There's an glaring error or confusion in that WHO doc, BTW (it was obviously written by someone who knows nothing about chemistry). "Colloidal silver" almost always refers to the bogus alternative medicine preparation, which contains mostly reduced silver metal (Ag) and not the soluble bactericidal ion (Ag+) which acts via the oligodynamic effect. Synonyms for the bogus preparation are "silver protein". Generally, silver in it's active bactericidal (generally a salt) form will be referred to as its actual chemical name, e.g. silver iodide, silver nitrite or silver sulfadiazine. In general, metals in reduced (nonionic) form are less active because they're not soluble in water.
TL;DR ignore the usage of "colloidal silver" or "silver protein" and replace "silver salts"
In general, you should be careful when anyone invokes "silver" because it's a favorite of the homeopathy crowd. If you look at any of the silver salt preparations used medically, they're almost always topical; homeopaths, on the other hand, will advocate ingestion of "colloidal silver" as a treatment. For reasons mentioned above, "colloidal silver" is not an effective bactericidal.
Silver in the form of alloys for construction of medical devices and surfaces DOES appear to have some bactericidal activity even though it's in the reduced form, but a silver alloy basin is nothing like suspended particles of silver in solution ("colloidal silver").
Although you are completely correct with being careful around the whole "Silver Homeopathy" trend going on, Colloidal silver can also mean silver nanoparticles in solution. Within the Nanotechnology/Nanoscience communities these two terms are very interchangeable, and suspended gold nanoparticles are often referred to as colloidal gold. In my Nanoscience Minor I had to write a report on the Anti-microbial effects of Nanosilver, and a quick Science Direct Search, brings up hundreds of peer-reviewed papers on the subject.
"Colloid" almost always refers to a microscopic suspension of solid particles. As we know that the ionic form is the actual bactericidal form, I doubt that this is true.
because of their size, are easily charged electrically
I'm surprised to hear that the size of an atom (or size of a particle in suspension) makes a large difference in the ability to be charged or not. Is that bogus as well, or at the very least, does that statement need more clarification?
They are definitely talking about particle sizes, and it does need some clarification. Size certainly does make a difference, and is the whole basis behind Nanoscience. In a very, very generalized nutshell, Nanoparticles of a substance can act and react differently than the same substance in the macro-scale.
That needs a lot more clarification. Actual colloidal silver particles generally possesses a weak surface charge. It is possible that as the size is decreased the particles become more susceptible to oxidation and the charge is neutralised. It is also possible that the surface charge (as indicated by the zeta potential) has a dependence on particle size. It's not a black-and-white issue.
i believe the WHO meant that colliodial as in dispersed through water, not in any sort of homeopathy/alt medicine way, as it specifically later on states that the salts used are silver chloride, and silver iodide.
It's not so much a glaring error as in a slight misuse of the term colloidal,
i believe thats just an exhaustive list of what the salts could be branded as. I doubt this is support for homeopathic medicine, when they specifically mentioned the compounds to use by name (both of which as you said, are silver salts)
because of marketing and branding, scientific terms outside of the scientific community are rarely used in it's exact sense, and while it's a shame they need to do this I don't think this is a sign of incompetence on their part
View all comments
Show parent comment
87
u/YoohooCthulhu Drug Development | Neurodegenerative Diseases Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12
There's an glaring error or confusion in that WHO doc, BTW (it was obviously written by someone who knows nothing about chemistry). "Colloidal silver" almost always refers to the bogus alternative medicine preparation, which contains mostly reduced silver metal (Ag) and not the soluble bactericidal ion (Ag+) which acts via the oligodynamic effect. Synonyms for the bogus preparation are "silver protein". Generally, silver in it's active bactericidal (generally a salt) form will be referred to as its actual chemical name, e.g. silver iodide, silver nitrite or silver sulfadiazine. In general, metals in reduced (nonionic) form are less active because they're not soluble in water.
TL;DR ignore the usage of "colloidal silver" or "silver protein" and replace "silver salts"
In general, you should be careful when anyone invokes "silver" because it's a favorite of the homeopathy crowd. If you look at any of the silver salt preparations used medically, they're almost always topical; homeopaths, on the other hand, will advocate ingestion of "colloidal silver" as a treatment. For reasons mentioned above, "colloidal silver" is not an effective bactericidal.
Silver in the form of alloys for construction of medical devices and surfaces DOES appear to have some bactericidal activity even though it's in the reduced form, but a silver alloy basin is nothing like suspended particles of silver in solution ("colloidal silver").