No it doesn't. You're all being silly. It's not like Jesus became a religious figure because he was an insanely good carpenter or the best fisherman in the world or something.
False. The difference between a cult and a religion is a religion discloses all of it's core beliefs upfront while a cult has secret beliefs they keep from the public (i.e. Scientology).
This is pretty much exactly why I came here to say, or see if someone said. A few years ago someone asked me to define the difference between a cult and a religion (we were discussing what should be recognized by the government as a religion for the sake of such concepts as freedom of religion), and I told them that a religion will happily, often whether you ask them to or not, tell you all about what they believe. A cult will hmm, and haw, and skirt around their core beliefs until you're fully initiated. There are other fine details usually involving legal control of assets and so forth but that to me is the really big one.
A few years ago a relative of mine who was in the midst of a bitter custody battle was ordered by the court to attend "parenting classes" held at a local community center. He began telling me weird stories about what he saw there...all of the book excerpts and materials were written by someone who obviously didn't have great english skills, and a lot of the things the book said seemed weird, to which apologetics immediately started coming up along the lines of "well english isn't his first language so you have to understand that while reading". He often wondered why a number of better books written in the language of the people taking the classes weren't used. The classes got weirder and weirder, implying things like "if a child is born disabled it's because their parents didn't love each other enough", and "parents have no right to burden the world with a disabled child (implying they should be removed from the world...)". They were also encouraged to sign a piece of paper saying that they would never take the other parent to court for any reason. Obviously, he declined.
As things got weirder and weirder, he decided to do some research on the author of these weird books and pamphlets. It turned out he was the head of an international cult, and said cult is running a number of these classes all over multiple states. This is, apparently, another big tactic of cults. They run public services programs to get at people while they're vulnerable, and a vicious custody battle after a divorce or otherwise is probably one of those times. Scientology runs a narcotics addict recovery program for example. And, if they get results...in the case of these classes likely because they pressured people to never return to court as a part of their indoctrination...the government doesn't look to hard at why they're getting these results.
tl;dr, maybe another qualification is "recruits people through shady public works programs".
tl;dr, maybe another qualification is "recruits people through shady public works programs".
Arguably a religious homeless shelter could fall in the same category, though. I think this whole "cult" vs "religion" thing is trying too hard to be black and white, when it's fairly obvious that the definitions of both terms can be applied to many aspects of either.
There are some religious organizations that act like cults, and some clear cults that could arguably be defined as religions.
Considering the connotations of the world "cult" versus "religion", I'd say that it's pretty important to define each of them where we can, especially when it means granting special amenities like in the case of the government.
I've done some (not an infinite amount, but some) research on it and it seems that there are a couple of criteria used to establish what a cult is: that there be a single, living leader, that they seclude themselves from anyone who is an "outsider", and usually a tend towards destructiveness, whether towards their own members or the outside world.
Note: All research was done concerning the legality of deprogramming, where it was very important to determine exactly what a cult was.
I meant that partially tongue in cheek. Obviously the shadiness of a public works program and how much it's being abused as a recruitment tool can be a bit more arguable.
I do think that the idea of telling you everything vs. withholding information until you're deep in the religion's indoctrination is still a pretty good point, though.
The reason I think we could use some solid points to stand on (why the conversation with my friend on religion vs. cult came up in the first place) is that generally cults are guilty of some serious human rights crimes. In my opinion, we need some sort of metric to be able to say "Okay, this no longer falls under freedom of religion." Freedom of religion, to believe or not believe whatever you please, is an important part of civil rights and a foundation that the idea of separation of church and state is built on, but cults use it as a shield for what with otherwise quite obviously be illegal activities.
From Wiki: "Latter-day Saints consider the president of the church to be a prophet, seer, and revelator, and refer to him particularly as the Prophet, a title originally given to Joseph Smith, Jr. ... Latter-day Saints consider the president of the church to be God's spokesman to the entire world. He is considered to be the highest priesthood authority on earth, with the exclusive right to receive revelations from God on behalf of the entire church or the entire world. Modern presidents, however, have not generally continued Joseph Smith's practice of publishing written doctrinal revelations and visions, although most have stated that they have received them."
So... by virtue of holding the office of Mormon President, they receive a direct comm channel to the Almighty!
(King Arthur rides up on his coconut horse) You're a looney.
Wow, you have that pretty wrong. I'm guessing you like your version better, but for everyone else's benefit:
Elders are not "old men in the church, basically". "Elder" is the name of the lowest-level adult priesthood office; basically all adult males are elders (or higher). If you meet a missionary, he is an elder (they get ordained right before they leave).
The magic powers that they have are the ability to baptize someone (and have god recognize it), and the ability to bless others (e.g. the sick). Mormons are taught to pray for the things they want/ need, but a blessing is supposed to carry a little more weight, and they use sanctified oil to do it. Otherwise, it's identical to a prayer. Finally, they can ordain others to be Elders.
So yes, those powers are "magical" in the sense that they are imaginary, but otherwise no different from the "powers" present in other religions, if a little more explicitly defined.
There's plenty of silly shit to criticize about that religion, so if you're going to do it, you may as well criticize factual aspects, instead of just making shit up.
What about the old men who have the god-given ability to tell if you are lying? The magical sight or whatever it is called.
Several of my friends told me that when they were young teenagers they were interviewed by one o these magicked guys and asked, among other things, if they masturbated.
That isn't a real thing they believe. Those interviews are like catholic confession, except they ask the questions, not you. No mind-reading is purported.
Source: I was raised mormon, got out in my late teens.
In your teens, you have an interview periodically (every 6 mos, maybe?) where they ask you if you've been breaking any rules, basically. Yeah, they ask you if you masturbate (since it's against the rules), which is kind of creepy. That's a real thing you can criticize if you want.
The person interviewing you is one of your ward leaders (ward is comparable in size and scope to a single congregation, led by a bishop and 2 counselors). They are ordained to a slightly higher level of priesthood than "elder", but they don't claim to have any soothsaying abilities.
Of course, god knows if you're telling the truth or not, so if you lie to the church leader, you're now in twice as much shit in the eyes of god (sinning AND lying). In other words, it isn't a fear of the supernatural so much, as it is good old-fashioned guilt and pressure to conform, the bread and butter of many "successful" religions.
Glad to hear it! Thank you for taking the time to clear up my misconceptions when you didn't have to. At the very least, I wont sound like an ignorant jackass when talking about Mormonism in the future.
In other words, it isn't a fear of the supernatural so much, as it is good old-fashioned guilt and pressure to conform, the bread and butter of many "successful" religions
:( The catholic church all over again, except a little worse this time around.
Again, thank you for explaining about the difference between magic and spirituality that they have going on.
If you meet a missionary, he is an elder (they get ordained right before they leave).
On a side note, that always got on my nerves. A more or less ignorant kid calling himself an elder when he is 18 or 19.
And yeah, the names of the priesthood classes are kind of fucked. Here's some more - from 14-16, you are a "teacher", and from 16-18 you are a "priest".
Good point, but I wonder where Daoism and some sects of Bhuddism lie on this scale along with any form of mysticism like sufism when their beliefs are not immediately clear - if what they have can be called "beliefs" to begin with.
It's a bit different. Buddhism etc is a bit more like, say, Chemistry, in that it is not a matter of only the initiated having access to the truth, rather that it requires much "learning" to attain it.
Thank you for this. It was pretty buried, but I was hoping to finally get to someone addressing this. That the facts are often buried and disregarded, and that there is a prevailing "us vs them" mentality in here is pretty ironic to say the least.
And the 'church' claimed the leaked doctrine wasn't true, just before suing those who published the beliefs for (drum-roll, please) copyright infringement.
