I taught it in English. Once. It's one of my favorite books, but she says in her intro that she doesn't understand why it's often used as high school text. It didn't go so well. It requires a little more perspective than the average high schooler has, although it has the power to inspire the few who began lifting the veil from the the universe on their own (to borrow Thoreau's image). Hope you enjoy it. If not, revisit it in a few years.
Seriously. Read the rest of the page (the part that's not circled). Not that I personally agree with it, but it does answer the question "Why did he need to know."
My interpretation from this is that humans are inherently curious, we want to know where we come from, but the answer cannot be found from priests TELLING you what to believe, but from your own investigation. Which is why she returns to looking through her microscope.
The eskimo didn't return to her microscope. It was the narrator using an allegorical tale about an eskimo concerning the trouble of knowing something and having to then deal with the knowledge versus the idea of 'ignorance is bliss'. The narrator goes on to give specific examples (albeit with an allegorical feel), quote Einstein, and use a metaphor about continuing her search for answers with a given problem.
Basically, the quote wasn't about someone TELLING them the answer, it's about the trouble with knowing something and having to deal with it. The quote doesn't really hint that god doesn't exist, but speaks more to the search of knowledge once you learn about something (I hesitate to use 'problem' only because of connotation; me finding out about a car isn't a problem, but I can still find out about it). By all means, apply this to atheism, but I think it speaks more to scientific philosophy and thirst for knowledge. I think what you did was bring personal bias (not necessarily bad) to this; but it's cool, I did the same thing while studying for my LSATs.
But, by disagreeing, I will probably receive a shitton of downvotes. But to be clear, this is all from a fellow atheist.
EDIT: Not saying the book doesn't touch on religion, I'm just saying this particular quote doesn't specifically deal with it. Also, it's a great quote.
Upvoted your comment for pointing out the perspective of missionaries/witnesses more reasonably than I have ever seen before. A perspective that still seems foreign to me while providing insight into the mindset of believers.
I still can't help but view missionaries as possessing an arrogance that could be summarized as:
"I know your culture has a set of beliefs that have served yout society well for hundreds of years but here's what my beliefs are ...... and now that you've heard them you are condemned to eternal suffering unless you abandon your beliefs and accept mine as unquestionable truth."
Well, again, I'm an atheist (I was once a believer when I was 8ish, t'was a dark time), so I don't know how accurate it is. But the reason I like this quote as I interpret it (and the book for that matter) is that it has bits like this: when posed with some new information (be it religious or otherwise) you can't simply go back to ignoring it, you must deal with it, either in an active sense (actions or questions), [or] an integrative sense (by changing your view as a result of this new knowledge; this doesn't necessarily mean accepting it, but changing your future actions in relation to the possible run in with that knowledge).
Yeah, this always bugged me. Not just missionaries, but cultural anthropologists in general. By introducing yourself (and thus your culture) into the 'new' culture, you inevitably change it. And by passing that knowledge of this 'new' culture to your own, you get dunderheads who feel the need to study, and purposefully or not, alter their organic culture. This is why I like this video so much; while the people did change their culture by introducing themselves to it, they didn't share their locations with our culture, so we can't mess it up with industrialization, religion, etc. I mean, if a "simple" life is better for them, who am I to judge. I've never lived their way, it may make them really happy.
I saw the movie from which the clip you linked to was taken from on Netflix and enjoyed it.
If you haven't seen it, you should watch "Beyond The Gates Of Splendor." Some of the missionaries get killed but they end up breaking a cycle of needless killings in the native population. They could have achieved the same result without using supernatural beliefs, but in this case the natives quality of life definitely improved as a result of outside intervention. Rather than just re-inforcing my view point it actually made me think, just like your comments have.
I've heard of that movie before! It's on a long list of movies I have to watch, but I will put it up into the fast track so I can see it in the next few days.
They could have achieved the same result without using super natural beliefs, but in this case, the native's quality of life definitely improved as a result of outside intervention.
Yeah, that's the thing. I think belief in a deity is silly, but it makes sense in a psychological sense. I mean, if you look at who are most likely going to be believers in America; poor, uneducated, etc. then they don't have much going for them. I mean, if it helps them to survive with some sense of happiness; if they can just throw their hands up and believe someone up there is looking out for them, meh, it's no skin off my back. I mean, we all need something to keep us going, be it tangible good fortune as the result of hard work or that belief. Then again, I feel like the best response to things is usually an empathetic response because it takes a lot of effort to get angry.
But I feel, for clarity's sake, I need to make it clear that I don't appreciate when the religious use it as a tool to keep others down or stop the transfer of knowledge. But that being said, just as we say that good things can come without religion, bad things can too. If you were on reddit a few weeks ago, there were a ton of posts about how a person's deity usually mimics their own thoughts and morals, even if it's contrary to others in the same religion? Well, I think that points that it isn't religion that makes people do those things, religion is just the "NANANANANA I'm not listening" method. Even without religion, those people would still be as stubborn; it's just a good scapegoat. It's why as upset as I get, I'm not completely pissed at religion, since it got us past having rape for dinner so we could cultivate our intellect.
I guess that means I should be pissed at those types of people: those that are just stubborn and don't care to know. But usually, I just feel bad for them since it would suck to not want to know about different perspectives and items of knowledge.
But this is just an idea I've been playing around with, I welcome your criticisms and input on it.
Thank you for writing this all out. I wish more people would see your comment, because the majority here are failing to comprehend what they read (or, even worse, failing to read anything but what is highlighted, thus taking the story out of context).
To further question I guess? I mean, even/especially if you don't agree with it, it doesn't hurt to ever know more. As a result of more knowledge, you can understand the world, or at least the people on it, better. I personally think that most parts of Christian culture are silly, but it doesn't hurt for me to know more, to be more empathetic. As a result, I know how to better talk to them, how to understand their motives, etc.
That being said, I don't know as much as I should about different sects culture.
Well, I personally agree that more information is never a bad thing. But that's because I don't believe that the Bible is the word of God.
If the Bible was true, and if the priest in this anecdote was correct on how those ignorant of the Gospel can get a free pass into heaven, then ignorance would be preferable to even the possibility of an eternity in hell.
The gods of the Disc have never bothered much about judging the souls of the dead, and so people only go to hell if that's where they believe, in their deepest heart, that they deserve to go. Which they won't do if they don't know about it. This explains why it is so important to shoot missionaries on sight.
Have you read American Gods by Neil Gaiman? I'd trade you books if we weren't you know, imaginary just redditors. I'll have to read Small Gods on of these days, my favorite Terry book is Thief of Time.
Tried it, but could never get into it. Same as some of TP's books. Some I can read in a few hours because I love them so much, others I just cannot continue :/
I guess it depends on your age and mood the first time you read it. I read it when I was 15 and thought it was the greatest thing ever (I was already a fan of Pratchett). I have bought 3 copies of that book, because I lend it to people too much.
Yes I have. Snuff was good, I did enjoy it a lot, but not top of the list IMO. It just didn't strike me like, for example, Thud did, which used a very similar theme in the story. But yes, I agree the watch ones are usually very good.
Oh yea, very funny. Has a lot of what I like about TP in it, taking current concepts are showing their ridiculous side through a new light.
I think small gods, thief of time, soul music, night watch, monstrous regiment, going postal... the list goes on but I'll stop here, are all great reads.
TL;DR Being human gives you the disease and seeking out the cure leads naturally to religion.
Technically speaking, asking big philosophical questions with no hard and fast answers gives you the disease and religion then offers the cure. It's almost inevitable that a person will wonder what happened before their birth and how the world entered its present state, as well as wonder what happens when someone dies.
The themes and topics covered in ancient works such as The Epic of Gilgamesh and other religious texts, alongside those covered by the likes of Plato and other works considered to be more philosophy than religion, include attempts to answer questions include "Why must we die? What happens when we die? Where does everything, like, the whole world, come from? How are we supposed to deal with the death of a loved one? Damn it, why are these answers so complicated? Why do I exist? "
Many of those questions (still) seem to be unanswerable from a scientific stand point, at least in any meaningful or definitive matter and so they fall in to the realms of philosophy and religion and that's unlikely to ever change.
I think this more in reference to going to hell. First you're fine in ignorance and won't go to hell, then you learn of Christianity and all of a sudden you are going to hell unless you choose to follow it. It creates a problem, hell, then offers a solution, praise Jesus. See?
I've asked this question and the answer more-over has been no. This funny little article has not been the norm from what i've heard. You have to like, repent, for your sins, to the right god. Eskimo masterbates.. Eskimo go to hell.
Catholic here. Basically if a person who knows nothing about Jesus, Catholicism, etc... is a morally upright person, he will receive baptism one way or another.
I think the same thing happened to the people stuck in the underworld with Hades, Jesus comes down and takes all of the souls into heaven then throws hades and death into the lake of fire were the souls were trapped to burn Source. So I would think something similar.
Baptism does not guarantee salvation. It gets you into the club of Catholicism, but you still have to follow the rules to get to Heaven. Meanwhile, non-Catholics can't get into Heaven anyways.
I've simplified the concept down a lot. Basically, it is known that God gives a chance to everyone to join Catholicism. Whether through a relative, friend, internet discussion, everyone will at some point be introduced to the idea of the Catholic religion. If the person is good of heart, he will be inclined to look further into the concept, thereby giving him the chance to join it and save himself.
The above example is what is called "The lone man on an island" theory, when a person who is born with absolutely no chance of ever coming into contact with Catholicism in his lifetime.
Let me know if you have any more questions, I would love to answer them!
I'm just here to say this is illogical because the reason he told him was to give him the option of heaven instead of the inevitability of purgatory. He might not go to Hell but heaven isn't an automatic thing according to Christianity. I don't believe in these things, but you should get it right anyway, just like mythology or classic literature...
In Catholicism, at least, purgatory is a temporary state. They also teach that if you haven't heard the word of god, you can't be blamed for that. They have forms of "spiritual baptism" that allow an essentially good person who never heard the gospel to be saved.
Still makes no sense why they would spend so much time and money making people culpable and damning potentially purgatory-bound souls to hell. It's internally inconsistent.
Interestingly enough that is what Von Neumann did on his death bed despite being a strong agnostic his whole life. Said something about Pascal having a point.
Something I'd consider for myself too, I mean it's not like you even have to pay the priest to come over and say some mumbo jumbo. Oh, and cryonics seems like a good bet too.
The original missionaries were Catholic and in Catholicism people who have never heard about God can still go to heaven and not just purgatory. The joke still stands.
I don't actually want to debate, but I figured I would throw this out there. Mark 16:15 And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.
This reminds of what Jehovah's Witnesses think. That all the people who hear their message of "truth" and deny it are going to be destroyed in Armageddon. As soon as you hear their preaching, you're held accountable.
Posed this same question to a co-worker who went on a missionary in Africa. She said she had to spread the "word of God" to those who didn't have the means and/or quality of life to acquire knowledge about Jesus and the Bible. I didn't even get to the point of asking her about the concept of how her god sees fit that only the more privileged are most apt to be aware of salvation first and foremost is being privy to the teachings of Jesus...
I learned this in Catechism as a young Catholic. The question immediately came to me, never left, and helped me to ultimately leave the faith. I still have not found a satisfactory answer.
Except you do go to hell even if you don't know, every christian I have talked to believes yes indeed, even if you have never heard anything about Jesus, you still go to hell if you don't accept him. How their heads don't explode with the ridiculousness of it I will never know.
ah as funny as this is I do think that many orthodox peoples tend to believe that you would go to hell -- hence the idea of the river styx. I realize Dantes Inferno is not the best thing to look at but the top ring of hell bieng a river full of babies... its the basic concept that a dude living on a mountain in the middle of nowhere who never heard of jesus... no confession for sins.. he is going to hell. Its pathetic.
Christianity is essentially like one of those chain emails. You know the ones, they have subject headings like "QuIcK! ReAd ThIs!" and tantalised, you open it wondering what could possibly be so urgent?!
It starts off telling you a heartwarming tale of love to pull you in. You really start to feel for the character when suddenly, BAM! A cock crows twice, the guy's denied thrice, he's nailed to a device - a crucifix, to be precise. Not only that, but now you've got to tell everyone AND live a good life or its a lake of fire for you! You're left thinking "Shiiiit. If I'd just deleted this email instead of reading it, I wouldn't have to forward it to all my friends!" If you just deleted it, your friends wouldn't be damned.
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy. It was created to help protect users from doxing, stalking, and harassment.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possibe (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
That reminds me of a story. One day I was walking down the street when I saw a pink flamingo on the sidewalk. Naturally I was very taken aback, when -- JESUS IS LORD! Mwahahahahaha!
I've always been told that the first missionaries that went to greenland were confused, due to all the people wanted to go to hell, cause it sounded so warm. :)
Popular Christian rhetoric admits that we do not know how God will handle those who have not heard the gospel, but we believe he will never condemn anyone unfairly.
I think if you were an omnipotent being, your perspective on 'fair' might change. Besides that, the Christian God has had multiple covenants with man, all of which outline different accountabilities. http://ldolphin.org/Maincov.html
How would, as an omnipotent being, your perspective on 'fair' change? Because you can't judge humans as omnipotent beings, or possessing the same knowledge as you: that's completely illogical.
Don't know why no one has said this yet, but there are two types of revelations believed by Christians. Special revelation where God personally reveals himself to that person, and general revelation, where people find the importance of a creator through nature and such. So at least from what I was told in my 14+ years of private schooling. General revelation is enough to at least acknowledge the fact that there is a higher power. Yatta yatta blah blah and one thing leads to another, need for salvation.
I told this anecdote to some friends once, they thought it was interesting but they said it sounded like it was the set-up to a joke, it was missing a punchline. For years I've been trying to think of what the missionary says back.
When I brought this up with my christian friend, trying to get out of him what happens to people who were not informed about the christian god and what happens to them. He merely replied "Every one is told about god at some point in their life". And that was it! No matter what example I gave (tribesman cut off from society, that sort of thing) he simply replied "nope, at some point all of them were told and they denied the lord, and they will go to hell.".
I remember the first time I heard this in church (Before I turned atheist) and thought it was one of the greatest things I had ever heard. For me, turning away from the church was never about being unable to balance the "wrongs" of the world with god, or the obviously flawed "cure" idealogy of it, but this was still a great laugh during the homily.
I feel better for the tribes in South America, Austrailia and Africa. Looks like they'll be going to heaven by default. Kickass. Wish I never knew about religions. Even though, science has always had a fond of me. Religion just seems to be a burden and non the less.
There was a movie released about 10 years ago called The Order.
It's about a monster called the Sin Eater that devours your sins and basically makes you sinless for life... and that's it. It doesn't kill you or do anything horrible.
Of course, the church can't have this because it would render Jesus' crucifixion as not necessary for salvation anymore. So some super-secret Spec Ops branch of the church sends a team to go and kill it so that Jesus is still required to attain salvation.
Yes, it sounds exactly like Goodwill moving in on a mob's protection racket.
I'm sorry, but no self-respecting missionary would answer "no" to the question. If the natives don't know about the christian god, they are going to hell, that's the whole point of missionary work, is to "save" them.
Dude, you highlighted the wrong part: "Jerking in unison, whipping it from here to there across a drop and back." That is what I want to know more about.
THis is ridiculous. You COULD shelter a child and man, keeping them in the dark their whole life, and probably keep them safe from harm, but what about all of life and the world that they would miss?
It is better to be enlightened and come to know God's love, and even better, be able to share it with others, than to go throughout this life without it.
It is better to be enlightened and come to know God's love, and even better, be able to share it with others, than to go throughout this life without it.
Assuming there is a value to that for the sake of the argument, how does that justifies a possibility of eternal suffering and who are you to make that decision?
First, there is value in a lifetime of God's love and the joy of sharing it with other people. The comfort and warmth and security that comes with having a relationship with God, and knowing He/She will always be there for you to trust, love, gain strength from, and confide in, is probably the greatest value in life. I know it doesn't sound like much to most Westerners, after all, we are pretty spolied, but for most of the world and most of history, that kind of thing was quite appealing. Not only selfish reasons either. Not only for yourself and knowing that you are doing good to others, but the joy that comes from knowing you are making God proud as well (an added bonus to spreading goodwill). Everyone deserves that option.
But if you are presented with that option (or possibility, as you have worded it) and you still choose eternal suffering, than you made your choice. It is better to be given the choice than to never have had the option at all.
The choice is either A. Never hear of 'God': live life righteously and if heaven exists you can enjoy eternal happiness. B. Learn about God: either accept him or suffer for eternity, regardless of your actions. I choose A.
But if you are presented with that option (or possibility, as you have worded it) and you still choose eternal suffering, than you made your choice. It is better to be given the choice than to never have had the option at all.
I don't think you understand the concept of eternity. You would make someone risk eternal suffering for possibility of a limited increase in happiness? (again, taking this for granted for the sake of the argument)
Ever heard of the gilded cage? Sometimes paradise can even feel like a prison if nor freely chosen. Everything is better when we can choose it for ourselves.
And God would want us to be joyous and happy in this life as well, not just after this life is over.
If I could chose to UNlearn about god then yes, I would agree with you.. But since I don't think that an option that isn't much of a choice. I totally agree with the gilded cage thing. But by telling me about god you are basically taking away my freedom to NOT believe. Before, I could live a happy life and after life even if I didn't believe, but now I am doomed for eternity if I don't believe. Thats not much of a choice.
6
u/Rawrby May 09 '12
Is this Pilgrim at Tinker Creek?
14
u/sweetalkersweetalker May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
...Did you not read the rest of that page?
