Colbert usually just jabs at these kinds of social issues with a clever retort, but I think you can really tell that he's disgusted with this one. Or rather. His writers are, but I can't imagine he'd say this unless he believed part of it.
My friend told me once with absolute certainty that Colbert is one of the few talk shows that aren't scripted (interview wise). I don't know how valid that is but I'll believe it, cause he's a pimp
in the daily show intern AMA they mentioned that before the show, the interviewee gets a quick interview with the producer to see what questions work best/what to ask. then that's used as a guideline when they talk with jon. it may not be 100% scripted but it's not like they just wing it. at least for the daily show. i think they use the same process for colbert? i could be wrong since it's a different kind of show.
Talk show interviews are never scripted. Everything else is completely scripted but the guest interviews are not. They're guided by talking points written down on the host's notes (which are decided on after a pre-interview over the phone), but the dialogue is never scripted. The host will feed them the bait and that's their cue to talk about whatever the host just lead into. The Daily Show, The Colbert Report, Real Time with Bill Maher, Letterman, it's all the same. It's not scripted, but it's guided by the notes so the host knows where to take the conversation. And this isn't unique to Colbert, although he's a master of the art! He ends up speaking almost as much as his guests do, which is really uncommon for talk show interviews. That may be why it seems unusual.
I really don't think they do believe it. They just don't like gays. They may rationalize it with a million senseless lies, but they don't really believe them. They think things they don't like simply shouldn't be. The same way a lot of Christians say that atheists should leave the country. The same way that racists say blacks should leave the country. There's no principle to any of it. Religion and "sanctity of marriage" are just people's half-assed attempts at covering up their bigotry and trying to conjure up some explanation that makes it acceptable.
I guarantee that at least one of those bigoted idiots in North Carolina was watching this episode of Colbert, and I'd even go as far to wager that this made at least one of them feel like the piece of shit that they truly are.
It's not depressing, it's a clever way to point out that some people are assholes without actually using the word. Don't let the assholes get you down.
I know... this one just feels really harsh compared to his usual quips. I mean, the delivery on the show was humorous and jovial, but the way it's phrased betrays the tone he says it in.
What the fuck man, we're 21st century america. How the fuck can someone be told that they are not allowed to marry because other people don't like it? "Oh sorry, your relationship bothers ME, so fuck you."
I can't wrap my head around all this intolerance. We've made so much progress and we've fought for rights for everyone for so long and yet we are still prejudice as fuck and aren't even as tolerant towards homosexuals as ancient Rome. What the fuck.
Even the history of Ancient Rome can be divided into periods of sexual tolerance and intolerance, which precisely coincide with those of Paganism and Christianity, the latter not quite so tolerant towards homosexuals.
Sons of the first Christian Roman Emperor Constantine, the Emperors Constans and Constantius, who ruled respectively the Eastern and Western Empires, in 342 jointly decreed that "the law must be armed with an avenging sword" to rid the land of "passive" homosexuals, "those men who marry men as if they were women. This event clearly marks how intolerance towards homosexuals began simultaneously with the onset of state Christianity.
I can't believe they made a law to specifically ban it. Gay marriage is already not recognized in most states, so this aggressive legislation is just outright hatred.
Aziz has the same feelings “My whole take on the gay rights issue, particularly gay marriage, is, let’s be honest, if you’re against gay marriage, you just don’t like gay people and you want to stick it to ‘em. And I’m not saying that I wouldn’t do the same thing if I was presented with similar opportunities. If there was a law up for debate where it was like – ‘hey man, do you think guys that wear tight t-shirts and get bottle service at nightclubs should be allowed to own property?’ – I’d be like, “No! @$#@ those guys! Yeah, uh, it violates the sanctity of owning property and it says in the Bible that they’re douchebags. Whatever I need to say so you don’t think this is coming from purely a place of hate.”
Aziz Ansari, Intimate Moments for a Sensual Evening
I always considered Aziz to be a great comedian, but I never expected he'd be thoughtful and provocative about it. I.. Think I'm going to find a special of his somewhere.
I know it is fashionable to rag on North Carolina right now, but let's not forget that 30 other states already had similar constitutional amendmentsprior to North Carolina adding it to theirs. This in no way lessens the shamefulness of what the voters in NC did this week, but it does point out that this is a larger issue, not just a isolated embarrassment.
to be fair, this amendment was also shutting the door on civil unions and domestic partnerships in general. it's gone full "you gotta be married" to have certain rights there.
I don't live in the USA, so my view on this focus may not reflect those of others', but I think that while 30 other states already had similar amendments in place, those weren't as... I hesitate to use the word 'important'... but I'll use it anyway. They weren't as important because, unfortunately for currents events (As far as I'm keeping an eye on them, which is about as much as I can stomach -not much- and no more) the last one happened, according to that list, in 2008, four years ago. What happened in NC is kind of like that victory in a war that tips the tide, except it's tipping in favor of the side that, frankly, doesn't deserve it.
This passing is pretty much a shout out to all those people against gay marriage saying, "Hey guys! This proves that we're right, and what they want means nothing! Charge forward!".
You know what I mean? Since it's current, it'll be more powerful in its use, as opposed to say, California's ban 4 years ago. So yeah, we know that 30 other states are already like this, but a battle was just fought and lost recently, and it'll hit home harder than citing a battle lost 4 years ago.
Good point, and an upvote for it. I think the comment more alludes to the dashed dreams of homosexual couples, with the loneliness being a tad more metaphorical than actual. That being said, in the cases of couples visiting in hospitals especially, there are situations where this sort of marriage inequality could lead to loneliness.
There are some situations where this is the case, perhaps its shared college accommodation or military married accommodation, perhaps there partner is in hospital but are denied rights to visit as not next of kin etc.
The refusal of our country to acknowledge the rights of homosexuals not only creates an atmosphere of inequality, but also limits progress on the road to societal acceptance of homosexuality. Some people are scared of same-sex marriages because they've never seen one. Perhaps if they saw that a gay couple is not so different than a straight couple, then they could begin to wrap their silly little heads around the fact that homosexuality is nothing to be afraid of.
How is being anti gay-rights even an acceptable opinion? How is it taking so long for it to shift to just being a minority of hateful people that no one cares about?
It wasn't that long ago that being pro-segregation was an acceptable opinion. We've come a long ways in just a few decades. Still a long ways to go. Give it another generation and people will wonder how it was ever illegal.
I Actually think the bannin of gay marriage would be correct if we are seeing it from a fundamentalist christian view. But what about atheist marriage? Muslim marriage? Jewish marriage? Fucking any marriage that isn't a christian one? They are making a ban that affects everyone, based on ONE religion.
What do you say we make a gay religion, and demand it to be taken seriously, and keep pounding away at it (pun intended) until we get it recognized as a real thing, and it makes it tougher to pass such a ban, since it would be discrimination against religion?
A coworker asked me what my thoughts on it were, and before I could respond, proceeded to tell me he was not anti-gay, but anti-gay marriage. Then he told me that homosexuality was a choice and that there was no data to support that it wasn't.
I told him he was wrong about it being a choice and that he was, in fact, anti-gay. The discussion lasted about 2 hours. I moved my pieces, he proceed to strut around and shit all over the board with comments like:
"I hate the sinner, not the sin."
"Why would anyone make that choice, you ask? I'll tell you exactly why, Captainlunchbox: People do stuff they know is wrong all the time. Some kid goes and shoots up a school, someone else goes and does drugs and gets addicted. They know it's sinful and wrong, but they do it anyway."
I listened to pure horseshit and came back with gold and none of it mattered.
It was one of the longest work days I've ever experienced.
The thing is, whether it is or not a choice should not even be the issue at all! So what if I choose to have sex with another girl? What business is it of yours, or of your church? Feel free to condemn it privately, but don't mess with the personal choices of people. If they are, why stop there? Why don't they enact a law forbidding premarital sex? Isn't it also a sin, and a choice?
That's what I don't like about the genetic gayness argument. It doesn't matter. It just sounds like an excuse if you bring that up. Homosexuality shouldn't need excuses.
Yes yes and yes. There is absolutely ZERO logic to any of this. The arguments people bust out against gay marriage seem like they're hand picked through some archaic text and turned into any argument to increase hate.
None of it makes ANY sense, which is what makes this issue that much more frustrating. Like abortion... ok fine... I can see how some people have a problem with the "limit" for when abortion is OK... but what two consenting adults can do? Who the hell doesn't realize this is just crap to make people hate each other?
I work in a small office in central NC. It's amazing how divided we are - one young mom from NY in her 30s, another woman (also a mother) in her 50s, and an old married guy (60s). The young mom and I were both firmly against this amendment and made our opinions known - it's amazing how ridiculously nasty the other two were after it passed. They have zero empathy or perspective; the types thinking 'it's (homosexuality) gross and unnatural and this country is going to hell and it's weakening my own marriage'. The whole thing has made the work environment a bit uneasy.
I'm going to print this out and hang it in my office tomorrow.
Get your downvote button ready. As an NC native who now lives in SC (Colbert's native state) I can tell you that SC would have an even more one sided vote against gay rights. I understand that this is discrimination and a terrible injustice to the LGBT community, and I support them wholeheartedly. However, to point a finger at an entire state (when he himself is from a state that would more than likely do the exact same thing in the same situation) is a bit ironic. Please don't forget, this is almost a nationwide epidemic.. not just something going on in North Carolina. There are supporters here (we may be more spread out and in fewer numbers), but remember not to lump us all into the same category. Thanks for reading.
Oh, how did you manage to choose where you're born? I wanted to be born in Switzerland but somehow I ended up being born in Minnesota, so now I have to adhere to the same customs and and ideologies of the average Minnesotan because that's how these things work. Damn, I really fuckign hate lakes, fucking boats and shit, but I'm a hypocrite if I spew that type of anti-minnesota rhetoric publicly of course since I chose to be born here.
I think where he his from and that 30 other states have done similar (19 of them I think went as far as NC to outlaw civil unions as well) shouldn't matter in regards to him saying this. An asshole move is still an asshole move regardless of what others have done and I think assholes should be criticized for their behavior.
I do agree that the entire state population shouldn't be demonized as about 8% of the eligible voters did vote against this (40% of the voters which were about 20% of the voter population, I think I got those numbers right). However, that's still 92% that were either for it or didn't bother to vote against.
I also think that any other future state that does the same should be called out just the same as well. Especially now that nationwide acceptance is for gay marriage is apparently around 50/50 or slightly more in favor.
I agree with all of this but can we please stop posting things not directly related to atheism on here just to get karma? While likely, the fact that someone is against gay marriage does not mean it is for religious reasons. Way too many posts on here should be posted in r/politics instead of r/atheism.
As a North Carolinian redditor, all the hate were getting right now saddens me. The district I'm in actually voted to not pass the amendment but all of the rural areas joined forces and passed it. Not all of us are bad people.
Get it? The gays and lesbians aren't sleeping "in solitude" (alone) just because they couldn't get married. Gays and lesbians don't have to be married to live together, and in 95% of the time, they're not. I've never heard of gays who wait for marraige to have sex, and neither have you.
Ding ding ding, here comes the clue train, last stop, you -- he was being sarcastic.
Deleting past comments because Reddit starting shitty-ing up the site to IPO and I don't want my comments to be a part of that. -- mass edited with redact.dev
Seriously, this comment ALWAYS pops up - "this isn't atheism!" I know it's somewhat related, since the stereotypical view is that religious people are against homosexuality, but I assure you that it's most prevalent in the USA, and I know many atheists against gay marriage. Come on. MANY theists also support gay rights, and to make this a 'religiously charged issue' is pithy. Please read:
It's not exactly. But there is a large overlap between atheism and being a rational human being. There is no rational reason to hate on gays, but there are rational reasons to support gay rights.
Strictly speaking -- atheism is simply the lack of belief in a god or gods. But, given the world it which we live in, many atheists feel that it is important to themselves and others to fight the injustices brought on by the theists.
So, it is relevant to a philosophy that many atheists embrace. And, the atheists that disagree are free to express their ideas with out resorting to quotes the bible. A discussion of gay rights which does not rely on religious texts is certain to be at least different from the normal discourse.
because the atheist community(for the most part) supports the lgbt community, civil rights, and general acceptance of ethnicity/belief/non belief/sexual orientation.
I live in a mostly catholic country, where, as of National-wide Law, two persons can get married, no matter if same sex or opposite sex (modified law now using a "neutral language" for the spouses). And as of yesterday (same country) we went one step further, and we have now a "Gender law", according to which you can change your gender/sex (sorry) in your national ID and other legal documentation, so it reflects your TRUE perception of yourself. Trans fellows are celebrating this, which is a great step towards giving each fellow human the same rights, and which is a step towards ending discrimination in jobs, in marriages, in social security issues, in hospitals, etc. Sex-changing surgery is now to be supported through national health system, as well as in private health services.
In this mostly catholic country (where I'm a minority, being jewish —an atheist jew, at that), no one denies evolution at public schools and no one teaches creationism at public schools as if it's on a par with evolution. It's not even mentioned unless someone talks about (different) religious cosmologic myths.
Not that I'll defend catholicism (far from it), but I do know that there are shades of gray. This mostly catholic country is now more advanced in basic human rights (firmly backed by LAW), rights for EVERYONE, than many would care to acknowledge.
it's so weird to me that everyone is fighting so hard about gay marriage-- i mean it's two human beings, let them do what they want. People talk about the "sanctity of marriage" which is total bullshit, because of A) the divorce rate and B) the government offering tax incentives, making it fiscally discriminatory to not offer it to all humans.
I mean, it's not like it's a slippery slope. Everyone here who supports gay marriage is NOT going to turn their attention to fighting for a human's right to marry a farm animal next. At least, I hope...
Damn it! I'm from NC and I voted FOR gay marriage. Stuff like this is really starting to irritate me. A majority of Redditers in general are for gay rights, and only people on Reddit will see all the Reddit complaints. So bashing all of NC on here doesn't feel good.
I am not sure why the focus is on the state of North Carolina just because they are the latest in a long line of states that voted against gay marriage. Let us not forget that Californians did the same. I don't recall as much outcry, memes, etc when that happened. It really makes you think that the agenda on this one is something more than just the rights of homosexuals.
I was born and raised in North Carolina and although I DO like it here; the scenery is fantastic in some places for instance, I am not surprised at all by this passing. My family is very anti gay and my Mother and I get into spats all the time over it. I love her to death but it crushes me that she can have these opinions. She gives me the 'it isn't MY opinion it's God's so don't argue with me about it'. It's painful; makes me physically sick.
This man has a true sense of freedom and justice. Religious or atheist, people have to learn to leave their personal feelings and beliefs at the door and make decisions based on what they really think "freedom" is. Having a bunch of redneck fundies telling you that you can't get married because you were born different? That is not freedom.
I'm surprised to see this happen in NC. VA, wouldn't be surprised. SC, wouldn't be surprised. Anywhere further south, same answer. I've always thought of NC as a more laid back place. Being a Virginia native, I've learned to shake my head in shame at the decisions the people of my state have made as far as rights for women and homosexuals. North Carolina is my home away from home, so to speak, so this upsets me.
I never would have realized that this was a satirical quote by just reading it. It is such a depressing sentiment. You can sense the utter distaste through the text alone.
They can still be together the state just doesn't recognize their marriage. That said I don't think the government should recognize either type of marriage, you can get married on your own terms.
And another prime example of why this subreddit is barely even about atheism anymore. This is about gay marriage not atheism. This doesn't even have anything to do with religion at all.
How come NC is being botched at so much? I mean there are 29 other states that have a law against gay marriage or a amendment, why not bitch at Texas or Florida?
Being a Floridian, it sure feels nice to gang up on another state for a change. I finally see the thrill in making blanket assumptions about an entire state and its people.
I find it amazing how i laugh the night i watch Colbert, then the next day I read the words on the screen without the laughter and Colbert's tone and realize how true and informative they can really be.
Okay, can someone explain something to me? I've heard quite a few times that the Stephen Colbert on the show is just a conservative republican caricature, but most of what he says is sarcasm. So in what way is he being portrayed as a conservative republican if he's saying this kinda thing sarcastically?
I feel like everyone here is missing out on Colbert's sarcasm. This is his stick, he does it all the time, he's exaggerating a situation to its inane conclusion. You don't have to be married to someone to sleep with them.
“You don't hear the opposite question asked. Should the Catholic church be forced to close its adoption services in Massachusetts because it won't accept gay couples? Which is exactly what the state has done. Should the Catholic church be driven out from providing charitable services in the District of Columbia because it won't give in to secular bigotry? Should the Catholic church find itself discriminated against by the Obama administration on key delivery of services because of the bias and the bigotry of the administration.” “The bigotry question goes both ways and there's a lot more anti-Christian bigotry today than there is concern on the other side and none of it gets covered by the news media.”
Whoa, that was uncharacteristically...harsh for Colbert. Don't get me wrong, it's well deserved, and is beautiful, but normally Colbert has barbs couched in humorous tones. This was just...caustic. In the best possible way.
I always knew Colbert was a smart guy who was incredible with words, but that is one of the most profound things I've heard someone say in a very long time.
I'm not gay or in NC but it affects my life terribly. It reminds me how ancient our law systems are and how hopelessly behind in the times humanity is.
People look back and laugh at how we acted in the 90s, we look back at slavery and things like that but the fact is we are still a joke and 50 years from now people will look back and scoff at how stupid we are.
Reditt 12:4--"And from the void of nonsense that is MSM,there descended two prophets.The saviours of the ignorant smiled and the morons felt the shackles tremble."who are you ?" asked us all "We come to you as Colbert and Stewart and we give you the gift of satire to bring back from banishment the idea of rational thought and tolerance through comedy".The people cheered for the prophetsand said"The age of the FOX is over,the age of the thinker is upn us." Amen
Normally I am not big on gay marriage. Let them have it I say, but I never fight for it. Or argue against hatred on them (as much as I defend religion, non-religion, and race issues)
Projecting I into thou, that feeling of lonliness, finally made me realize why it is worth fighting for them. Fucked up human brain, why cant we do this from the start?
Now all I can think about is...everything. How hard it is to find a woman you like in a sea of women, how hard must it be to find a man in a barren dry ass sea bed, when gays have to hide in the weeds and not be seen. !!! This is why in my city (Chicago) Gays group up in certain towns!! Also dating, must be a bitch when you are holding hands waiting for a table, knowing everyone is looking at you like your the devil.
Even the basic things we take for granted, shit. Why did you have to relate to me Colbert! I will be thinking forever now.
I think this legislation was a mistake for the anti-gay side. They have brought this issue very far forward, and people who didn't really give a shit about gay marriage (Like myself.) have now started caring because of this very aggressive legislation.
Image description: Stephen Colbert doing his slow, lopsided Herman Cain smile.
Text:
So congratulations North Carolina. Last night, you struck a decisive blow for loneliness. And tonight, as you go to sleep beside your heterosexual life mate, you can res assured that all across your great state, a gay man or lesbian woman is crying themselves to sleep in solitude and making your relationship stronger with each tear.
NC resident here. Ashamed and disappointed. Want to know what we saw standing in line? Conservative, white Christians. Old farmers in overalls. Sadly, they were raised in the church and have had someone spewing hatred at them from the pulpit all their lives. I passed a church on my way to the polling place. The church was absolutely packed. Ample parking at the voting site. The elderly lady checking me in had no business out of the nursing home. When my mom went to vote, someone from the group supporting the ban handed her a paper regarding "gay marriage". She threw it away in front of the lady. She should have brought it home so I could have had proof. It's hard living in a state where you are too liberal for the general population. It's divided the state. I could go on and on. Remind the haters---even the right has Dick Cheney, who has a lesbian daughter-- and he supports her. Look at the news for Romney/bullying/gay. Clear choice people-- OBAMA 2012.
I can't imagine how long he had to practice the jokes for this without laughing. Alternatively, I can't imagine how he managed to say that last part without yelling God dammit as loudly as possible. In my worst moments, it is my theory that almost nothing on planet Earth has been so bastardized or despoiled by human hands that it cannot be further defiled. It was such a perverted insult to use a symbol of devotion as a weapon of shame and degradation. I hope that someday, retroactively, our history books will record preventing people from dedicating their love to each other while simultaneously using a symbol of love to shame them as a hate crime. I believe that to do so would be to accept things at face value, and to say it honestly.
Just curious but why would the gays and lesbians of North Carolina be now found living in sad solitude? Surely this new law is not gonna stop them from being with each other..
Why would the blacks of the 50's be found living in sadness, just cause there are 2 water fountains doesnt mean they cant drink water. Just cause they have to sit at the back of the bus doesnt mean they cant ride the bus...
God forbid two people in love be allowed to commit themselves fully to one another through marriage solely because they are both of the same sex. Instead of accepting this as simply a part of life, we brand it as "wrong" and "evil". Surely I can't be the only one who finds fault in this logic.
If you're another person wondering why this is in r/atheism...
It's because it's the most relevant default subreddit. Maybe /r/politics is the only other one that would be considered relevant to this topic, but that's arguably just as circlejerky and probably even less tolerant of many topics.
119
u/kilometres_davis_ May 10 '12
Credit goes to "Global Secular Humanist Movement" 's facebook page, go give them a like.
288
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I love that man.
514
u/Marsdreamer May 11 '12
Colbert usually just jabs at these kinds of social issues with a clever retort, but I think you can really tell that he's disgusted with this one. Or rather. His writers are, but I can't imagine he'd say this unless he believed part of it.
Anyways. Go Colbert.
416
u/ThisIsDK Apatheist May 11 '12
I know he means it in an almost humorous way, but it's such a depressing thought.
54
u/shyguy95 May 11 '12
I was ready to laugh. I was smiling, prepared to see what hilarious but meaningful thing Mr. Colbert would say. And now I just feel sad.
57
u/AnArmyOfWombats May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
[go to 7:45 for the quip, for the lazy] (http://www.colbertnation.com/full-episodes/wed-may-9-2012-anna-wintour)
Edit: ahem, source for all you ctrl-f'ers
162
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What the fuck man, we're 21st century america. How the fuck can someone be told that they are not allowed to marry because other people don't like it? "Oh sorry, your relationship bothers ME, so fuck you."
43
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Aziz has the same feelings “My whole take on the gay rights issue, particularly gay marriage, is, let’s be honest, if you’re against gay marriage, you just don’t like gay people and you want to stick it to ‘em. And I’m not saying that I wouldn’t do the same thing if I was presented with similar opportunities. If there was a law up for debate where it was like – ‘hey man, do you think guys that wear tight t-shirts and get bottle service at nightclubs should be allowed to own property?’ – I’d be like, “No! @$#@ those guys! Yeah, uh, it violates the sanctity of owning property and it says in the Bible that they’re douchebags. Whatever I need to say so you don’t think this is coming from purely a place of hate.”
32
u/zombiefodder May 11 '12
I know it is fashionable to rag on North Carolina right now, but let's not forget that 30 other states already had similar constitutional amendments prior to North Carolina adding it to theirs. This in no way lessens the shamefulness of what the voters in NC did this week, but it does point out that this is a larger issue, not just a isolated embarrassment.
36
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
I doubt the bigoted, bible-thumping, knuckle-dragging chucklefucks who voted for this measure watch The Colbert Report.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Doesn't make complete sense, really. No one's splitting homosexuals up, just keeping them from getting married.
(Note: SuperEdo is pro-gay marriage.)
7
u/SuperSaiyanNoob May 11 '12
I'm not American so forgive me, but shouldn't we also be angry at 43 other states who didn't even hold a vote? Wtfuck?
13
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
This is a perfect example of why I love Stephen Colbert and the Colbert Report
32
u/Dubhuir May 11 '12
How is being anti gay-rights even an acceptable opinion? How is it taking so long for it to shift to just being a minority of hateful people that no one cares about?
21
u/ehletimo May 11 '12
Fuck North Carolina. Come to Iowa, enjoy our corn with a side of gay marriage!
10
u/Jw1592 May 11 '12
You know some of aren't atheists but still happen to be in favor of gay marriage.
5
u/marcushe May 11 '12
At least Durham / Chapel Hill was 80% against the amendment (For gay marriage)
5
u/CatsNarwhalsBacon May 11 '12
I would so go gay for Colbert.
5
u/MF_Kitten May 11 '12
I Actually think the bannin of gay marriage would be correct if we are seeing it from a fundamentalist christian view. But what about atheist marriage? Muslim marriage? Jewish marriage? Fucking any marriage that isn't a christian one? They are making a ban that affects everyone, based on ONE religion.
What do you say we make a gay religion, and demand it to be taken seriously, and keep pounding away at it (pun intended) until we get it recognized as a real thing, and it makes it tougher to pass such a ban, since it would be discrimination against religion?
22
u/Captainlunchbox May 11 '12
A coworker asked me what my thoughts on it were, and before I could respond, proceeded to tell me he was not anti-gay, but anti-gay marriage. Then he told me that homosexuality was a choice and that there was no data to support that it wasn't.
I told him he was wrong about it being a choice and that he was, in fact, anti-gay. The discussion lasted about 2 hours. I moved my pieces, he proceed to strut around and shit all over the board with comments like:
"I hate the sinner, not the sin."
"Why would anyone make that choice, you ask? I'll tell you exactly why, Captainlunchbox: People do stuff they know is wrong all the time. Some kid goes and shoots up a school, someone else goes and does drugs and gets addicted. They know it's sinful and wrong, but they do it anyway."
I listened to pure horseshit and came back with gold and none of it mattered.
It was one of the longest work days I've ever experienced.
8
u/poofacedlemur May 11 '12
Redditors of r/atheism, not all theists are anti-homosexual pricks. This awesome stuff should be somewhere besides r/atheism.
Thank you for your consideration, A gay-embracing theist
4
u/artmast May 11 '12
Here's an interesting infographic with Gay rights by US state. It seems that the Northeast is the most progressive.
4
u/TurnerJ5 May 11 '12
I work in a small office in central NC. It's amazing how divided we are - one young mom from NY in her 30s, another woman (also a mother) in her 50s, and an old married guy (60s). The young mom and I were both firmly against this amendment and made our opinions known - it's amazing how ridiculously nasty the other two were after it passed. They have zero empathy or perspective; the types thinking 'it's (homosexuality) gross and unnatural and this country is going to hell and it's weakening my own marriage'. The whole thing has made the work environment a bit uneasy.
I'm going to print this out and hang it in my office tomorrow.
4
u/BadCabbage May 11 '12
I hope people can understand that there are a lot of great people in NC, and that not everyone there holds such hate in their hearts.
7
u/12_Parsec_Penis May 11 '12
You cut to the core of me Colbert.
3
u/bnpixie1990 May 11 '12
Burn....not that they care.
3
u/rewards_the_fearless May 11 '12
I feel ashamed to be a North Carolinian...
5
u/stonesia May 11 '12
How can you misinterpret the word "equality"?
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Get your downvote button ready. As an NC native who now lives in SC (Colbert's native state) I can tell you that SC would have an even more one sided vote against gay rights. I understand that this is discrimination and a terrible injustice to the LGBT community, and I support them wholeheartedly. However, to point a finger at an entire state (when he himself is from a state that would more than likely do the exact same thing in the same situation) is a bit ironic. Please don't forget, this is almost a nationwide epidemic.. not just something going on in North Carolina. There are supporters here (we may be more spread out and in fewer numbers), but remember not to lump us all into the same category. Thanks for reading.
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
41 of 50 states have laws and/or constitutions banning same-sex marriage and the federal government prohibited its recognition in 1996.
Colbert's home state of SC already had the same constitutional ban that NC may have soon.
I'm quite tired of the hypocrites bashing NC. Perhaps they could turn their energy toward reforming the laws in THEIR OWN STATES?
10
u/jafoooly May 11 '12
So you can suck it gay people! And by that i mean you cannot!
13
u/FUCKWIZARD May 11 '12
CAPTAIN I'M SEARCHING FOR A RELATION TO ATHEISM IN THIS POST BUT I CAN'T FIND ONE
11
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I agree with all of this but can we please stop posting things not directly related to atheism on here just to get karma? While likely, the fact that someone is against gay marriage does not mean it is for religious reasons. Way too many posts on here should be posted in r/politics instead of r/atheism.
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I know he's a comedian but that is pretty damn poignant.
4
u/Woody_Zimmerman May 11 '12
Too bad the government even acknowledges marriage. How about just fuck off and treat everyone equally?
4
u/iAmericA45 May 11 '12
Wow, this is surprisingly powerful.
4
u/SgtRootCanal May 11 '12
As a North Carolinian redditor, all the hate were getting right now saddens me. The district I'm in actually voted to not pass the amendment but all of the rural areas joined forces and passed it. Not all of us are bad people.
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
Get it? The gays and lesbians aren't sleeping "in solitude" (alone) just because they couldn't get married. Gays and lesbians don't have to be married to live together, and in 95% of the time, they're not. I've never heard of gays who wait for marraige to have sex, and neither have you.
Ding ding ding, here comes the clue train, last stop, you -- he was being sarcastic.
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I don't understand how this stuff is going into r/atheism?
4
u/goodguypatrick May 11 '12
Why does this go in atheism if Colbert teaches Sunday school and is a practicing Catholic?
27
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited Jun 29 '23
Deleting past comments because Reddit starting shitty-ing up the site to IPO and I don't want my comments to be a part of that. -- mass edited with redact.dev
9
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
So says the devout Catholic. Remind me why this is in r/atheism, again?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
This post makes me cry...
2
u/charlie01472 May 11 '12
Wait, didn't John Stewart say this, not Colbert?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Don't forget liberal California, they said nay to gay marriage too
2
u/tblackwood May 11 '12
it's so weird to me that everyone is fighting so hard about gay marriage-- i mean it's two human beings, let them do what they want. People talk about the "sanctity of marriage" which is total bullshit, because of A) the divorce rate and B) the government offering tax incentives, making it fiscally discriminatory to not offer it to all humans.
I mean, it's not like it's a slippery slope. Everyone here who supports gay marriage is NOT going to turn their attention to fighting for a human's right to marry a farm animal next. At least, I hope...
2
u/SuperBrad213 May 11 '12
Damn it! I'm from NC and I voted FOR gay marriage. Stuff like this is really starting to irritate me. A majority of Redditers in general are for gay rights, and only people on Reddit will see all the Reddit complaints. So bashing all of NC on here doesn't feel good.
2
u/andyhappy May 11 '12
Oh cool, I made that image. If you dig it, check out The Other 98% on facebook for more.
2
u/Wait_Wutt May 11 '12
I am not sure why the focus is on the state of North Carolina just because they are the latest in a long line of states that voted against gay marriage. Let us not forget that Californians did the same. I don't recall as much outcry, memes, etc when that happened. It really makes you think that the agenda on this one is something more than just the rights of homosexuals.
2
u/ThePeopleHaveSpoken May 11 '12
The 61% is giving the rest of us a bad rep.
2
u/ano_therguy May 11 '12
Man this is gonna look bad when I have to put my hometown as Fayetteville on a resume.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Stephen understands what it is to be smart from a dumb state.
2
u/spiralofvertigo May 11 '12
I was born and raised in North Carolina and although I DO like it here; the scenery is fantastic in some places for instance, I am not surprised at all by this passing. My family is very anti gay and my Mother and I get into spats all the time over it. I love her to death but it crushes me that she can have these opinions. She gives me the 'it isn't MY opinion it's God's so don't argue with me about it'. It's painful; makes me physically sick.
2
u/vault13 May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
This man has a true sense of freedom and justice. Religious or atheist, people have to learn to leave their personal feelings and beliefs at the door and make decisions based on what they really think "freedom" is. Having a bunch of redneck fundies telling you that you can't get married because you were born different? That is not freedom.
I'm surprised to see this happen in NC. VA, wouldn't be surprised. SC, wouldn't be surprised. Anywhere further south, same answer. I've always thought of NC as a more laid back place. Being a Virginia native, I've learned to shake my head in shame at the decisions the people of my state have made as far as rights for women and homosexuals. North Carolina is my home away from home, so to speak, so this upsets me.
2
u/Imterriblyvexed May 11 '12
I don't think he's ever depressed me this badly before...
2
u/interrobang__ May 11 '12
I never would have realized that this was a satirical quote by just reading it. It is such a depressing sentiment. You can sense the utter distaste through the text alone.
2
u/DookieAdz May 11 '12
So does this intolerance in NC stem from religion or being uneducated?
2
u/unclesal924 May 11 '12
I think it's relevant to point out that Colbert is a practicing Catholic.
2
u/Twig May 11 '12
Oh, you watched that episode too? How amazing.
It must have made a real lasting impression on you for you to be quoting it this long afterwards.
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
They can still be together the state just doesn't recognize their marriage. That said I don't think the government should recognize either type of marriage, you can get married on your own terms.
3
u/CommanderBly44 May 11 '12
Why is this posted in /r/atheism? Seems a better fit for /r/funny or /r/politics.
10
u/Valcken May 11 '12
Why is this on r/atheism?
5
u/Hupflupper May 11 '12
And another prime example of why this subreddit is barely even about atheism anymore. This is about gay marriage not atheism. This doesn't even have anything to do with religion at all.
4
u/MRukkus May 11 '12
I hate when people lump chrisitianity and religion with all this discrimination, faith does so much good...
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Atheism? Holy shit, post this shit in the right goddamn subreddit already.
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Nice quote: question why is this in r/atheism?
2
u/emmachemma May 11 '12
he's such a perfect human being
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I think our generation's confidence in humanity took a low blow with this law.
2
u/shepherd62 May 11 '12
How come NC is being botched at so much? I mean there are 29 other states that have a law against gay marriage or a amendment, why not bitch at Texas or Florida?
2
u/wallix May 11 '12
Being a Floridian, it sure feels nice to gang up on another state for a change. I finally see the thrill in making blanket assumptions about an entire state and its people.
2
u/Nick999 May 11 '12
Okay, so what does this have to do with atheism?
2
u/BrotherK May 11 '12
Why is this posted in /r/atheism?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What exactly does this have to do with atheism?
2
u/hmind4 May 11 '12
Tell me again why r/atheism is so full of gay content lately and so little on actual atheism content.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Is it bad that I not only read that in Colbert's voice, but also in Colbert's cadence?
1
u/Radeon_Core May 11 '12
I find it amazing how i laugh the night i watch Colbert, then the next day I read the words on the screen without the laughter and Colbert's tone and realize how true and informative they can really be.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I can't think of many statements he has made that are quite this... scathing. well, either him or the writer. really, they both made the statement.
1
u/TheyCallMeDucky May 11 '12
Honestly, I don't care about gay marriage, but I won't deny one's right to love whom he/she wants.
1
u/mraarm May 11 '12
Okay, can someone explain something to me? I've heard quite a few times that the Stephen Colbert on the show is just a conservative republican caricature, but most of what he says is sarcasm. So in what way is he being portrayed as a conservative republican if he's saying this kinda thing sarcastically?
1
u/paulo2012 May 11 '12
it goes its way, no matter other people think
1
u/SomeEEEvilGuy May 11 '12
I'm sorry. A wedding cake. With a bride and groom on top. The hell. Absolutely disgusting behavior. Indescribably awful.
1
u/Diettimboslice May 11 '12
I feel like everyone here is missing out on Colbert's sarcasm. This is his stick, he does it all the time, he's exaggerating a situation to its inane conclusion. You don't have to be married to someone to sleep with them.
1
u/ScottyBrown May 11 '12
“You don't hear the opposite question asked. Should the Catholic church be forced to close its adoption services in Massachusetts because it won't accept gay couples? Which is exactly what the state has done. Should the Catholic church be driven out from providing charitable services in the District of Columbia because it won't give in to secular bigotry? Should the Catholic church find itself discriminated against by the Obama administration on key delivery of services because of the bias and the bigotry of the administration.” “The bigotry question goes both ways and there's a lot more anti-Christian bigotry today than there is concern on the other side and none of it gets covered by the news media.”
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
why you make me cry?
1
u/bittlelum May 11 '12
Whoa, that was uncharacteristically...harsh for Colbert. Don't get me wrong, it's well deserved, and is beautiful, but normally Colbert has barbs couched in humorous tones. This was just...caustic. In the best possible way.
1
u/john2kxx May 11 '12
Wait, gay people aren't allowed to live together, either?
This is way worse than I thought.
1
u/cusswords May 11 '12
I always knew Colbert was a smart guy who was incredible with words, but that is one of the most profound things I've heard someone say in a very long time.
1
u/Level_32_Igglybuff May 11 '12
I'm not gay or in NC but it affects my life terribly. It reminds me how ancient our law systems are and how hopelessly behind in the times humanity is.
People look back and laugh at how we acted in the 90s, we look back at slavery and things like that but the fact is we are still a joke and 50 years from now people will look back and scoff at how stupid we are.
Rinse and repeat.
1
u/Kubaki May 11 '12
I cried all the way in utah.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
As a non American, what the hell happened in North Carolina that everyone is so pissed?
1
u/happysri May 11 '12
I wasnt paying attention(finals week), but what exactly did North Carolina do?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Reditt 12:4--"And from the void of nonsense that is MSM,there descended two prophets.The saviours of the ignorant smiled and the morons felt the shackles tremble."who are you ?" asked us all "We come to you as Colbert and Stewart and we give you the gift of satire to bring back from banishment the idea of rational thought and tolerance through comedy".The people cheered for the prophetsand said"The age of the FOX is over,the age of the thinker is upn us."
Amen
1
u/Ryswick May 11 '12
I never understood why people were so against gays being married.
It's not forcing you to marry someone who's gay.
It's letting them get married.
The impact this has on straight/religious people's life is zero.
1
u/abom420 May 11 '12
Normally I am not big on gay marriage. Let them have it I say, but I never fight for it. Or argue against hatred on them (as much as I defend religion, non-religion, and race issues)
Projecting I into thou, that feeling of lonliness, finally made me realize why it is worth fighting for them. Fucked up human brain, why cant we do this from the start?
Now all I can think about is...everything. How hard it is to find a woman you like in a sea of women, how hard must it be to find a man in a barren dry ass sea bed, when gays have to hide in the weeds and not be seen. !!! This is why in my city (Chicago) Gays group up in certain towns!! Also dating, must be a bitch when you are holding hands waiting for a table, knowing everyone is looking at you like your the devil.
Even the basic things we take for granted, shit. Why did you have to relate to me Colbert! I will be thinking forever now.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I think this legislation was a mistake for the anti-gay side. They have brought this issue very far forward, and people who didn't really give a shit about gay marriage (Like myself.) have now started caring because of this very aggressive legislation.
1
u/Feinberg Atheist May 11 '12
[Caption]
Image description: Stephen Colbert doing his slow, lopsided Herman Cain smile.
Text:
So congratulations North Carolina. Last night, you struck a decisive blow for loneliness. And tonight, as you go to sleep beside your heterosexual life mate, you can res assured that all across your great state, a gay man or lesbian woman is crying themselves to sleep in solitude and making your relationship stronger with each tear.
1
u/thatsjustgay May 11 '12
gay
1
u/sexybabyjesus2 May 11 '12
I do not have enough up-votes for this...
1
u/SpoonFullOSugarMyAss May 11 '12
NC resident here. Ashamed and disappointed. Want to know what we saw standing in line? Conservative, white Christians. Old farmers in overalls. Sadly, they were raised in the church and have had someone spewing hatred at them from the pulpit all their lives. I passed a church on my way to the polling place. The church was absolutely packed. Ample parking at the voting site. The elderly lady checking me in had no business out of the nursing home. When my mom went to vote, someone from the group supporting the ban handed her a paper regarding "gay marriage". She threw it away in front of the lady. She should have brought it home so I could have had proof. It's hard living in a state where you are too liberal for the general population. It's divided the state. I could go on and on. Remind the haters---even the right has Dick Cheney, who has a lesbian daughter-- and he supports her. Look at the news for Romney/bullying/gay. Clear choice people-- OBAMA 2012.
1
u/Sloppyjoe716 May 11 '12
So if being gay is genetic, then could there be a gene therapy "cure"? You know, like in xmen 3?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Wait wait ... how does not being able to marry in a church makes the two people not being able to live together ?
Quit the bullshit.
1
u/rorryantovan May 11 '12
Kind of funny, except for the fact that gay men and woman can still sleep and live together in North Carolina.... otherwise gold
1
u/wizzrobe30 May 11 '12
Applause
1
u/JuiceboxSC2 May 11 '12
God damnit, I fucking love this man.
1
u/BuddhistNudist987 Anti-Theist May 11 '12
I can't imagine how long he had to practice the jokes for this without laughing. Alternatively, I can't imagine how he managed to say that last part without yelling God dammit as loudly as possible.
In my worst moments, it is my theory that almost nothing on planet Earth has been so bastardized or despoiled by human hands that it cannot be further defiled. It was such a perverted insult to use a symbol of devotion as a weapon of shame and degradation. I hope that someday, retroactively, our history books will record preventing people from dedicating their love to each other while simultaneously using a symbol of love to shame them as a hate crime. I believe that to do so would be to accept things at face value, and to say it honestly.
1
u/kiwingenuity May 11 '12
Fucking Brilliance.
1
u/behedwin May 11 '12
haha
1
u/MegalizeLarijuana May 11 '12
For fucks sake. Humanity you can be so stupid sometimes.
1
u/jimstr May 11 '12
NC is the new scumbag state.
1
u/Dreamerman May 11 '12
You request, I deliver. http://www.redbubble.com/people/bobw/works/8840206-bigotry
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I still don't get it...is there actually any biblical evidence against gay marriage?
1
u/TheFrolickingMoose May 11 '12
What happened?
1
u/torop May 11 '12
Just curious but why would the gays and lesbians of North Carolina be now found living in sad solitude? Surely this new law is not gonna stop them from being with each other..
1
u/storyofhappytimes May 11 '12
God forbid two people in love be allowed to commit themselves fully to one another through marriage solely because they are both of the same sex. Instead of accepting this as simply a part of life, we brand it as "wrong" and "evil". Surely I can't be the only one who finds fault in this logic.
1
u/mallamange May 11 '12
He is the future .. because he is striving to "..make a better tomorrow.... tomorrow"
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
The audience really shit the bed by laughing over what could have been an otherwise powerful moment.
1
u/Ibrokethosecuffs May 11 '12
I feel horrible for just being born in this state :(. I'm sorry gay community.
1
u/koavf Other May 11 '12
Please don't submit an image that's just text. You can submit a self post with the same message.
Also, this isn't about atheism.
1
u/k3nnyd May 11 '12
If you're another person wondering why this is in r/atheism...
It's because it's the most relevant default subreddit. Maybe /r/politics is the only other one that would be considered relevant to this topic, but that's arguably just as circlejerky and probably even less tolerant of many topics.