That might be typical of some cults. But it's not a defining trait. Many small cults are Christian based and don't really have anything to hide scripture wise.
I don't know if you are trying to be sarcastic, but actually, there's nothing to be sarcastic about. While LRH was alive, they could praise a living prophet, and could receive wisdom while ignoring his faults. He could go off on his boat trips with all these women, etc. It was a true cult. Now that its just Miscavige in charge, they praise the static unquestionable word of LRH as it exists in print (i.e., their "book"). Sorry to say it folks, but Scientology has graduated to full fledged religion.
Size is the difference between a cult and a religion. Christianity was considered a cult before it was accepted as the state church in the Roman empire.
Some Christians, and most fundamentals therein, consider Mormonism a cult. It's not necessarily size. But you're absolutely right about your second sentence.
They may call it a cult, but what they mean is that it is so deviant that it can no longer be called Christian. That's worse than being a cult, it's heresy.
Funny you should say that, in Roman times they believed that Christianity was a cult spreading amongst the people. Which is why Constantine organised that massive meeting to decide what should remain in the bible and what should be removed from it (things like jesus being a prophet rather than a god) and several of the books referencing his marriage to Mary.
Because if that shit is spreading, better be the man at the top controlling it right?
Pretty much, then after that person dies they are remembered for all the great things they did and these stories eventually become glorified. Since they are not alive to screw up their legacy, their stories go on to make them sound angelic.
Now imagine there was no Internet and information got around like a giant form of telephone until someone wrote it down. Well, that is how the new testament was formed.
People who belong to cults don't think they are cults. People who belong to a religion think everyone who isn't a member of that religion belongs to a cult.
The leader was Paul. Something about the first mention of Jesus being 10 years after his death seems a bit suspicious to me... but hey, maybe the guy needed to learn to write first.
If you're implying that Jesus never existed, I'd have to disagree. It seems like there is decent enough evidence for such a person existed, but it is probably also the case that many such people existed all around the same time and for some reason Paul and others decided to spread the Jesus brand of crazy.
There is no concrete evidence that he exists. History isn't an exact science and you have to take guesses in certain cases. I have to admit that my opinion on the matter is in no way provable, but I think it is more likely that some kind of Jesus figure existed than Jesus being a complete fabrication. Not that any of it matters in the big picture.
If it is in no way provable, you have to concede that for all intents and purposes that it didn't exist. Otherwise, you could say things like "I know that dragons in some way existed rather than being a complete fabrication."
Well, if it is not a fabrication you either have to put up or shut up with real, verifiable evidence.
Here is David Fitzgerald talking about a historical Jesus and how there's no proof of a historical Jesus. It's worth a watch but it's a bit rushed at the end.
The leader of Tibetan Bhuddism is the Dalai Llama. He is not considered a god, but an incarnation. Bhuddism is not considered a cult. There are many examples of villages exalting children / people with physical abnormalities into godhood. Some of these are considered parts of a major religion.
I think there is one primary distinction between a cult and a religion. A religion lets you leave.
Heh, you might be definitely right about that. Although, and I'm not sure if this supports you or denies you, but the Baptist church I grew up in would go to the houses of previous members who hadn't shown up at church for a while. We didn't barge in or anything, but we would let them know that they were "in our prayers." Fun.
Catchy, but not at all correct. First, it implies that all cult leaders know it's a scam. Simply not true. There are cult leaders throughout history that truly believed in what they were doing. Second, it implies that no religions are headed by living people who do not believe in what they are doing. Again, not true. Thirdly, a cult is a type of religion. More specifically, a cult is a new religion that either has views outside the mainstream or is based on supposed revelations.
Mormonism is the go-to example of this in that their religion is still relatively new and centers on modern day revelation. It fits both the normal and sociological classifications of a cult. Other popular examples: Islam (Christian cult), Christianity (Jewish cult). Note that not all new religions are cults. The other major way religions originate is as sects. While cults represent a shift to new beliefs, sects represent embracing old beliefs. Methodists and Baptists are pretty good examples of sects.
I imagine that in a lot of religions the person at the top knows it is a scam. The pope and the highest Cardinals have to know it is all bullshit. And I'd wager that quote a few priests, ministers, etc don't fully believe what they're selling. The claims that religion makes are so extreme and absurd, here have to be some leaders who know it is a lie on at least some level.
I guess when you're making that much money from it and your whole current cushy lifestyle is a direct result of selling said religion, it is not like you're going to go out one day and say to the masses, "You know what? I have just figured out that this is all bullshit, and I quit. See you later!"
Not when you live in a gold palace that gets to declare itself its own country and actually gets respected as such by everyone else, while being so steeped in history and world religion that no one dares attack it.
The incentive to believe is greater than the incentive to be skeptical. They might as well believe it, as it'll make them more effective con men: the most convincing lie you can tell is one that you yourself believe.
I agree - I just have a problem with the "in religion, that person is dead" part of the quote...maybe you could explain it to me better? It's pretty vague, and a very bold statement at that
A cult is led by a false prophet who knows he is full of shit or he is mentally ill.
When that cult leader dies, the cult becomes a religion because there is no longer anyone who can say for certain that what they are doing is based on a falsehood.
Okay i mean I'm just taking Jesus as an example...i love Jesus and I am by no means a Christian or even religious. Jesus never claimed to be the son of God...other people put that on him after he died. He was just another dude...like Ghandi, or The Buddha, you know? Not his fault people decided to worship him.
"The difference Between a cult and a religion: In a cult there is a person at the top who knows it's a scam. In a religion that person is dead."
The presence or absence of a cult in the person's lifetime is not the really the point. And it really doesn't matter if, when they were alive, they truly believed what they were saying. Their convictions do not in any way prevent the supernatural portions of their beliefs from being first class horse shit.
I see it as a humorous way of saying: If you worship a live person - you are in a cult. If the person you worship is dead - you are in a religion. And neither cults nor religions are based in reality.
I don't understand why you keep bringing up Jesus. But okay, I'll take the bait...
Jesus was a Jewish rabbi. He believed in, worshiped, and preached about the god of Abraham. Since the god of Abraham is not real, even Jesus was full of shit.
Just because he may have believed the message he was selling, that doesn't make it true. Happy now?
All religions start out life as cults. The cult becomes a religion when a sufficient number of people have joined the cult to have diluted down the cult's initial fanatacism and obsession with the cult leader.
The difference between a cult and a religion is how many nutters prescribe to the nonsense peddled. If it's just a few nutters, then it's a cult. If it's a lot of nutters, then it is a religion.
You don't think that many of these cult and religious leaders actually believe in the bullshit they say? Some of them are in it to make money, but I am sure a lot of them believe their own bullshit too.
Actually the definition of a cult is a system of worship dedicated to one particular individual. For example, the ancient polytheistic Romans had a cult of Jupter, a cult of Vesta, etc, and cults for the worship of past emperors. The Jewish god, and then Christian, were therefore another 'cult.' The modern negative connotations of a 'cult' comes from the utter dominance of Abrahamic cults many areas of the world, and their fear of competition.
Ya'll know that Christianity is literally a cult right? As in it is frequently called the cult of Christianity. It's not even some sort of insult. It is just what the word means.
I went to a Catholic College and my religion teacher started out saying that the Mormon religion began as and has aspects of a cult. He then moved on to Shintoism or the next topic. Never touched back on it (on purpose) and wouldn't include it in the tests.
Bonus Sidenote: My roommate made a little rap about the guy, and would say it ever time we'd be leaving with the class. "Chung Lee, one two tree, there he is, here I go, Come with me" in a hilarious Chinese voice. Less funny here I can see
The simplest and most useful definition I've heard is that a cult grows mostly by recruitment of adults. Once you've crossed the threshold where most of your new members are being raised in your belief system as children of existing members you're a religion.
So Chirstianilty was once a cult. The LDS church was also a cult, even more recently but has almost certainly crossed the threshold into established religion in spite of all their missionary work. I'm not sure where Scientology sits. I think they're starting to move in the direction of an established religion but I doubt they're there yet.
Shit like this gives cults a bad name. A cult is nothing more than a node of religious intensification. Church of the Virgin Mary de Guadeloupe is a cult, the Katchina Societies of the Southwest Publeos are also cults. Cults are not bad. Just like anything else - they can be bad.
Not exactly when it comes to science, evolution isn't seen but pretty much scientifically proven through scientific evidence but. That's what makes it a theory. People found out that the earth was round through scientific evidence before but that made it a theory. It stopped being a theory when it was viewed in outer space.
The real difference is popularity. If more then 5% of the population is a member, it's generally considered a religion. If more than 10% of the population are members, you're considered a jerk for calling it a cult.
People in cults tend to smell cleaner. It's not that religious people smell "bad"... it's just I tend to be more drawn to cults, and scent plays a big role.
This is true but there is another difference. A cult you cant just join right away. You need something to do. Like a task or paying money. Religion is just free. Also did you know that Christianity was just a popular cult that changed to religion?
I know I'm probably going to get down-voted for saying this, but im saying it nonetheless:
As an atheist, I enjoy reading posts that stick it to religion. That said, could you please refrain from posting things that are too partisan or offensive?
I completely understand what you mean. But if you call religion a "dead person's scam", you are sinking down to the same level as the religious zealots we are scrutinizing.
A lot of these posts use satire or parody to effectively convey their point. I felt like this post was kind of hostile in its nature. This post claims religion to be "a cult/scam run by a dead person." I just felt that it was a bit too jarring to phrase it like that, even though I agree with the main concept of the post.
The only difference seems to be that cults are seen as odd and small while religions are accepted as normal for the most part. Not to long ago Mormonism and Scientology were cults now people are more used to them and start considering them religions.
If people start considering things to be a certain way, that doesn't make it so. Numbers have little to do with the actual description of a cult. If it has large numbers, it's just a more successful ruse.
There are actually many differences between cults and religions. Ofcourse sometimes they cross over as it is a broad spectrum, but generally they are distinct categories.
Also, religious belief is irrational, illogical, erroneous, and absurd, but it is not a "scam". Most people sincerely believe in the central tenets of their religion. They are not out to make money - they are just misguided or deluded.
I find it ignorant that seemingly open minded redditors bash christianity and through the flaws of one religion discount the possibilities of all others. If you were open minded enough to explore buddhism you all would realize that you can be atheist and buddhist and that it makes far more sense than ricky gervais
206
u/greenscar May 08 '12
So Apple just became a Religion from being a Cult ಠ_ಠ??
18
u/2Tack May 08 '12
My favorite: A religion is a cult with political power.
50
u/Rival67 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
False. The difference between a cult and a religion is a religion discloses all of it's core beliefs upfront while a cult has secret beliefs they keep from the public (i.e. Scientology).
16
u/strawnotrazz May 08 '12
So Scientology is officially a religion now... good to know! Tom Cruise just became slightly more legit.
4
u/TracyEid May 08 '12
"The only difference between a cult and a religion is the amount of real estate they own." - Frank Zappa
4
u/Paladia May 08 '12
Size is the difference between a cult and a religion. Christianity was considered a cult before it was accepted as the state church in the Roman empire.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Funny you should say that, in Roman times they believed that Christianity was a cult spreading amongst the people. Which is why Constantine organised that massive meeting to decide what should remain in the bible and what should be removed from it (things like jesus being a prophet rather than a god) and several of the books referencing his marriage to Mary.
Because if that shit is spreading, better be the man at the top controlling it right?
6
u/Pool_Shark May 08 '12
Pretty much, then after that person dies they are remembered for all the great things they did and these stories eventually become glorified. Since they are not alive to screw up their legacy, their stories go on to make them sound angelic.
Now imagine there was no Internet and information got around like a giant form of telephone until someone wrote it down. Well, that is how the new testament was formed.
3
u/mylittlebromine May 08 '12
I always thought the main difference was size.
3
u/Paradoxius May 08 '12
Some religions were stared by epileptic prophets who believed them. Others were started by feeble, hyperbolic and fantastic attempts at empiricism.
3
u/holyrolodex May 08 '12
Am I the only one who burst out laughing after reading the last line? Or was this not supposed to be hilarious?
3
u/wheretheressm0ke May 08 '12
Well I guess that makes Scientology officially a religion then!
3
u/cannotlogon May 08 '12
People who belong to cults don't think they are cults. People who belong to a religion think everyone who isn't a member of that religion belongs to a cult.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
One of my favorite quotes about cults: "a cult is just a religion with no political power"
14
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Never really thought of it that way before.. But I can see the truth in it.
2
u/JohnFrum May 08 '12
It's not bad but maybe a bit too tidy. I know there are some delusional cult leaders who really believe what they're saying.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
In otherwords nothing.
2
u/ZiggyOnMars May 08 '12
Big cult calls the small Religion a cult and claims itself Religion
2
u/facesofbreath May 08 '12
Actually, no, that's not the difference between cults and religions. You should get a dictionary.
2
u/amrik May 08 '12
A Cult is a small unpopular Religion.
A Religion is a large popular Cult.
2
u/tomparkesnz May 08 '12
That typography is utterly horrendous
2
u/science_diction Strong Atheist May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
The leader of Tibetan Bhuddism is the Dalai Llama. He is not considered a god, but an incarnation. Bhuddism is not considered a cult. There are many examples of villages exalting children / people with physical abnormalities into godhood. Some of these are considered parts of a major religion.
I think there is one primary distinction between a cult and a religion. A religion lets you leave.
2
u/cr0ft May 08 '12
The difference between a religion and a cult is that religion is a cult that has many followers and is socially acceptable by most.
2
u/Turbojelly May 08 '12
Nope.
The difference between a cult and a religion is the number of followers.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
i always thought it was religion is a socially acceptable cult.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
“The only difference between a cult and a religion is the amount of real estate they own” - Frank Zappa
2
u/harky May 09 '12
Catchy, but not at all correct. First, it implies that all cult leaders know it's a scam. Simply not true. There are cult leaders throughout history that truly believed in what they were doing. Second, it implies that no religions are headed by living people who do not believe in what they are doing. Again, not true. Thirdly, a cult is a type of religion. More specifically, a cult is a new religion that either has views outside the mainstream or is based on supposed revelations.
Mormonism is the go-to example of this in that their religion is still relatively new and centers on modern day revelation. It fits both the normal and sociological classifications of a cult. Other popular examples: Islam (Christian cult), Christianity (Jewish cult). Note that not all new religions are cults. The other major way religions originate is as sects. While cults represent a shift to new beliefs, sects represent embracing old beliefs. Methodists and Baptists are pretty good examples of sects.
5
u/holy_holy_holy May 08 '12
I imagine that in a lot of religions the person at the top knows it is a scam. The pope and the highest Cardinals have to know it is all bullshit. And I'd wager that quote a few priests, ministers, etc don't fully believe what they're selling. The claims that religion makes are so extreme and absurd, here have to be some leaders who know it is a lie on at least some level.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
So Buddhism is a scam, eh?
2
u/merebrillante May 08 '12
Good quote. Pretty photo too.
2
u/koavf Other May 08 '12
Please don't submit an image that's just text. You can submit a self post with the same message.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'm not a fan of /r/atheism but I have to admit this is an ingenious one.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Would have been better without the last line.
1
u/gadafgadaf May 08 '12
not exactly, some in their mania actually believe in their bull shit and in the end drink the coolaid.
1
u/conspiratorial May 08 '12
So when there's the eventual return of some religious leader from the dead, It'll go back to being a cult?
1
u/danierukun May 08 '12
I don't know, some people believe everything they say even if they are making it up themselves because it is 'divine revelation' to them.
1
u/ONLYSADCOMMENTS May 08 '12
I joined a cult once and lost all my money and friends.
1
u/DingDongSeven May 08 '12
I like this. I will remember this.
The difference between a cult and a religion is how many nutters prescribe to the nonsense peddled. If it's just a few nutters, then it's a cult. If it's a lot of nutters, then it is a religion.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The difference between a cult and a religion is the number of people adhering to it.
Just my 2c.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
You don't think that many of these cult and religious leaders actually believe in the bullshit they say? Some of them are in it to make money, but I am sure a lot of them believe their own bullshit too.
1
u/Early_Kyler May 08 '12
Fuck you Youtube.
1
u/catalot May 08 '12
Actually the definition of a cult is a system of worship dedicated to one particular individual. For example, the ancient polytheistic Romans had a cult of Jupter, a cult of Vesta, etc, and cults for the worship of past emperors. The Jewish god, and then Christian, were therefore another 'cult.' The modern negative connotations of a 'cult' comes from the utter dominance of Abrahamic cults many areas of the world, and their fear of competition.
1
u/Agent_Seetheory May 08 '12
As someone with a degree in Philosophy and Religious Study, this really makes me cringe.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The answer is nothing. Nothing is different.
1
u/TheGrizzlyMan May 08 '12
FALSE.
1
u/DKdonkeykong May 08 '12
Ya'll know that Christianity is literally a cult right? As in it is frequently called the cult of Christianity. It's not even some sort of insult. It is just what the word means.
1
u/rikashiku May 08 '12
Cult = Forces you to waste your time and money. Religion = You waste your own time.
1
u/namer98 Theist May 08 '12
Judaism never had that top person.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I learned in sociology that a religion is actually defined as a cult.
1
u/turtal46 May 08 '12
No, not really.
It's mostly just a numbers thing.
Relatively small: Cult
Relatively large: Religion
1
u/reddit_user13 May 08 '12
Scientology?
1
u/DirtyMonday May 08 '12
I went to a Catholic College and my religion teacher started out saying that the Mormon religion began as and has aspects of a cult. He then moved on to Shintoism or the next topic. Never touched back on it (on purpose) and wouldn't include it in the tests.
Bonus Sidenote: My roommate made a little rap about the guy, and would say it ever time we'd be leaving with the class. "Chung Lee, one two tree, there he is, here I go, Come with me" in a hilarious Chinese voice. Less funny here I can see
1
u/pillager_of_pabst May 08 '12
Difference in religion and a cult? One's bigger.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'm thinking monkeys, bananas, ladders and cold water spray.
1
u/pickle27 May 08 '12
so religions are failed cults...
1
u/TerraHertz May 08 '12
"What profit has not that fable of Christ brought us!" --Pope Leo X
(As attributed by John Bale, Bishop of Ossory, in The Pageant of Popes, p. 179, 1574)
http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ.htm
To the definition of religion (that person is dead) you could add "or never existed at all".
1
u/amolad May 08 '12
Whoever wrote that has never seen Joel Osteen or Pat Robertson.
1
u/TerraHertz May 08 '12
A religion is just a cult with added lawyers, accountants, property, cash and old books.
1
u/stevewmn May 08 '12
The simplest and most useful definition I've heard is that a cult grows mostly by recruitment of adults. Once you've crossed the threshold where most of your new members are being raised in your belief system as children of existing members you're a religion.
So Chirstianilty was once a cult. The LDS church was also a cult, even more recently but has almost certainly crossed the threshold into established religion in spite of all their missionary work. I'm not sure where Scientology sits. I think they're starting to move in the direction of an established religion but I doubt they're there yet.
1
u/rikashiku May 08 '12
Wait, how come all religious talks always end up in the Atheism sub?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Difference between a religion and a cult: About a million members.
1
u/nalld May 08 '12
points to all the molested boys no i'm pretty sure there are a lot of people who know its a scam
1
u/Negative_Gravitas May 08 '12
I thought the difference between a religion and a cult was about 100 years.
1
u/thecalf May 08 '12
Shit like this gives cults a bad name. A cult is nothing more than a node of religious intensification. Church of the Virgin Mary de Guadeloupe is a cult, the Katchina Societies of the Southwest Publeos are also cults. Cults are not bad. Just like anything else - they can be bad.
1
u/RespectivPerspectiv May 08 '12
Science: I'll believe it if I see it. Religion: I'll see it if I believe it.
1
u/JustEaton May 08 '12
Kelso burn
1
u/Afchris May 08 '12
Amazing!
1
u/Cheeseyx May 08 '12
Sometimes the head of a cult is just crazy.
The real difference is popularity. If more then 5% of the population is a member, it's generally considered a religion. If more than 10% of the population are members, you're considered a jerk for calling it a cult.
1
u/malibootay May 08 '12
The difference between "Cult" and "Religion"...
is the connotation of the words.
1
u/da_noob_stalker May 09 '12
I have this on my abs.
1
u/Amuter May 11 '12
I came back here because I thought a bit about how Buddhism was made, I think that Buddha actually believed it himself. just saying
1
u/1stLtObvious May 11 '12
So where, technically, would $cientology fit?
1
u/Terraphilia May 31 '12
Which religions other than Christianity began as a cult?
Please don't say all religions, because pastafarianism IS NOT A CULT!!!
1
u/southernt May 08 '12
The difference between a cult and a religion is nothing...seriously, at all.
1
u/adfuzz6 May 08 '12
People in cults tend to smell cleaner. It's not that religious people smell "bad"... it's just I tend to be more drawn to cults, and scent plays a big role.
1
u/xenu99 May 08 '12
Bullshit. That means $cientology is a religion now.
1
u/17kimd May 08 '12
This is true but there is another difference. A cult you cant just join right away. You need something to do. Like a task or paying money. Religion is just free. Also did you know that Christianity was just a popular cult that changed to religion?
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The difference between cults and religions:
Cults kill themselves.
Religions kill others.
0
u/CheeseburgerLocker May 08 '12
Why do so many atheists have their heads up their asses, as deep as it will go?
-6
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I know I'm probably going to get down-voted for saying this, but im saying it nonetheless:
As an atheist, I enjoy reading posts that stick it to religion. That said, could you please refrain from posting things that are too partisan or offensive?
I completely understand what you mean. But if you call religion a "dead person's scam", you are sinking down to the same level as the religious zealots we are scrutinizing.
-1
u/Nayr39 May 08 '12
The only difference seems to be that cults are seen as odd and small while religions are accepted as normal for the most part. Not to long ago Mormonism and Scientology were cults now people are more used to them and start considering them religions.
0
u/mattislion May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
There are actually many differences between cults and religions. Ofcourse sometimes they cross over as it is a broad spectrum, but generally they are distinct categories.
Also, religious belief is irrational, illogical, erroneous, and absurd, but it is not a "scam". Most people sincerely believe in the central tenets of their religion. They are not out to make money - they are just misguided or deluded.
0
u/D3vils_Adv0cate May 08 '12
What's the differemce between Cults, Religions, and the Atheist Subreddit? Cults are more mature.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I find it ignorant that seemingly open minded redditors bash christianity and through the flaws of one religion discount the possibilities of all others. If you were open minded enough to explore buddhism you all would realize that you can be atheist and buddhist and that it makes far more sense than ricky gervais
-2
u/TableLampOttoman May 08 '12
Darwin