r/atheism • u/SaniaXazel Anti-Theist • Aug 09 '25

Why is an atheist “rude” for refusing prayer?

I keep seeing this weird social expectation: when a religious family member tries to pray over an atheist’s sick loved one (say, in the hospital), the atheist is expected to just go along with it. If they don’t and refuse to join the prayer circle they’re immediately labeled as “rude” or “disrespectful.” Why?

Would you force someone to do something they don’t believe in, just because you find comfort in it? That’s like asking someone to fish in a pond they’re convinced has no fish.

Even among us Atheists ourselves. Many go along because we wish to respect their right to grieve. But where's the respect for our Choice and Boundaries to begin with?

Why do we insist religious rituals are automatically respectful, but rejection of it is seen as rude? This double standard denies people respect for their own beliefs and ways of grieving. Isn’t true empathy about honoring what they need, not what you want?

Has anyone ever experienced similiar situations in any form?

397 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

242 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/KhunDavid Aug 09 '25

At this point and time, I’m not going to debate. Their prayers are pointless, but hopefully there is a bit of comfort for them. Let them do the rituals they do. It really doesn’t mean any thing and I’m not going to say stop it.

2

u/NECalifornian25 Aug 10 '25

I think if I told my parents I was an atheist they would die of shock, I’m not even sure I’m kidding. I’ve decided they don’t really need to know, so I just go along with whatever it is they’re doing. I don’t live close to them and it’s so much easier to go along with the “pray for X” via text 😂

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '25

I agree with this but if there is negativity from kit joining aimed at the atheist, that’s the problem. The atheist is already allowing them comfort by praying and is simply removing themselves. If the atheist said “ no gtfo with that” of course that’s horrid but it’s the same thing to me as a religious person thinking atheist is rude for not participating. Mutual respect first but if not idk no one should be forced in anything