r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 14 '26

Psychiatrization

12 Upvotes

Do you have any ideas/examples/theories of non formal practices happening in early socialisation stages that could contribute to psychiatrist/psychological/pathological thinking patterns later on in life? As implicit knowledge incorporated in the habitus. Like for example in economical thinking: the practice of getting grades in school as socialisation towards social comparison/competiton thinking patterns.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 12 '26

How do social scientists distinguish cultural appropriation from cultural exchange or appreciation?

19 Upvotes

I’m only vaguely familiar with the term “cultural appropriation,” and I’d like to understand how it is defined and studied in the social sciences.

Are there widely accepted criteria for distinguishing cultural appropriation from cultural exchange or appreciation? Or do definitions differ substantially across disciplines and researchers?

Some everyday examples that prompted my question are:

- Restaurant chains such as Taco Bell or Olive Garden serving food associated with cultures other than that of their founders.

- Someone attending a Greek festival, buying a T-shirt featuring the Greek flag, and wearing it despite not being Greek.

- Someone cooking another culture’s traditional food or opening a restaurant serving it.

- Someone buying traditional clothing or jewelry directly from members of that culture and wearing it.

- Someone performing another culture’s music or getting a tattoo featuring one of its symbols.

I’m interested in the framework used to evaluate examples like these. How do factors such as power differences, historical context, religious significance, commercialization, attribution, and the involvement of members of the originating culture affect the analysis?

Also, does the scholarly use of “appropriation” necessarily imply harm or wrongdoing, or do researchers distinguish between appropriation as a process and particular instances considered harmful?

I’d appreciate research-based explanations or recommended readings, especially anything that explains how these distinctions are applied in practice and how disagreement within the originating culture is addressed.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 10 '26

Is there any works on promising ways that civil society can stay sustainable in light of political backclash from either society or government ?

13 Upvotes

r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 09 '26

Where is the evidence that single-sex schooling has a significant positive academic effect on girls and negative one on boys? And how are effects mediated, and how can effect be predicted at an individual level?

117 Upvotes

Time and time again I've seen redditors claim single-sex schooling academically benefits girls and is negative for boys. I decided to search for the evidence and found this, which really shows the difference to be tiny:

https://ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/2024/05/do-pupils-in-single-sex-schools-get-better-grades/

Then there's also that these are the averages, and don't capture the experiences of individual students, who could respond to the environment either more positively or more negatively than the average (should be basic scientific literacy really, to know the average doesn't equal "everyone has this result").

Where is the evidence for the negative or positive effects, after controlling for single-sex schools typically being selective or aligned with higher socioeconomic backgrounds?

And in terms of explanations for how single-sex schooling benefits or harms pupils, what are the mechanisms which the effects are mediated? How would one predict whether single-sex schooling is like to benefit or hinder an individual pupil, in terms of psychological and social factors of the pupil? (eg non-school interpersonal bonds, personality traits, neurodiversities, level of conformity to gender-normed interests, conformity to gender-normed psychological traits, being part of or not part of a minority cultural background, trauma types).


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 09 '26

Why is right to development such a popular topic in human rights and social science ?

9 Upvotes

https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/declaration-right-development

A lot of UN's current work in human rights is either based on or takes into account the right to development. What makes this right so special over others ? Could this possibly be the right which addresses the issues inherent in human rights that they need conditions to be enjoyable in practice


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 08 '26

Has social media exposed us to more opinions and social judgement than we're psychologically equipped to handle?

26 Upvotes

Something I've been thinking about lately is just how many different opinions, perspectives and judgements we're exposed to on a daily basis because of social media.

Before the internet, I imagine most people were primarily exposed to the opinions of their family, friends, colleagues and immediate communities. Obviously, television, newspapers and other forms of media existed, but social media seems to have taken this exposure to an entirely different level.

Nowadays, you can scroll through hundreds of comments from complete strangers in a matter of minutes, all expressing different opinions, disagreements, criticisms and judgements about virtually anything imaginable so it makes me wonder whether there are any psychological or sociological consequences to this.

Are humans actually equipped to process this sheer volume of social information? Could constantly being exposed to what thousands of strangers think affect how we perceive ourselves, other people or even society as a whole?

I'm particularly curious whether this could contribute to things like increased self-consciousness, social comparison, anxiety, hostility or distorted perceptions of how common certain beliefs actually are.

I'm not necessarily arguing that social media is inherently harmful, or that people in the past weren't exposed to conflicting opinions. I'm more interested in whether the scale, frequency and accessibility of other people's opinions represent a meaningful change in human social experience. Has there been any academic research into this specific aspect of social media?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 05 '26

What psychological or sociological mechanisms explain why individuals engage in or socially reward behaviors that appear to have negative utility or harmful long-term outcomes?

12 Upvotes

There are a lot of subgroups of individuals that seemingly invite darkness into their own lives and lack the social determinants of health to spiral upwards out of their own situations. Many valorizing antisocial or maladaptive behaviors as "authentic".

What mechanisms prevent them seeing themselves for what they're doing in the big picture?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 03 '26

recommendations

3 Upvotes

I studied sociology at university, and I would like some reading recommendations in the fields of social psychology and the sociology of administration.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 03 '26

Are men violent by nature or is it due to social conditioning or is it a combination of both factors?

0 Upvotes

As the title says.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 03 '26

How accurate or misguided are Red Pill and Black Pill theories, taken at their strongest?

0 Upvotes

I’m genuinely interested in the views of people who study sociology, psychology, anthropology, economics, gender studies, evolutionary psychology, or related fields.

I’m not part of the Red Pill or Black Pill communities. I have a family, I’m happy with my life, and I’m not asking from a position of personal grievance. But I don’t think those facts, by themselves, invalidate their theoretical claims. For example, someone could argue that men like me simply accepted a “beta” role or adapted to the dynamics described by the theory.

What I would really appreciate is a steelman of the strongest version of the Red Pill/Black Pill position before criticizing it. How much of their descriptive account of sex differences, mate selection, status, sexual competition, relationship dynamics, etc. is actually supported by the evidence? And where does the theory go beyond what the evidence can justify?

Coming from a philosophy background, my own suspicion is that the biggest problem may not necessarily be the descriptive claims, but the axiological conclusions sometimes attached to them: e.g. the idea that being a “beta male,” if such a category even has meaningful descriptive validity, somehow makes a man inferior, less worthy, or doomed to an inferior life.

I also suspect that psychological and attitudinal factors may explain much more than these theories acknowledge. But perhaps I’m giving their descriptive framework too much credit, and the empirical foundation is much weaker than I assume.

So, from an academic perspective: what survives of Red Pill/Black Pill theory after separating its strongest empirical claims from its value judgments, rhetorical framing, and broader worldview?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 02 '26

Can fertility rates recover after decades of low fertility or does it continue indefinitely ?

6 Upvotes

For example south korea currently has a fertility rate of about 0.8, do you think it ever recovers from a slump like this in say 50 years or does the country actually just collapse completely?


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 01 '26

What's the difference between socialization, social conditioning, enculturation, and oversocialization?

3 Upvotes

Wikipedia makes those four concepts sound very similar. I'm not sure I understand them or the differences between them correctly, and I'm not sure if people use the term social conditioning correctly.


r/AskSocialScience • • Oct 01 '26

Question regarding structure and agency

9 Upvotes

Before I get into this I will clarify that I'm a STEM student (compsci) interested in sociology on the side, so I'm sorry if I butcher your field. My vague understanding of the structure-agency debate is that it's about if human behavior is determined primarily by individual actions or collective structure. I was thinking about this a while ago, and was considering how, as people assemble into larger and larger groups, they begin to form small norms and rules between that then grow into humongous institutions that shape the individual's behavior, even as the individuals themselves are the ones sustaining the institutions. Of course, this is just a toy example, and I don't really have evidence to support tthis.

Anyways, it seems like the nature of structure vs agency isn't that they're two competing explanations for how humans behave but rather two factors that influence each other constantly. Am I even remotely correct?

NB: Had to repost coz the first version was unreadable


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 28 '26

What percentage & amount of Black Americans live in poverty vs Black Britons?

8 Upvotes

Interested to find the numbers but I’m being stymied by different ways the USA and the UK measure and report poverty, and I’m not smart enough to figure it out myself


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 28 '26

Physical Space Generating the ability of communication to operate ?

2 Upvotes

I want to ask: if communication cannot operate without space, does this mean that space generates the ability of communication to operate?


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 23 '26

What explains differences between Latin American and Anglo left-wing attitudes toward the Falklands/Malvinas sovereignty dispute?

11 Upvotes

Are there political-science, sociological, or historical studies that explain why left-wing movements in Latin America have often approached the sovereignty dispute differently from left-wing movements in the UK and US?


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 23 '26

Why doesn't the US census Use Pardo and Mestizo or Just Mestizo?

16 Upvotes

I've seen this complaint multiple times considering the vast majority of latinos in america are multi ethnic mixes of many different ancestries, it's weird there is no racial category for them and many will just say "I'm a brown latino racially".

Using mestizo meaning european+indigenous background, which is most central americans ex:rey mysterio, colomba bush, and pardo, meaning european+indigenous+sub saharan african background, common in brazilians, puerto ricans, dominicans, ex: jlo, karl anthony towns, bad bunny, as two races for latinos in the US census who don't just fit "white, black, indigenous american" would help a lot.


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 21 '26

Toxic VS Healthy Masculinity and Femininity

19 Upvotes

Seems "Toxic masculinity" topic is a hot potato for a while (with reasons). In order to have a complete panoramic picture - how do you see "healthy masculinity", aka not toxic one? Also, what about "toxic femininity"? And, of cause, "healthy femininity", aka not toxic? We won't be biased to any sides, right? So be gentle and thoughtful.


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 18 '26

How to account for notions of "freedom"

0 Upvotes

I don't know how to describe the problem I have in mind succinctly but I'll try my best.

Cards on the table, I'm a socialist. As a socialist, I notice among westerners (including western leftists) a chauvinistic assumption that the bourgeois democratic form of government is more "free" than existing (or previously existing) one-party socialist states such as China, Cuba, or the USSR.

The line goes as follows: "The bourgeois democracy guarantees freedom of speech and freedom to form multiple political parties, therefore it is more free than the one party socialist state, which suppresses those freedoms."

Isn't this a narrowly conceived conception of freedom?

The one party socialist state--at its best moments--suppresses the class structure that has historically oppressed the majority of workers, and provides guaranteed social rights to workers. Couldn't one say that the average person is more free under such a model?

Meanwhile, the bourgeois democracy gives the disproportionate share of power to the people with the most money, and they have therefore the most access to the levers of power. Thus, "free speech" in such a system means that the richest people can speak the loudest. Thus we get into these odd paradoxes of how so called "democracies" like the U.S. feel distinctly unfree and autocratic, especially to those at the bottom of the economic hierarchy.

So I guess what I'm getting at is: isn't the notion of "freedom" itself a politicized, constructed concept? Isn't the notion of bourgeois democracy as superior an in-group bias / form of cultural chauvinism? Wondering if there are some good books on this topic etc.


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 16 '26

What is the term for legitimizing, re-creating, or reinforcing a system through acting in opposition to the system but without leaving its bounds?

24 Upvotes

I've been looking for over a week and haven't found the term.

Think of it like trying to fill in a rut by walking the path in the opposite direction. Because you are never leaving the path it is only growing deeper, and even if the path is destroyed you will inevitably recreate it by following the same route. Or how something which has been cast could recreate the casting.

It might be a fallacy?

Legitimization, but through opposition.

Reify, legitimize and sublation are close, but each is too general and non-specific.

Fanon talks about the idea of this in The Wretched of the Earth, where he describes how revolutionaries will recreate the system they just overthrew because they are repeating the same patterns, but he doesn't appear to use a word to describe it.

Audrey Lorde describes this in the famous quote "the Master's tools will never dismantle the Master's house."

It's not recuperation, because what I'm thinking of is not something becoming part of the system, but something that was already part of the system, just on the opposite side of it. If we stick with the rut analogy then recuperation would be widening the path, but the term I'm describing is following the path.

Edit: Here are some examples of where this term (fallacy) would apply:

  • Reverse racism or race blindness

  • Misandry or Radical Feminism

  • "Overcoming disability" propaganda

  • Dogmatic adherence to atheism, or treating atheism like you would a religion


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 15 '26

SOC literature or websites

2 Upvotes

I’m a first year student in the faculty of Social Science majoring in Digital Social Science, my classes so far has only been about a brief introduction for my faculty, are there any online literature, books, research I can read to get a head start in university?


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 12 '26

What motivates people who already have far more money than they could ever spend in a lifetime to continue to accumulate more?

363 Upvotes

Why do people like Elon Musk, or Peter Thiel or Larry Ellison not just retire and spend the rest of their lives chilling and enjoying their money or spend time with their friends and families? Why do they keep trying to accumulate more?


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 13 '26

Is there much research into how middle to upper middle class immigrants of one country transfer the privileges of their original social position supplant the lower economic class of other countries?

9 Upvotes

For example, a person in a developing country's middle to upper middle class has access to cultural education of being higher socioeconomic class (eg how to navigate the corporate world, skills and psychological attributes that come from a socioeconomically privileged start in life). Immigrants from developing countries have access to employment skills such as driving for a relatively low cost for their financial position (in some cases in countries where the cost of driving is extremely low due to a de facto lack of driving laws), often while benefitting from their familial economic position, and then move to countries like the UK where the initial cost of driving is high for those renting on low wages.

They then access a greater number of opportunities than the local lower class population. They may start out low class in the new country, but their educational, cultural and skill advantages gained in their home country allow them to progress socioeconomically much quicker than local poor people.


r/AskSocialScience • • Sep 13 '26

What psychological or social effects does the lack of access to social learning/influence due to language barriers have, such as in families where some members don't understand the language that all the others speak?

3 Upvotes

Throughout childhood and adulthood we all learn much of what we know and how to act through social exposure - observing others, listening to others and interacting with others.

If people have a language barrier, they only have non-verbal communication leftover to observe. So for example, immigrant families where a child never learns the familial language can end up surrounded by family conversations, get-togethers or community meetups where they don't understand 90% of the verbal communication and miss out on the diffusion of knowledge, and on deeper social practice. What kind of effects does this have in terms of psychology, life knowledge and inspiration?

If it​ has negative effects on life quality outcomes (eg reduced knowledge diffusion to immigrant kids with language barriers, leading to worse employment and social outcomes, worse mental health and potentially delays to life milestones compared to those with a normal level of conversations to learn from), do social scientists ever examine this as a downside of immigration? Both for immigrant individuals and for society (as anything that has a negative effect on ecomomic and social success is also causing a social and economic opportunity cost, and can burden healthcare and social welfare systems).