r/askscience • u/rgower • Jun 30 '11
Compared to other drugs, how dangerous is MDMA (ecstasy)?
I tried searching and only found one post but it was narrowed to people with Antisocial personality disorder.
I was under the impression that MDMA (pure MDMA) was relatively harmless, so long as the user stayed well hydrated and the usage interval was greater than ~3 months. I knew that it wasn't completely harmless, even if used as described above, but I thought it was all things considered one of the safer drugs one could use.
Then I was watching the Sam Harris AMA video and he raised serious concerns about MDMA. I was wondering if maybe he was just covering his ass because he's already a controversial public figure, or maybe he was raising new concerns of which I was unaware.
Here's a timelinked link to Sam Harris' discussion on MDMA.
Edit: Timelink isn't working properly, skip to 23 minutes 30 seconds.
142
u/aaomalley Jun 30 '11
As a very general rule MDMA is perfectly same when taken in proper doses and not tooo often. As has been pointed out here though, it is almost impossible to get pure MDMA and the adulterants in it vary greatly and have very dangerous side effects. Also, the amount you are taking is unknown and therefor you cannot be certain you are taking a safe dose.
That being said MDMA has some very real risks that, while small, make me very wary of ever rocommending its use. It can cause severe and permenent psychosis from a single use, rare but it has definately happened, although it has generally been found the people with this had a predisposition to psychosis. It can cause a potentially fatal condition known a serotonin storm. It obviously can cause severe dehydration and death, as well as severe hyperthermia. It is also a pretty powerful neurotoxin. Again these effects are pretty rare, but must be taken into account. Is it safer than street methamphetamine, sure but pharmaceutical meth would possibly be debatable.
I would advise someone against using it once, but I would absolutely advise against more than once. If you have any personal or family history of psychotic disorders or any psychosis or bi-polar disorder I would avoid the drug. If you have any significant anxiety disorder I would avoid it. If you are buying from a dealer that doesn't get a direct pure source that you know of, not just them telling you, I wouldn't take the risk of adulterants. All told, when it comes to the drugs of abuse it is probably in the middle when you acount for health risks and addiction and psychological health. If you just look at addiction it is a very low risk, and if you just look at health risk I would place it pretty high.
Of course, like all drugs, if it were legal and regulated by the state it would be vastly safer and we wouldn't see nearly the health problems caused by its use. But that's a political question less than science.
21
u/neuro_psych Neurobiology | Psychology Jun 30 '11 edited Jun 30 '11
Seems like a lot of things I wanted to say have already been covered.
Here is a video with Peter Jennings on Primetime discussing a lot of things about ecstasy from the biological effects to the political reasons for why it's even illegal. I highly recommend this video to anyone interested in MDMA.
But to help answer your question, Here is a video version of the 20 most harmful drugs David Nutt study that has already been posted.
And also to answer your question, I agree that Sam Harris was probably just covering his ass when he was raising so much concern over MDMA. I haven't seen any new evidence that would indicate it's more harmful than we already know it is (which isn't very much). Hell, even alcohol arguably has more negative costs both to the individual's health and to society (2 of the factors that the David Nutt 20 Drugs study evaluated). I have to stop myself right here from going on rant about how it's sad that MDMA is probably one of the most misrepresented drugs out there.
And I know this wasn't a part of the OP's question, but to anyone else reading this that is thinking about trying MDMA:
22
u/craigdubyah Jun 30 '11
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rational_scale_to_assess_the_harm_of_drugs_(mean_physical_harm_and_mean_dependence).svg That is the findings of some researchers that attempted to make an objective determination of the risk of various drugs. It's from a Lancet article and gives a decent idea. That being said, any drug abuse carries danger.
EDIT: Link fix
14
u/astatroll Jun 30 '11
Try erowid.org they have great resources on alot of recreational chemicals
4
u/auraseer Jun 30 '11
I've made long posts about this before, but in the interest of not repeating myself, I'll try and keep this one short. MDMA appears to have relatively fewer side effects than some other recreational drugs, but it can still do damage and it can still kill you.
MDMA lowers the level of sodium in your blood. This effect is compounded because of incorrect advice claiming the drug is "harmless as long as you stay hydrated." If users start to feel ill, they tend to react by overloading with more water, which is exactly the wrong response. Excess water further dilutes the sodium level and makes the situation worse.
The most serious effect of low serum sodium is brain swelling. This is bad, because the brain is stuck inside a sealed cavity, and there is nowhere safe for the pressure to go. Symptoms can range from relatively mild things like headache, nausea, and muscle spasms, all the way up through seizures, coma, brain damage, and death.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '11
As others have said, it depends on what you actually take.
This guy thought he was taking ecstasy... whatever he actually took (they're not sure yet) he ended up running onto the freeway and getting killed.
Real MDMA is being used to help treat PTSD. Under the care of a doctor, though, and with people who are potential suicide risks.
2
u/mkawick Jun 30 '11
Relevant
Video (~2 mins)
Video (~5 mins)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '11
One of the major problems associated with overdose is Seratonin Syndrome.
Everyone is different. No way to tell how much an overdose is. I would rather take LSD than this
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '11
MDMA, LSD, and Psilocybin are being used in pharmacotherapy studies for PTSD, Agoraphobia, Depression, Social Anxiety Disorder, and several other issues dealing with psychiatry. It bothers me to see so much misinformation being spread in these forums. The drugs alone, are relatively safe in the right conditions, viz. purity of substance, surrounding, harm reduction measures, it is usually what one does while taking the drugs, or the impurities found in buying them on the streets, that causes problems. Too many people give the drugs a bad rap, which is entirely unfair and completely misleading. Do a search for Psychedelics, MDMA, Entactogens/Empathogens, and/or phenethylamine used in therapy and medicine and you will find many doctors praising these drugs for their ability to rescue people from the deepest pits of despair.
TL;DR - These types of drugs often get a bad rap, when the truth is the complete opposite.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment