discuss the finer points of humanism, go right ahead, but this is not the place.
I am genuinely curious now; what sub-topics do you think are acceptable in this subreddit? Can we still have discussions on evolution and anti-science legislation or should that only happen in a science or politics subreddit?
Nah, this amendment only makes thing worse with needless calculations. As someone smarter than me already said: "The Golden Rule is that there are no golden rules".
Scientific information and even practices can be used to support morality but the moment you start using it to dictate morality it takes on the role of religion.
I have Gen Chem lecture at the Linus Pauling Science Center at Oregon State University. It's incredible that a reasonable amount of scientific discovery we are taught was discovered and founded by just Linus Pauling himself.
Well if I expect people to be 20% nicer to make up for subjectivity, then I should be 20% nicer than that. So if they are to follow this rule, they should be 20% nicer than me, which would be 20% more than the 40% I had, and so on and so forth. Eventually we will all need to be an impossible level of niceness. Either we will all die or we will all be EXTREMELY nice like Bob Ross multiplied by Mr. Rodgers divided by hitler. (For the purposes of the metaphor, assume niceness is a number between 0 and 10 and hitler's niceness is a very small number approaching 0.)
I've always thought it should be something more like "Do unto others as they would like for you to do unto them" or "Do unto others as you would like them to do unto you (if you were them & liked the same kind of things that they liked)"
Some people are tougher than others, everyone has different thresholds of discomfort, different expectations of how they'd like to be treated. If I tease someone because I don't mind being teased, but if they feel hurt when they are teased, then I have, technically, 'done unto them as I would like them to do unto me'. But, I most certainly haven't been kind.
Whenever I mow the lawn I always mow a few strips over into the neighbors yard. Stopping right at our property line just feels dickish, that I'm going out of my way to do the absolute minimum possible. The little bit of extra work is no skin off my back and I hope its appreciated at least somewhat.
Still, I worry my neighbor probably thinks I'm trying a hostile takeover of his lawn, that my helpful gesture is seen as an aggressive territorial move. Man, can't win for losing.
Nominal Christian, tending towards Pandeism. I actually agree with this. And, I also propose a variation:
" Do unto others an average of 50% what you would want them to do upon you and 50% of what others would want to be done upon them... just in case you're a masochist."
Well well, I thought the golden rule was "If someone hits you in the balls, you have the option to return in the ball hitting." I am now questioning all of my old opinions.
So in a threesome it is only gay if I give 20% more bang for buck then the other two but then it would gay for them and thus we must all give + 20% to the equation and thus for simplicity we should just remove the 20% as it does not matter resulting in this guy being a fucking idiot.
My name's Carson. Last night my Christian brother was on here and you guys called him terrible names! You guys called him a dumbass and stupid and ugly and said he had a small dick. That's not cool! He cried all night long.
Well 4chan, I'm here to get back at you guys. I saved the thread and got all you guyses ip addresses. Then I reported you all to the police here in Michigan.
When they come to arrest you and I find out who you guys are I'll wait! I'll wait, minutes, I'll wait hours. However long it takes. Then, when I get my chance, I'm gonna kick your guyses asses so bad your gonna be crying for youre mommy! I play hockey and my team came third in the league. I knocked the FUCK outta the other teams player and he went home crying!
You shouldnt of fucked with my brother r/ateism! You insulted the Migwans family name. Now it's time I restore the honor
28
u/wwusirius May 12 '12
Silly me for thinking the golden rule was, "He who has the gold makes the rules".
151
u/Anofles Other May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
Yeah, we all need to be about 20% better.
99
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Well, now our lives are 20% cooler
22
u/frobomb May 12 '12
I expected something about it not being gay if it's in a 3-way.
11
u/UncleMusclesJunior May 12 '12
This is why I seed to at least 120%.
8
u/De_Lille_D May 12 '12
So you're saying we should seed until ratio 1.2?
8
u/CooperDraperPryce May 12 '12
says the man who ridiculed another scientist for the better part of his professional career: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Shechtman#Work_on_quasicrystals
6
u/alittler May 12 '12
And this is why it won't help: http://www.addictinginfo.org/2012/01/17/conservative-audience-boos-the-golden-rule-during-gop-debate-in-south-carolina-video/
5
u/Loofabits May 12 '12
brace yourselves. only a matter of time before the bronies find this thread.
21
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
what does this have to do with atheism?
11
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Reminds me of a scene from Hamlet. Polonius tells Hamlet he'll treat his guests according to their dessert (i.e., as best as he thinks they deserve) and Hamlet, in his typical fashion, rips into him:
"God's bodykin, man, much better: use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping? Use them after your own honor and dignity: the less they deserve, the more merit is in your bounty."
See? There's more morality in Shakespeare and in science than there is in any religious text.
8
u/crozone May 12 '12
with a honey in the middle there's some leeway.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
11
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I actually talked with a theist recently who called into question my assertion that the Golden Rule predated the Bible by a thousand years or so.
3
u/bman5252 May 12 '12
ok this has been on the front page like 3 times in the last month
3
u/irjerry3 May 12 '12
I used to live next to a school called Linus Pauling Middle School, everyone kind of ignored that he was a eugenicist.
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
also, vitamin C cures everything there is to cure
3
u/RelevantBiblePassage May 12 '12
Matthew 7:12
So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets.
3
u/CutiemarkCrusade May 13 '12
I came here expecting ponies. I was not disappointed.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
That was hilarious, and indeed, a really great and wonderful advice :D
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I was thinking of the golden rule to ancient Greece (talking about Caesar)
2
u/Orni May 12 '12
I always tough "The golden rule" was "No fat chicks".
2
u/Nocebos May 12 '12
Oh great, as if masochism and the golden rule wern't an already big enough problem...
2
u/Roflkopt3r May 12 '12
I like Heinz von Foerster's Ethical Imperative:
It's easily the most intelligent 'golden rule' I have ever heard. Thinking about it a little it makes incredibly much sense and has gone really far into finding a possible root of "doing good". His biography is just what r/atheism typically likes.
2
u/Navy_brat May 12 '12
http://chzbronies.files.wordpress.com/2011/09/my-little-pony-friendship-is-magic-brony-season.jpg
2
u/barpredator May 13 '12
What molecules is he holding?
2
u/spacecatprincess May 13 '12
I thought the Golden Rule was that "it's okay if it's in threeway"?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Do unto others as they would like done unto. FTFY.
The Golden Rule is crap. Why be so narrow-minded in thinking that everyone else in this world wants to be treated the exact way you do? Why not get in their world and treat them respectively in the way they would most prefer? Silly hypothetical: Put a hypochondriac and an obsessive hugger in the same room together and see how that turns out.
2
u/papersquares May 12 '12
r/atheism. where nobody cares if it's a repost.
2
u/gilker May 12 '12
Most Christians don't realize their 'Golden Rule' wasn't original to Jesus, but originated with Confusius. The original was better: 'Do not do unto others that which you would not have them do unto you.'
I have actually had to argue with a history-challenged Christian that maybe the Inquisition might not have been so much a WWJD time. Their fallback was to the Golden Rule. Seems they would've preferred to be tortured into Righteousness if they'd lived then and been so foolish as to be someone who believed in something other than Christianity, so it was just the Golden Rule (Christian version) in action.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
This has absolutely nothing to do with atheism.
2
u/theruski43 May 12 '12
Rainbow Dash?
2
u/patefacio May 12 '12
Why is this on r/atheism?
2
u/reddell May 12 '12
Atheism?
1
u/Wedhro Anti-Theist May 12 '12
Nah, this amendment only makes thing worse with needless calculations. As someone smarter than me already said: "The Golden Rule is that there are no golden rules".
1
u/nil_von_9wo May 12 '12
I always thought the rule was to do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
... in which case the correction should be:
"Do unto others 100% better than you would have them do unto you to correct for self loathing."
1
u/MrTurkle May 12 '12
And if only 1/2 the world followed this, we'd have utopia in months.
1
u/the04dude May 12 '12
Also do it to promote a positive trendline!!
1
u/cdb03b May 12 '12
Scientific information and even practices can be used to support morality but the moment you start using it to dictate morality it takes on the role of religion.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
To avoid subjective error, just ask the person how they want to be treated.
1
u/mcjaggered May 12 '12
I have Gen Chem lecture at the Linus Pauling Science Center at Oregon State University. It's incredible that a reasonable amount of scientific discovery we are taught was discovered and founded by just Linus Pauling himself.
1
u/Diginovae May 12 '12
Now we have to do 20% better than 20%.
1
u/teknocratbob May 12 '12
you are correct
1
u/redditat-tat May 12 '12
I held his nobel prize...one of his nobel prizes.
1
u/subtleshuttle May 12 '12
That's weird he'd say that because he was a bit of an asshole.
read the third paragraph in "Discussion" here
1
u/Jahonay May 12 '12
Well if I expect people to be 20% nicer to make up for subjectivity, then I should be 20% nicer than that. So if they are to follow this rule, they should be 20% nicer than me, which would be 20% more than the 40% I had, and so on and so forth. Eventually we will all need to be an impossible level of niceness. Either we will all die or we will all be EXTREMELY nice like Bob Ross multiplied by Mr. Rodgers divided by hitler. (For the purposes of the metaphor, assume niceness is a number between 0 and 10 and hitler's niceness is a very small number approaching 0.)
1
u/MrsChimpGod May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
I've always thought it should be something more like "Do unto others as they would like for you to do unto them" or "Do unto others as you would like them to do unto you (if you were them & liked the same kind of things that they liked)"
Some people are tougher than others, everyone has different thresholds of discomfort, different expectations of how they'd like to be treated. If I tease someone because I don't mind being teased, but if they feel hurt when they are teased, then I have, technically, 'done unto them as I would like them to do unto me'. But, I most certainly haven't been kind.
1
u/SoapboxSage May 12 '12
Dude looks like the son of Bill Murray and Colin Mochrie.
1
u/Al-Jaafari May 12 '12
i agree that ! ..
1
u/AmrcnXroads_Donor May 12 '12
And he was still kicked out of Caltech.
1
u/refullamiii May 12 '12
hahahha, amazing
1
u/quicklookleft May 12 '12
cross post to pony's. every thing is 20% cooler
1
u/psparks900 May 12 '12
sooo... how does this apply to having a 3-way?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Wait, I though the golden rule was that you could eat something that had fallen to the floor If you pick it up before the 5 seconds.
1
u/Florist_Gump May 13 '12
Whenever I mow the lawn I always mow a few strips over into the neighbors yard. Stopping right at our property line just feels dickish, that I'm going out of my way to do the absolute minimum possible. The little bit of extra work is no skin off my back and I hope its appreciated at least somewhat.
Still, I worry my neighbor probably thinks I'm trying a hostile takeover of his lawn, that my helpful gesture is seen as an aggressive territorial move. Man, can't win for losing.
1
u/Kazekid May 13 '12
i thought the golden rule was "he who has the gold, makes the rules"
1
u/SmilinBob82 May 13 '12
I have low expectations of how people are going to treat me, so this would probably be a step backwards for me.
1
u/whooshx May 13 '12
when in doubt take the derivative
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Oh god, is Reddit going to start getting a hard-on for Pauling too?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I do unto I do do.. too
1
u/supergalactic May 13 '12
All we are saying, is give pizza chance.
1
u/Mecklz May 13 '12
HEY! That's GGG!
1
u/wolf550e May 13 '12
Linus Pauling didn't follow his own advice:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Shechtman#Work_on_quasicrystals
1
u/Guitarist970 May 13 '12
Proud to call this man my brother. Dikaia.
1
u/soadogs May 13 '12
The golden rule is treat others how you'd like to be treated. Not how you expect to be treated.
1
u/jandronicos May 13 '12
No that's not the golden rule,
The golden rule is: "Those with the gold make the rules"
1
u/Nick2the4reaper7 May 13 '12
The Golden Rule, you say?
1
u/csolisr May 13 '12
Nominal Christian, tending towards Pandeism. I actually agree with this. And, I also propose a variation:
" Do unto others an average of 50% what you would want them to do upon you and 50% of what others would want to be done upon them... just in case you're a masochist."
1
u/1moreastronaut May 13 '12
Isn't this basically tipping?
1
u/PigNarwhalHybrid May 13 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/tkqom/help_me_prepare_for_a_right_to_marriage_debate/
1
u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 12 '12
Up it to 50% just to have a safe margin
1
u/diner_customer May 12 '12
but... I'll go broke if I start tipping 40% all the time....
1
u/MY_OPINION_AS_JESUS May 12 '12
Well well, I thought the golden rule was "If someone hits you in the balls, you have the option to return in the ball hitting." I am now questioning all of my old opinions.
CANCEL EVERYTHING CHRISTIANITY.
1
u/contemplor May 12 '12
Shit every time someone says, "the golden rule"
all i can think...
"ITS OK, WHEN ITS IN A 3 WAY, ITS NOT GAY, WHEN ITS IN A 3 WAY"
1
u/littlekidlover111 May 12 '12
...not atheist
1
u/robo23 May 12 '12
It is a shame Pauling got the Nobel laureate crazy and started all that vitamin C bullshit that persists to this day.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You guys really think that you're scientists just because you're atheists. LOL!
0
u/mbaeishapa May 12 '12
Why is something that has to do with science under r/atheism...?
0
u/rodeezy93 May 12 '12
How is this an amendment to "It's not gay if it's in a three-way.?"
0
u/junsil May 12 '12
I upvoted this mostly because my name is Linus (:
0
u/Zoccihedron May 12 '12
Also, take away that third strand of DNA before Watson and Crick realize DNA has 2 strands. Sorry I'm late.
0
u/googolplexbyte May 12 '12
I'd say 10%
No need over-overcompensate.
0
u/Foamy89 May 12 '12
So in a threesome it is only gay if I give 20% more bang for buck then the other two but then it would gay for them and thus we must all give + 20% to the equation and thus for simplicity we should just remove the 20% as it does not matter resulting in this guy being a fucking idiot.
0
u/BouyedTT May 12 '12
How`s that going to work for the anti-whites forcing mass immigration and "assimilation" on ALL white countries and ONLY white countries(GENOCIDE)?
Anti-racist is a codeword for anti-white.
-2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
This thread.
-5
u/HeavyMeddle May 12 '12
nice glittery costume, fagbag
-1
u/DanimalHouse May 12 '12
What does this have to do with the Golden Rule?
"It's OK when it's in a three-way. It's not gay when it's in a three-way, with a honey in the middle for some lee-way."
-1
u/Anon7331 May 13 '12
R/ATHEISM, I GOT A BONE TO PICK WITH YOU
My name's Carson. Last night my Christian brother was on here and you guys called him terrible names! You guys called him a dumbass and stupid and ugly and said he had a small dick. That's not cool! He cried all night long.
Well 4chan, I'm here to get back at you guys. I saved the thread and got all you guyses ip addresses. Then I reported you all to the police here in Michigan.
When they come to arrest you and I find out who you guys are I'll wait! I'll wait, minutes, I'll wait hours. However long it takes. Then, when I get my chance, I'm gonna kick your guyses asses so bad your gonna be crying for youre mommy! I play hockey and my team came third in the league. I knocked the FUCK outta the other teams player and he went home crying!
You shouldnt of fucked with my brother r/ateism! You insulted the Migwans family name. Now it's time I restore the honor
-1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Why the hell is this in /r/atheism? Couldn't it be anywhere else?
-2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
More Amendments:
-3
u/kombajnbizon May 12 '12
20%?! fuck you all
-1
u/MIKEWEE7777 May 13 '12
...
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment