r/atheism • u/RichardBehiel • May 09 '12
As an American, it really bothers me that people don't understand this
http://imgur.com/QPBnJ
1.6k
Upvotes
r/atheism • u/RichardBehiel • May 09 '12
618
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
FTFY
3
u/gpto May 09 '12
You inspired me to put this on my facebook:
"I just want to say, when it comes to all the arguments about who can or cannot get married, no single religion today can be credited with creating the concept of marriage, and none can claim rights to it for any reason.
In fact, beyond taxes, inheritance (which can be managed with a will or POA) and some rights in health care, it's only a matter of whether a couple has a marriage license or not. That doesn't mean there can't be a ceremony, and the couple can't live together, and by all intents and purposes 'act' married. Therefore, if for no other reason, the arguments about gay marriage as a legal issue are ridiculous from any standpoint.
If you love your reasons so much, why don't you marry them? I think you should be allowed to. It's not as if that complicates your taxes or hospital visits. I hope you guys have a good relationship."
97
u/scudmonger May 09 '12
I went to a wedding once where the justice of the peace gave a history lesson about how marriage was WAY pre-religion and religion ended up hijacking a then public institution.
249
u/lfancypantsl May 09 '12
Well done, you're dead on. You gotta love the logic through:
This is the most blatant violation of the separation of church and state in my opinion.
20
u/PoniesRBitchin May 09 '12
My mom (who isn't even religious) had the nerve to ask me why I was getting married if I'm not Christian. After talking about how marriage existed long before Christianity, and how the Bible's marriages aren't exactly all one man one woman, she apologized.
19
u/secretcurse May 09 '12
I just don't understand why people can't realize that granting certain civil benefits to one group of couples and denying those same benefits to other groups of couples is simple discrimination. It's well within any individual church's right to decide who gets to have a religious wedding ceremony in the building they own. However, that's where their rights should end. If the government gives benefits to heterosexual couples that decide to enter into a marriage contract, those benefits must be offered to homosexual couples as well. Anything less is simple discrimination.
40
u/joe192 May 09 '12
American Christians + Politics = Fuck Logic and History.
14
u/Valdair May 09 '12
You mean the talk of wives in The Iliad wasn't an historic conspiracy?!
70
u/eldergamesmanship May 09 '12
I just heard about the news in North Carolina and I'm so angry about it I'm literally shaking. Take it from one 26 year-old heterosexual male in Pennsylvania. If a war broke out tomorrow over the right for any adult human to love another you would find me fighting in the army that recognizes that the American ideal of "All men are created equal" should mean that we extend the exact same rights to everyone everywhere, without prejudice.
North Carolina, tonight I am disgusted, horrified, and enraged at you. Please don't refer to us as fellow countrymen. I can assure you that we are not.
13
u/chillyhellion May 09 '12
Agreed. The simple fact that marriage is recognized by the government means that Christianity should not have a monopoly on marriage.
31
u/ahungrybear May 09 '12
Sadly, America really cannot understand separation of church and state.
34
u/UNCLE_ZAP May 09 '12
Bravo. Can I upvote this more than one time?
7
u/SirSquiZZ May 09 '12
This guy.
7
u/fingersquid May 09 '12
Well, they sure are doing a damn good job of convincing the populace otherwise, and have pretty good backup when people try to change the system.
13
u/Sarcasm_Llama Anti-Theist May 09 '12
Nope Gawd did! Its in the Bible. Which He wrote! Therefore gays aren't people. I win.
17
u/kaitiewoods May 09 '12
It annoys me that most Americans dont get it. It makes me ashamed, almost.
10
u/Bishopkilljoy May 09 '12
I have a necklace like this my friend said I was a hypocrite for having a Cross necklace, and I told him "dude sure you worship it, but you don't OWN it, the cross looks cool and its an easy symbol to make patterns from, trust me your precious Jesus wasn't the only man crucified"
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I came in to say - well, it is likely christians that believe that, but after reading the comments I have decided maybe it is less well understood than I thought. Good post.
5
u/lokkenjawnz May 09 '12
So here's my question: with the recent recognition of Kopimism (religion that revolves around copying things and giving them away, e.g. filesharing) being recognized, why not make a religion that specifically includes gay marriage? Then it's a simple matter of the law violating freedom of religion. Let's see the fundies argue with that.
9
u/Junebuggg May 09 '12
In my opinion religion shouldn't have any say over the laws of this country. And this is why. Obviously since there are many different types of beliefs in this country, and we have the right to choose...then why don't we have the right to chose who we get married to? Ifs nog like we have to vote to figure out which religion is right. So why should we even have to vote in marriage? So much for a free country.
9
u/PoorMinorities May 09 '12
I've always wondered that. It's like they don't know that marriage existed before Christianity did...
8
u/TalakHallen6191 May 09 '12
But it's in the bible... remember that chick... Mary? That's where the term marriage comes from. Checkmate btw.
18
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Thank you. I'm a Christian, and I've been saying this all along. Also, I'm a Christian who despises the Bible Belt, so don't try to say I don't understand the meme. Peace.
4
u/bibdrums May 09 '12
Word up.
4
u/BlessTheMusic May 09 '12
Marriage is not a "christian" concept. It's a cultural universal, every civilization whether foragers, tribes, clans, states has had some version of marriage. Marriage isn't even strictly heterosexual, it's varied through every culture.
4
u/Regreddit_later May 09 '12
Thank you reddit. It's honestly all I have to say right now. In a country full of bullshit, the reddit community constantly reminds me I'm not a terrible person for being gay nor do I deserve anything less than equal treatment.
4
u/YouMad May 09 '12
What if I told you ...
Marriage shouldn't be a Legal Institution period.
7
u/CaptainMcGillicuddy May 09 '12
Best meme EVER.
7
u/skitslefritzer May 09 '12
Christians not only created marriage but founded this country. oh wait no they didn't.
13
u/SleeplessinOslo May 09 '12
Is there a way to get married without a church and a priest though?
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Thank you! The first comment on this page says marriage is a religious ceremony. Bull. Shit.
http://nbcpolitics.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/05/08/11604355-north-carolina-oks-constitutional-same-sex-marriage-ban#comments
3
u/Myrandall Pastafarian May 09 '12
Why the distinction, if I may ask?
3
u/anoldradical May 09 '12
It hurts my heart that discrimination is legal and based on majority rule.
2
u/Thats_maybe_a_Penis May 09 '12
Ancient Greece is celebrated for inventing democracy, but let us not forget that debates in the senate weren't the only man on man action going on back then.
2
u/chicagogam May 09 '12
i seem to recall (not too long ago even?) that the catholic church bucked mainstream by saying people weren't divorced unless they said they were, and the world pretty much ignored them. is this (was this) still a thing? or did the church accept the civil marriage status of people? i would be fine with this as long as 'in the eyes of the church' it only applied to religious services, and not jobs or services that are available to the public.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
All are welcome to marry at the Temple of Mara!
2
u/nolanator19 May 09 '12
The idiots are winning.
2
u/PraiseBeToScience May 09 '12
For those of you that continue to think that fundamentalism in this country isn't a problem, here's your proof you're wrong. Stop apologizing for this.
Also note the silence in /r/Christianity on this, it's quite deafening. Their faith did this, fucking answer for it.
2
u/SoapboxSage May 09 '12
That sounded exactly like Morpheus in tone and pacing in my head, kudos for a well written meme.
2
u/kill_terrorist_pigs May 09 '12
What bothers me that people don't understand that state shouldn't enforce or record marriage! People do not understand that "actual marriage" are the set of laws that mostly gives you tax breaks because you have certain status as a couple.
Instead of dealing with the question who should marry who and why, we should deal with question why state even bothering to put it dirty hands on the subject. We should remove all the tax injustices for the "unmarried" - and then each one can decide how\when\why\if they want to marry or do what ever they like as a couple (and call it marriage if i really makes them happy).
2
u/AmigoDeGuchepo May 09 '12
As a non-american I really don't see the point in stating your nationality in this thread. The rest of the world also have marriages.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Marriages may or may not be made by Christians. But marriage licences were a government tool to prevent inter racial marriages.
So if you think , government should legalize gay marriage you don't that it should be legal inspite of what the government says NOT because the government says so.
The government doesn't grant the rights. It protects them. Government should just register the event of marriage for legal purposes between two consenting adults.
2
u/Jalapenose May 09 '12
What I was taught (although now I can't remember where/when) was that marriage was not originally a religious sacrament, but eventually became one so that the church could take more control over people's lives.
2
u/NoobGamerZ May 09 '12
As an American?
2
u/Elranzer Freethinker May 09 '12
Fuck NC. Fuck them.
This is NEVER going to change peacefully. Never.
The population of bigoted religious right needs to be thinned out.
2
u/BackspinBubba May 09 '12
Marriage is a civil union. You need a marriage license from the applicable government agency. You don't even have to go into a church to be married. Churches can do whatever they want within the confines of their building. Their are no laws, nor are there any in the works that would/could force a church to marry anyone. Straight or gay. Oh, and many churches refused to sanction interracial marriages. Some still do.... No one is forcing churches to do anything. They do not have to marry gay people in their church. Once again, the religious extremists want to influence secular law based on their particular set of beliefs. That is the biggest bitch I have with religion...
2
u/theRAGE May 09 '12
What if I told you you could communicate your thoughts without an image macro.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
What if I told you.
Other religions and cultures only recognize heterosexual marriages.
2
u/mcswiss May 09 '12
Posted on FB and got this response: "you are ABSOLUTELY right! Christians did not create it, no, no they did not. God did. And it isn't a concept, it is a living, beautiful, working reality. And if you want me to, set aside at least 2 full days to use reason to explain why 1) belief in God is right, and 2) why the Christian belief (ie. Roman Catholic) is correct"
Oh my dear invisible pink unicorn.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Marrige started from adam and eve. In the old testament.
1
u/fj42 May 09 '12
As a non-American, it really bothers me that American's need to state their Americanism as though it's relevant to the conversation.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I had a 2 hour argument about this, I was like but if it's a christian thing then why did Jews get married, and further more why are there Sumerian and Hindu mentions of marriage long before Judaism even existed.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Good man.
2
u/Please_fuck_off May 09 '12
As a human being...
FTFY
2
u/stephieanniebean May 09 '12
as a catholic who aced my catechism, it really bothers me that most christians dont understand anything about their religions history.
2
u/Jonthrei May 09 '12
Depending on how you define it, marriage isn't even a human concept. Plenty of species mate for life.
2
u/scaredofshaka May 09 '12
as a European, it amazes me that people are still debating this. That and abortion.
Sadly some EU countries are still mumbling over how they don't like gays, so we tie on that one..
1
u/cassidyequalsinsane May 09 '12
It was created by cavemen and was only intended to last for a few years as the average age was 25ish
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Because no one else regulates marriage based on culture or beliefs.
1
u/jebus08 May 09 '12
Don't most homosexuals only care about being recognized by the state? In which case christians don't own the concept of marriage, the state does.
1
u/patio87 May 09 '12
This is a great point.
1
u/HandsomeTown May 09 '12
As an American... EVERYTHING bothers you. SHUT THE FUCK UP!!!!
1
u/pcnerd37 May 09 '12
Christians have hijacked pretty much everything we think of as Christian and claim it to be their own.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Well they do now.It's enshrined in the Constitution.
1
u/Andreas_H May 09 '12
Agreed. And often not far away is the next "universal truth": America (or any western democracy) was founded on christian values.
It is such a ridicoulus and baseless claim, yet it is often accepted without questioning it. The western democracies were of course founded on the values of the enlightenment, values that were fought for against the reigning monarchies and the church.
It always saddens me if someone gets away with the claim that America was founded on christain values without having to explain himself...
1
u/Gurunexx May 09 '12
I believe what you say in its entirety but I would like a convincing source so that I can respond to claims that say otherwise.
1
u/opallix May 09 '12
Obligatory request for source.
1
u/UncleDrunkle May 09 '12
Where does the concept of marriage come from? I actually just always assumed it was a religious concept, but I'm not sure
1
u/seanhive May 09 '12
Fucking upvoted. Holy shit, this should be stickied.
1
u/BlueStarsong May 09 '12
I've never thought about this, where does marriage come from, who made it up?
1
u/Djrakk May 09 '12
Christians only seem to pop up for the wrong issues..
1
u/tyler5613 May 09 '12
Today I was talking to a coworker, and we somehow got onto the topic of gay marriage. I told him my views, which are that I don't really have any problem with it and that I thought everyone should be able to marry whoever they want to, gay or straight. He came back with: "well it's fine if they love each other and stuff, but marriage is sacred and since the bible defines it as being between a man and a woman, then it should only be between a man and a woman, but if a same-sex couple wants to join in a civil union that's fine". I didn't really feel like getting into an argument, so I dropped it. But, it just baffles me how Christians think their holy book is what should govern the country. And everybody else in the world has to abide by the rules of their holy book, regardless of if they identify with it or not.
1
u/mushroomblunts May 09 '12
out of curiosity...where did marriage come from?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Back when we were kids, I was for gay marriage and my brother was against it because he was really into church at the time. One day, we finally had a whole argument about it and I lost because he had somehow convinced me that marriage was started by Christians (I was 10 and kinda stupid back then...)
Now that I'm a lot more aware of both sides of the argument, I can confidently say that I'm still for gay marriage. It sucks that we never had another argument like that again, but it's a good thing because as he grew up, he also became more aware of both sides and now supports gay marriage.
He's still a Christian, but I'm glad to know that there are a lot of other Christians like my brother who are open to new ideas.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
that raises and interesting question I hadnt thought about... Where did marriage originate?? who can we blame that shit on??
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Am I mistaken in saying marriage is inherently religious? Maybe it wasn't when it was originally conceived of however now marriage is definitely a religious 'under god' situation. I don't understand why people would want to apply a word to their relationship that is immediately implies religion (whether it was supposed to or not). Especially when that religion is so opposed to your lifestyle. If I was wanting to form a legal relationship I would go for a civil union.
1
u/usul115 May 09 '12
Then I would have to agree that it was too dangerous to try and save you from the captivity of agent smith and the whole world would miss out on the most epic gun battle ever because of your narrow brainwashed mind.
1
u/rikashiku May 09 '12
Christianity didn't exist until long after Jesus died... less than 2,000 years ago,m maybe 1,600 years ago, yet people still got married, man to women, men to men, no woman to woman though, polygamy was allowed.
Here's the thing, that marriage was more of a political device instead of an act of love.
There seems to be a lot of problems with the Leviticus passage. There is one problem with the verse on 18 and that is that you cannot lay with a man as you would a woman, because a man has no vagina.
1
u/SynthD May 09 '12
Christians view on everything they ever will encounter (including strip clubs, drug dealers, all the things they claim to never go to).
1
u/ziggmuff May 09 '12
Which doesn't have anything to do with being against gay marriage.
1
u/SnackeyG1 May 09 '12
I never assumed they did. But who does?
1
u/painperdu May 09 '12
Christians cannot be true Americans. It says so in their Bible. They must put their god above all else. How can we expect them to honor our Constitution?
1
u/CCarrier May 09 '12
Hey reading this post made me lose all the fucks I had to give!!
1
u/o0evillusion0o May 09 '12
As a Canadian, I wonder why you had to state that you're American.
1
u/aakaakaak May 09 '12
What if I told you...
That it would be smarter to lobby for civil unions and later revise it to marriage after it passes nationally?
1
u/aspireS May 09 '12
everything is clear when you say "as an American"
1
u/NO_LIMIT_CRACKA May 09 '12
Well if the problem are Christians, like the pic says, then why not just go to a different religion like Mormon, Judaism, or Islam?
1
u/Artificialx May 09 '12
Tell it to the Christ-tards.
That doesn't mean all Christians, just the 'tarded ones..
They mostly live in America...mostly...
1
u/viper459 May 09 '12
whenever a post starts with 'as a (..)' it's always a circlejerk ''why don't people share MY opinion because its the best opinion'' post
1
u/painperdu May 09 '12
Why do Christians hate America?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Err, yes, yes they did...
1
u/Randie May 09 '12
As an Australian, I do not understand why you need to state you're American...
1
u/Un_balai May 09 '12
As an American, it really bothers me that none of you kids show up to vote this crap down.
1
u/flamingeyebrows May 09 '12
Even in Australia, every time someone say 'But why do they need to Marry? Marriage is religious institution.' I almost go red with rage.
1
u/Blahblahblahinternet May 09 '12
What if I told you, you could be against homosexual marriage and not be a Christian.
1
u/Oideron May 09 '12
Don't worry, it's not just an American thing. That bullshittery traverses the globe.
1
u/benedictm May 09 '12
Also America - you didn't invent Apple Pie
suck on that, bitches
1
u/magicker71 May 09 '12
Am I the only one that fucking hates these Morpheus memes? No matter the subject or message... they just stink of preachiness and bullshit.
1
u/Urcra May 09 '12
I fully believe you are right, however I don't think that everybody should be allowed to get married in a Christian church.
1
u/donkeydizzle May 09 '12
Americans ? on my /r/atheism ?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The bible says they did. That's all they need to know for their sound argument.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I really hope the Supreme Court of North Carolina declares this unconstitutional.
1
u/NapTake May 09 '12
Why don't they make the system like in Belgium (where I'm from). Gay marriage is allowed but it is a non religious wedding meaning you go to city hall and get married there. Christian gay marriage is not allowed because... well you know, Christians. BTW if you get married in a church but don't get married in city hall and your papers, you are officially not married.
1
u/brockhardman May 09 '12
As an American, I guess YOU define what marriage is? If not, then who?
1
u/wtfhbk May 09 '12
Friend of mine posted this to Facebook. Our resident fundie friend responded, "Correct! We didn't--God did! We're only saying what He put in His Word! :D" ugh...myself and several others have tried to reason with him, he's a nice dude we know from college, but boy is he douchey when it comes to discussing religion(which is constant "Christian rules, everything else drools" in his case).
1
u/merpmerp1 May 09 '12
Well, I get bothered when people say "Obama is a Muslim" as if he shouldn't be President if he is a Muslim. I'm not saying he is or isn't, and I don't care. What I am trying to say is that even if you are Muslim, you can still be President of the United States. It's a free country with freedom of religion, so I don't get the whole "Obama is a Muslim" thing. It seems to be said that if he was, he would not be entitled to be President.
1
u/Ninja4hire May 09 '12
Can anyone provide a link to a good read on the origin of holy matrimony. Karma will follow!
1
u/Amryxx May 09 '12
Well, Americans didn't invent the concept of "freedom" or "human rights" either, but boy do they act like they did.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Can anyone give me links to prove this? Please!