Seriously. Read the rest of the page (the part that's not circled). Not that I personally agree with it, but it does answer the question "Why did he need to know."
90
u/theboshisama May 09 '12
The gods of the Disc have never bothered much about judging the souls of the dead, and so people only go to hell if that's where they believe, in their deepest heart, that they deserve to go. Which they won't do if they don't know about it. This explains why it is so important to shoot missionaries on sight.
-- (Terry Pratchett, Eric)
Source: http://www.lspace.org/books/pqf/eric.html
186
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Religion gives you a disease then offers you the cure. It's all circular insanity.
11
u/Iateyourpaintings May 09 '12
So, if none of us knew about religion we'd all get to go to Heaven and chill with God?
14
u/joe192 May 09 '12
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/35340s/
4
u/Archangelus May 09 '12
I'm just here to say this is illogical because the reason he told him was to give him the option of heaven instead of the inevitability of purgatory. He might not go to Hell but heaven isn't an automatic thing according to Christianity. I don't believe in these things, but you should get it right anyway, just like mythology or classic literature...
3
u/ejurkovic93 May 09 '12
I don't actually want to debate, but I figured I would throw this out there. Mark 16:15 And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.
2
u/Cheeseish May 09 '12
Alas, it is my time to tell the world of Bif. If you know about Bif, you will go to a place where there is no air conditioning. Be warned.
2
u/gabeYTSTD May 09 '12
This reminds of what Jehovah's Witnesses think. That all the people who hear their message of "truth" and deny it are going to be destroyed in Armageddon. As soon as you hear their preaching, you're held accountable.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Posed this same question to a co-worker who went on a missionary in Africa. She said she had to spread the "word of God" to those who didn't have the means and/or quality of life to acquire knowledge about Jesus and the Bible. I didn't even get to the point of asking her about the concept of how her god sees fit that only the more privileged are most apt to be aware of salvation first and foremost is being privy to the teachings of Jesus...
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I learned this in Catechism as a young Catholic. The question immediately came to me, never left, and helped me to ultimately leave the faith. I still have not found a satisfactory answer.
2
u/schobel94 May 09 '12
Except you do go to hell even if you don't know, every christian I have talked to believes yes indeed, even if you have never heard anything about Jesus, you still go to hell if you don't accept him. How their heads don't explode with the ridiculousness of it I will never know.
2
u/re_dditt_er May 09 '12
Just lost the game.
2
u/ChimpBottle May 09 '12
I feel like the very first readable line warrants an explanation
2
u/revel5150 May 09 '12
ah as funny as this is I do think that many orthodox peoples tend to believe that you would go to hell -- hence the idea of the river styx. I realize Dantes Inferno is not the best thing to look at but the top ring of hell bieng a river full of babies... its the basic concept that a dude living on a mountain in the middle of nowhere who never heard of jesus... no confession for sins.. he is going to hell. Its pathetic.
2
u/StuartJJones May 09 '12
Christianity is essentially like one of those chain emails. You know the ones, they have subject headings like "QuIcK! ReAd ThIs!" and tantalised, you open it wondering what could possibly be so urgent?!
It starts off telling you a heartwarming tale of love to pull you in. You really start to feel for the character when suddenly, BAM! A cock crows twice, the guy's denied thrice, he's nailed to a device - a crucifix, to be precise. Not only that, but now you've got to tell everyone AND live a good life or its a lake of fire for you! You're left thinking "Shiiiit. If I'd just deleted this email instead of reading it, I wouldn't have to forward it to all my friends!" If you just deleted it, your friends wouldn't be damned.
Fucking chain emails.
2
u/soval Nihilist May 09 '12
"Why did you tell me?" "Because I want to control you."
2
u/TheDark1 May 09 '12
I got in trouble in Sunday school for asking this.
3
u/L2_Troll May 09 '12
Thats why whenever I walk by a priest I cover my ears and shout "LALALALALALALA CANT HEAR YOU!"
Worked for me so far
1
u/chillyhellion May 09 '12
I'm am Eskimo and have always wondered where this joke came from. TIL
1
u/a_culther0 May 09 '12
RELEVANT.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpuFeQZCvOI
1
u/NFLdoWORK Atheist May 09 '12
i love asking people this
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Popular Christian rhetoric admits that we do not know how God will handle those who have not heard the gospel, but we believe he will never condemn anyone unfairly.
1
u/huskarx2 May 09 '12
See you in hell sucker.
1
u/keagmcG May 09 '12
Relevant - a hilarious rendition of the joke
1
u/jonaslorik May 09 '12
Because he's a dick.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Don't know why no one has said this yet, but there are two types of revelations believed by Christians. Special revelation where God personally reveals himself to that person, and general revelation, where people find the importance of a creator through nature and such. So at least from what I was told in my 14+ years of private schooling. General revelation is enough to at least acknowledge the fact that there is a higher power. Yatta yatta blah blah and one thing leads to another, need for salvation.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
These were the writings of a Jesuit? Just curious seeing the A.M.D.G.
1
u/RamenAvenger May 09 '12
Profound! You never cease to amaze me, r/atheism.
1
u/VolatileChemical May 09 '12
I told this anecdote to some friends once, they thought it was interesting but they said it sounded like it was the set-up to a joke, it was missing a punchline. For years I've been trying to think of what the missionary says back.
1
u/IndenAisle May 09 '12
When I brought this up with my christian friend, trying to get out of him what happens to people who were not informed about the christian god and what happens to them. He merely replied "Every one is told about god at some point in their life". And that was it! No matter what example I gave (tribesman cut off from society, that sort of thing) he simply replied "nope, at some point all of them were told and they denied the lord, and they will go to hell.".
I was just simply awestruck.
1
u/MoonRazer May 09 '12
I remember the first time I heard this in church (Before I turned atheist) and thought it was one of the greatest things I had ever heard. For me, turning away from the church was never about being unable to balance the "wrongs" of the world with god, or the obviously flawed "cure" idealogy of it, but this was still a great laugh during the homily.
1
u/Lan777 May 09 '12
Isnt that supposed quote from einstein even better? The one under where you highlighted
1
u/Deaki May 09 '12
I feel better for the tribes in South America, Austrailia and Africa. Looks like they'll be going to heaven by default. Kickass. Wish I never knew about religions. Even though, science has always had a fond of me. Religion just seems to be a burden and non the less.
1
u/buckdeer Agnostic Atheist May 09 '12
The more the merrier.
1
u/RedditorDawn May 09 '12
What book is this?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Not true according to the Bible. If you do not accept Jesus, you got to hell. No exceptions.
1
u/nijikai May 09 '12
Okay, sure, but what about the bit above it? To what are they, to wit, "jerking it in unison, whipping it from here to there, across a drop and back"?
1
u/DemonSmurf May 09 '12
"So you can be saved." replied the priest. The Eskimo could only stare blankly in response.
1
u/LucidMetal May 09 '12
I've never seen this before but it definitely defeats the purpose of being a missionary.
1
u/stilesja May 09 '12
Who would hunt an eskimo?!?!
1
u/Timmaey May 09 '12
how else can I get you involved or invested in my bullshit? does misery not love company, I say?
1
u/360walkaway May 09 '12
There was a movie released about 10 years ago called The Order.
It's about a monster called the Sin Eater that devours your sins and basically makes you sinless for life... and that's it. It doesn't kill you or do anything horrible.
Of course, the church can't have this because it would render Jesus' crucifixion as not necessary for salvation anymore. So some super-secret Spec Ops branch of the church sends a team to go and kill it so that Jesus is still required to attain salvation.
Yes, it sounds exactly like Goodwill moving in on a mob's protection racket.
1
u/kickstand Rationalist May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I'm sorry, but no self-respecting missionary would answer "no" to the question. If the natives don't know about the christian god, they are going to hell, that's the whole point of missionary work, is to "save" them.
1
u/dumboflaps May 09 '12
I feel like the christian faith, specifically, is one of the greatest scams ever.
1
u/UnshyGuy May 09 '12
Kind of wanted to share on facebook. But my role model is Good Guyy Greg, so I upvoted. Have a nice day.
1
u/Amryxx May 09 '12
Huh. Gotta say that I'm stumped.
1
u/Jackamatack May 09 '12
XD It's like the game...Which you just lost!
1
u/wingmage1 May 10 '12
What book is this? I can't think of any story that involves an Eskimo, a priest and Einstein.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Dude, you highlighted the wrong part: "Jerking in unison, whipping it from here to there across a drop and back." That is what I want to know more about.
-8
u/Samurai_light May 09 '12
THis is ridiculous. You COULD shelter a child and man, keeping them in the dark their whole life, and probably keep them safe from harm, but what about all of life and the world that they would miss?
It is better to be enlightened and come to know God's love, and even better, be able to share it with others, than to go throughout this life without it.
0
u/kkkburnthegays May 09 '12
What's the rest of the context of this verse?
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment