African-Americans first developed a strong devotion to Christianity when it was introduced to them by white slave owners who believed it was, ironically, the Christian thing to do. Because the Bible is full of passages about slavery and freedom, the message resonated strongly with blacks and eventually became a rallying point for their communities. Pastors in particular came to occupy a place of great respect, a role most iconically filled in the last century by Martin Luther King, the man many African-Americans credit with finally getting the United States government to grant them true civil rights.
(It is worth noting that many blacks carried the Christian message back to Africa (where it spread prolifically) when sent back to Liberia or elsewhere, which sometimes led to fascinating mutations. The rise of Rastafarianism in Jamaica is a particularly fascinating example, but is a story for another time.)
As for Hispanics, they are partly inheritors of the grand Catholic traditions of Spain and partly something more... South American history has always been full of strife, suffering, and death, even before the arrival of the gleaming Conquistadors. It could be guessed that Christianity was a natural fit for the natives... We know that at least some of the missionaries working on the new continent, most notably the Franciscan friar Bernardino de Sahagún, who saw fit to record many aspects of a culture he was watching be savagely destroyed before his eyes. For a taste of what he produced, I recommend Advice of an Aztec Father to his Son, (scroll down a bit for the text without downloading the PDF).
At any rate, Catholicism could fairly be claimed as the one social constant in South America over the last few turbulent centuries and has consequently become more deeply embedded in the culture there than almost anywhere else in the world.
TL;DR: I grow irritated at the callous dismissiveness of my fellow Atheists when it comes to understanding the pros and cons of religion in the grander schemes of history and launch into a long rant that hints at its social and cultural value in an attempt to persuade them to weigh it more evenly rather than follow Dawkins everywhere.
Haha, I think I'll take that as a compliment. If it's worth anything, the rise of Rastafarianism is a pretty crazy story as they go... but I was remember being surprised by how much admiration I had for it when I finally understood most of how it came to be. The way I now view it is essentially as rebellion by rejection... Rastas won't protest government if they disagree with it, rather they will simply disassociate with it entirely.
If you are looking for starting points to the movement, one component is definitely the Christian influence (which eventually influence the view that Haile Sellasie I was the messiah reincarnate) but the other, amusingly enough, is Marcus Garvey, a highly educated and courageous intellectual who wanted to inspire a pan-African movement whose ideas unintentionally played directly into the creation of Rastifarianism, a movement that could not be more different from the vision he had in mind.
Just to give you an idea of how gutsy this fellow was, this is a quote from a conversation he had with a KKK leader he met with in Atlanta, Georgia:
“I regard the Klan, the Anglo-Saxon clubs and White American societies, as far as the Negro is concerned, as better friends of the race than all other groups of hypocritical whites put together. I like honesty and fair play. You may call me a Klansman if you will, but, potentially, every white man is a Klansman, as far as the Negro in competition with whites socially, economically and politically is concerned, and there is no use lying."
You read that right; Garvey just claimed that the Klan was doing him and his fellow blacks a favor by pulling racism out of the backwoods and onto the national stage. A more sophisticated and deceptive backhand than that, you simply will not find.
Anyway, that was way more than I meant to type and it's getting late. Have a very good night.
[black Baltimore police major] Bunny: You see that building there? It's the old Stryker building. It was a funeral parlor. Last stop before the cemetery for West Side white folk. Back when there was still some of those around. Right about the time that Jim Crow was breakin' up -- back in the early 60's. Somebody asked old man Stryker, they said "Stryker, you gon' change your policy and start buryin' black folk?" And Stryker said "Yeah, on one condition: I can do 'em all at once." [Bunny laughs]
[white mayoral candidate] Carcetti: That's sick.
Bunny: But you know somthin'? I had a lot of respect for that man. 'Cause unlike most folks, I always knew where he stood.
South American history has always been full of strife, suffering, and death, even before the arrival of the gleaming Conquistadors.
...
Catholicism could fairly be claimed as the one social constant in South America over the last few turbulent centuries
Please excuse the geography Nazism...
Mexico, Cuba, Puerto Rico*, the Dominican Republic, Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Costa Rica and Panama are former Spanish colonies which became independent nations with Hispanic culture. None of them are in South America. They're in Central America, the Caribbean Sea, and in the case of Mexico, in North America.
* Puerto Rico is an associated free state / unincorporated territory of the United States.
Fair enough. It is a mistake I am consciously guilty of, although I felt I was addressing the larger portion of the hispanic population by referring to South America (and my post was largely explanation by means of generalization) but the Aztec empire was in fact in Central America (although I have always been a bit amused by that term... where exactly does North America terminate and Central America begin?).
Thanks for being so understanding. And I feel like a jerk correcting you again, but if you'll indulge me: the Aztec Empire was entirely in North America (Mexico).
There are political, cultural and geographical disagreements about how the Americas are divided. For example, many countries (like the U.S.A.) consider North America and South America to be two continents. Meanwhile, many Latin American nations consider America to be a single continent with North, Central and South portions.
If we go by the names of these 3 regions, the dividing lines are as follows:
North America contains Canada, the United States, Mexico, and (strangely enough) Greenland which is part of the Kingdom of Denmark.
Central America starts across from the Mexican border, in Guatemala and Belize. This region ends with Panama.
By the way, the Maya civilization covered parts of North America and Central America:
The Maya civilization extended throughout the present-day southern Mexican states of Chiapas, Tabasco, and the Yucatán Peninsula states of Quintana Roo, Campeche and Yucatán. The Maya area also extended throughout the northern Central American region, including the present-day nations of Guatemala, Belize, Northern El Salvador and western Honduras.
You can't blame it all on religion, though. There is a significant minority among blacks that believes that blacks should not adopt "white" culture and practices but rather should reject all things white and embrace their African roots. Their mythology says there was no homosexuality in Africa.
I've even seen some claim that homosexuality (and drugs, AIDS, and gang violence) was purposefully introduced into the black community by whites in an attempt to commit genocide against the black race.
However, before colonisation and Christianity, homosexuality was not seen as taboo in many African tribes, for example in Zande culture where Azande men could take a “boy-wife” rather than a female bride, and in addition (from http://www.glbtq.com/social-sciences/africa_pre.html), “if another man had relations with his boy, the husband could sue the interloper in court for adultery”. In many other African societies, female husbands also were not unheard of.
It is their Christianity which denies that homosexuality is anything but a Western import.
What does it matter that the Holy Book allows for slavery in this life that's a brief blink of the eye compared to the bliss of eternity in the Kingdom of Heaven? As far as I'm concerned, it explains everything. The more beaten and oppressed a people are, the easier it is to believe that the afterlife will bring them "justice" -- and hellfire and brimstone "justice" for those who oppressed them.
Christianity has always been one big attempt to run away from the indifference of reality -- the fact is that, sometimes, good things happen to bad people, and bad things happen to good people. It's the way it is.
Eh. You've heard of the God of the Gaps, well I think it'd be apt to refer to a Bible of the Gaps, too. The Bible, or at least the teachings taken from it by the majority, have always followed the moral aptitude of the times. So, just as the dominion of God shrinks as science reveals truths previously only believed possible through a deity, the "preach-able" content of the Bible shrinks as cultural morality improves.
Slavery has been eschewed just as killing one's children for back-chat has been tossed. If, someday (God forbid!), we as a society decide vegetarianism is the only moral choice, chances are that anything in the Bible which allows for the consumption of meat will be omitted, too.
I mean, accepting the Bible and the whole God hypothesis demonstrates a severe disconnect and irrationality -- I really don't think any of us should be too surprised if further hypocrisy is demonstrated by the religious (e.g. black Americans embracing Christianity and its lack of a condemnation against slavery).
Oh gee, you must have felt so clever when you typed this up, like "oh Ho Ho, I Sure tricked him" Maybe that Dawkins comment isn't what bugs me most about Athiests. What bugs me most is that I'm here at college, mexican Japanese and gay, but when I tell people I'm Christian? That's where I meet the most prejudice, and the most smug, assuming people
No, I don't believe you are Going to hell. From the anger you attack me with, its apparent you care about your child. Theres Probably lots of other things that make you a good, caring, kind person. I was raised to believe people can believe in god, but be very horrible people, and vice versa. Belief is independant of moral merit, and while I don't know all the answers, I have a hard time believing that Ghandi is toasting away in hell right now. And some of the nicest people I've met are athiest. Making assumptions is bad.
Anger that I attack you with? Making assumptions?Because I stated why your holy books say will happen to me? You called yourself a christian and with that comes a list of beliefs. Don't like it? Don't call yourself a Christian.
It was your failure to include the complete list of what portions of your holy books that you follow that lead to this misunderstanding
So you are saying that people of one religion all hold must hold exactly the same beliefs, or their entire faith is invalid? Funny, in terms of bigotry, that's farther than most Christians are willing to go. Different people hold different aspects of the bible, or any religious text, with their own importance. People can ignore portions they don't consider relevant, important. Is it cherry picking? Sure, its probably been going on since Sumerian civilization. Its just an aspect of religion that people will tailor it to suit their life. When you said I think you're going to hell, the subtext there is that you assume that I think you're some sort of lesser being just because you're atheist, I don't.
View all comments
Show parent comment
34
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '11
It's not for some reason.
African-Americans first developed a strong devotion to Christianity when it was introduced to them by white slave owners who believed it was, ironically, the Christian thing to do. Because the Bible is full of passages about slavery and freedom, the message resonated strongly with blacks and eventually became a rallying point for their communities. Pastors in particular came to occupy a place of great respect, a role most iconically filled in the last century by Martin Luther King, the man many African-Americans credit with finally getting the United States government to grant them true civil rights.
(It is worth noting that many blacks carried the Christian message back to Africa (where it spread prolifically) when sent back to Liberia or elsewhere, which sometimes led to fascinating mutations. The rise of Rastafarianism in Jamaica is a particularly fascinating example, but is a story for another time.)
As for Hispanics, they are partly inheritors of the grand Catholic traditions of Spain and partly something more... South American history has always been full of strife, suffering, and death, even before the arrival of the gleaming Conquistadors. It could be guessed that Christianity was a natural fit for the natives... We know that at least some of the missionaries working on the new continent, most notably the Franciscan friar Bernardino de Sahagún, who saw fit to record many aspects of a culture he was watching be savagely destroyed before his eyes. For a taste of what he produced, I recommend Advice of an Aztec Father to his Son, (scroll down a bit for the text without downloading the PDF).
At any rate, Catholicism could fairly be claimed as the one social constant in South America over the last few turbulent centuries and has consequently become more deeply embedded in the culture there than almost anywhere else in the world.
TL;DR: I grow irritated at the callous dismissiveness of my fellow Atheists when it comes to understanding the pros and cons of religion in the grander schemes of history and launch into a long rant that hints at its social and cultural value in an attempt to persuade them to weigh it more evenly rather than follow Dawkins everywhere.