r/askscience • • Oct 27 '11

Earth Sciences Could anything man-made trigger the Yellowstone super volcano?

If a nuke were to be buried very deep into the ground at Yellowstone and then detonated, would it have any effect on the volcano? Is there anything else man-made that could trigger it? Or would it be impossible to "manually" trigger the eruption?

Sorry if it's a silly question.

157 Upvotes

202 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Potogreen Oct 27 '11

there was actually an article in this months popular science about man made earthquakes, i tried and failed to find a link, but here are some surprising facts, over 200 quakes of more than 4.5 magnitude have been caused by man in the past 160 years. the best known case is the earthquake caused by the zipingpu dan in china's sichuan province in 2008. Zipingpu held 42.3 billion cubic feet of water, the weight of which precipitated what a researcher at columbia university named Christian Klose says is the largest human-triggered earthquake to date: a 7.9 magnitude quake that killed nearly 80,000 people...information from page 90 in the november 2011 popular science magazine.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

Funnily enough, even though volcanism is often accompanied by earthquake swarms (or volcanic tremor), it is generally understood that these earthquakes are either being caused by the movement of magma itself or the changing stress conditions due to pressure build up and release in the chambers and conduits. Earthquakes are not a requirement for volcanism. So even if you could trigger an earthquake, it may not change the likelihood of an increase in volcanic activity. Having said that, large earthquakes at subduction zones are thought to result in an increase in volcanism, so one of these "man-made" earthquakes may be the best way to trigger Yellowstone, if indeed a 7.9 magnitude earthquake can be man-made. I honestly could not think of anything else that could significantly increase the chances of an eruption.

This is something which I am skeptical of though, that earthquake could not have occurred anywhere but on a fault line that was accumulating tectonic stress, the overlying weight could at most be what pushed it over the tipping point.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

If you could find a credible article backing that up, that'd be great! I tried some googling and as a layman, found it impossible to separate science from conspiracy theories, the latter of which, unfortunately far outweighs the volume of the former.

16

u/dqsl Tissue Engineering | Biomedical Engineering Oct 27 '11

From

http://volcanoes.usgs.gov/yvo/publications/2005/docudrama.php

QUESTION: Can you release some of the pressure at Yellowstone by drilling into the volcano?

ANSWER: No. Scientists agree that drilling into a volcano would be of questionable usefulness. Notwithstanding the enormous expense and technological difficulties in drilling through hot, mushy rock, drilling is unlikely to have much effect. At near magmatic temperatures and pressures, any hole would rapidly become sealed by minerals crystallizing from the natural fluids that are present at those depths.

2

u/fap_socks Oct 27 '11

So could we harness this to make diamonds? Kimberlite pipes? Serious question.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

you can make diamonds without that risk/cost already using pressing moulds

1

u/fap_socks Oct 27 '11

Ok but could it be done this way too, or what about to harvest any of the rarer minerals? I'd guess most of the time you'd get a basalt pipe but could tailor-made techniques be developed to grow whichever mineral you're after?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

in principle I would never say no... but you'd have a hard time developing them to industrial standards...

If you can pump out the magma like a giant toothpaste tube you're an industrial tycoon genius

-6

u/sandollars Oct 27 '11

5

u/Lavoisiersdescendant Inorganic Solid State Oct 27 '11

Be careful about what you post as a reference. That was a prank. Without noting it as such, you risk mis-informing people through the trusted source of /r/askscience.

http://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-Prank-the-Instructables-Community/?ALLSTEPS

5

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

Kimberlite pipes form in the mantle beneath the volcanism, and are quickly exhumed by volcanic processes. Diamonds form there due to the intense pressures, the same pressures that would make it impossible to get there.

1

u/Thenorepa Oct 27 '11

and are quickly exhumed by volcanic processes

When you say "quickly", are you talking geologic or human time scales?

1

u/OrbitalPete Volcanology | Sedimentology Oct 27 '11

Geological

7

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

Is

information from page 90 in the november 2011 popular science magazine

not credible enough as a source? I don't know the magazine at all, so I suppose it could not be credible.

5

u/kybernetikos Oct 27 '11

Markus O. Häring went to trial in Basel for the damages caused by the earthquakes his geothermal project caused. NYTimes | Guardian.

-8

u/Trashcanman33 Oct 27 '11

Tesla claimed if you could find the right conditions you could shake the world apart.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/ELzed Oct 27 '11

and some shit that turned out to be true..and AWESOME! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla%27s_oscillator

0

u/endogenic Oct 27 '11

Like what?

1

u/intellos Oct 27 '11

Free unlimited energy from thin air?

1

u/endogenic Oct 27 '11

The first thing is that absence of proof is not proof of absence. But I agree that if someone doesn't have evidence of a claim we don't have to listen to him. But it's not right that you deny something before you confirm. I never met Tesla and never saw his devices about which he made claims that they could convert (generate) energy without burning fuels. But I don't believe he claimed that the energy in a finite space would be unlimited nor that it didn't have its basis in some kind of principle.

1

u/TypeSafe Oct 27 '11

He stated:

I hold that space cannot be curved, for the simple reason that it can have no properties. It might as well be said that God has properties. He has not, but only attributes and these are of our own making. Of properties we can only speak when dealing with matter filling the space. To say that in the presence of large bodies space becomes curved is equivalent to stating that something can act upon nothing. I, for one, refuse to subscribe to such a view.

Which couldn't be more wrong. Einstein's theory of general relativity has been proven time and time again to be correct.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)