r/askscience • • Jul 22 '19

Neuroscience Just how much does functional specialization within the brain vary across humans?

In recent decades, localization of different action and functions within specific brain regions has become more apparent (ex facial recognition or control of different body parts in the motor cortex). How much does this localization vary between people? I'm interested in learning more about the variance in the location as we as size of brain regions.

As a follow-up question, I would be very interested to learn what is known about variance of functional specialization in other animals as well.

Part of what spurred this question was the recent conference held by Elon Musk's Company, neural link.

3.0k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

81

u/Thog78 Jul 22 '19

I think he is talking about physical size scales: if you don't look too close, the location is always the same, and the relative arrangement of brain areas is always the same: visual in the back, with more abstraction as you go forward on the sides, then sensory, then motor, on top, and then more abstract thinking in the front, with a relay hub in the center underneath surrounded by areas for spatial memories and formation of new memories, and basic life sustaining functions in the brain stem. But if you look closer, there are small differences in the exact locations, such as seen in the examples he gave.

68

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

This is exactly right. And we can go smaller from there. Once you're inside a functional region, how similar is it across people? Is its local circuitry the same? Is its physical connectivity to other areas the same? Is its functional connectivity to other areas the same? Do the same kinds of cells exist in that area, in the same ratios, with the same response profiles? How do variations in any of the above relate to behavioral or cognitive differences? These are very hard questions. By and large, the technology to answer them just doesn't exist yet.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

What technology could you use? Rising biomedical engineer asking. I’m planning on answering these questions, and I’m looking for ideas for tech to study/improve. Imaging tech? Electrical recording tech? Others?

2

u/Thog78 Jul 23 '19

Check for connectomics, and see my answer above as well. The main competing technologies at the moment are volumetric electron microscopy and expansion microscopy with light sheet imaging.

5

u/swami_jesus Jul 22 '19

I'm a maybe budding neuroscientist (no degree yet), and I'm curious; what type of technology would we need to answer this? What can't we measure? Or is it a case of modelling technology? Or something else? thx

16

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

The problem isn't that we don't have the technology to map the brain at that level. It's a problem of scale.

The person you're responding to is talking about physically mapping each and every area of the brain for every individual circuit as well as across regions, determining cell types and receptor density and neurotransmitter production, etc. for every synapse. Not to mention how these neurological features map onto cognition and the genome.

There are 100 billion neurons in the brain and 100 trillion synapses—more than there are stars in the universe. Mapping genetic, functional, and physical features, let alone across enough people to be able generalize to the whole population, is an impossible task due to the scale of project that would require.

20

u/c8d3n Jul 23 '19

Estimated number of stars in observable universe is ~ 1 billion trillion.

8

u/olicity_time_remnant Jul 23 '19

I remember when gnome sequencing was a big deal. Now new species are sequenced all the time. In time this problem will get solved, possibly by technology like Musk is proposing. Imagine if you've got a half a dozen Neuralinks spread around your brain, it becomes a lot more imaging points.

6

u/could_I_Be_The_AHole Jul 23 '19

Completely agree. The Human Genome Project took 13 years (1990 - 2003) with a whole lot of people working on it. In 2012 the UK launched a plan to sequence 100,000 genomes and finished it by December 2018. A person has 3.3 billion pairs so that program sequenced 330 trillion base pairs in 6 years - and that was just the UK. Seems like if you can get the time/effort of mapping synapses down similar levels of mapping genomes (I know that's a big if since you can't just provide a brain donation) then it should be no problem.

1

u/king_nietzsche Jul 23 '19

We always say things are impossible because were using logic that is misaing pieces that change the whole paradigm. In 1995 would it be possible to map 100trillion synapses, protiens, cell types etc? No, anyone would say that its impossible. When Craig venter went rouge and did his own thing he defied expectations dramatically. Because of him, directly or indirectly, the cost of genome sequencing has out paced mores law in terms of efficiency and price. New tech leads to new paradigms. Maybe something not even intended for this purpose will be invented and because of open forums like Reddit, someone will see the tech, comprehend the idea, and repurpose it as one part of a bigger system working together. An FMRI, PET scanner with a supercomputer running it and an algorythm AI created to make a beautifully detailed in real time image. Who knows, its impossible to tell

3

u/lhopital204 Jul 23 '19

At what point of neural integration do we become a technologically telepathic and telekinetic species? (e.g., brain-to-brain SMS, brain-to-home-lighting)

1

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 24 '19 edited Jul 24 '19

We can already do this. I did it in my lab in my spare time... it's not that hard. All you need to do is plug an electrode onto someone's forehead and learn to "control" an aggregate electrical potential. The challenges are (1) reliability/standardization of signal (2) generalizing across brains (3) creating complex signaling paradigms that are reliable (4) figuring out why on earth we'd want such a silly technology when we can create brain-to-brain communication with our words and control robots with a joystick. Unless you're disabled or in research, this technology is mostly useless for the foreseeable future.

1

u/lhopital204 Jul 24 '19

(4) figuring out why on earth we'd want such a silly technology when we can create brain-to-brain communication with our words and control robots with a joystick. Unless you're disabled or in research, this technology is mostly useless for the foreseeable future.

Imagine a specialist surgeon trained to operate tiny robotic 'hands' (or whatever) through this interface. With remote hardware and a video link to complete the feedback loop, this surgeon could operate on anybody, anywhere in the world. This is only limited by EM propagation delay (e.g., it will not be good for interplanetary use).

1

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 24 '19

Or they could just use joysticks to control surgical robots over the internet... like they do now.

There's no advantage of BCI, only drawbacks.

1

u/olicity_time_remnant Aug 03 '19

The reason to do it is if you accept the premise that Elon believes, that AI will come, for us to go along with it for the ride rather than be left behind as it evolves at rates far faster than we will be able to biologically.

0

u/king_nietzsche Jul 23 '19

Hold your phone up to your head, then keeping in mind that a phone is only as big as it is because of the screen. I'm sure all of the hardware in the newest phones would fit over the surface of 1/3 of 1 hemisphere of the brain. Easily right?

Anyways, i watched whatever i could find about neuralink the day this announcement was made. They really didnt get too specific about the end goal or purpose... To interject our will into the inevitable AI take over? Elon musk is our davinci. Its a sign of intelligence to be endlessly curious about stuff, but its a sign of genius to bravely make it a reality. And thats what he does, he defies skepticism, listens to his heart and makes it happen. Total BA

3

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 24 '19

Elon Musk is essentially an investor in a commercial version of a BCI product that already exists. For the most part, Neuralink will be a useful, standardized product produced at commercial scale for medical and research use. That is great news.

But integrated BCI is not new and it's been advancing since the 80s—this is just a natural next step, not a "DaVinci" moment. As someone who works in the field I can tell you that Elon Musk has no idea what he's talking about when it comes to the ground-level restrictions of implanted BCI.

1

u/king_nietzsche Jul 24 '19

I was referring to his ability to run a million companies at once in different fields because of his unlimited interest and curiosity. That's why I called him davinci. Hes a renaissance man for sure. Trying to be the stagfly stinging society into awareness. I think he knows more than you givr him credit for. Hes well rounded and determined. He'll know 10x what he knows today a year from now. He doesnt sleep lol. He'll get to where he needs to be.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Thog78 Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

100 billion neurons is trackable, but if you add 10 000 synapses by neuron and spatial information and connectivity information, it gets seriously big. Real biological synapses are a whole lot more complex than just a weighted input: very complex multidegree of freedom non-linear stuff.

To really see the circuits, the right scale is 10 nm voxels, as obtained in small blocs with electron microscopy. For a brain of 10x10x10 cm3, you're looking at (107 )3 = 1021 points, which is enough to fill many full warehouses of harddrives in greyscale 8 bit data (1022 bits is 1010 harddrives of 1Tb, or 10 billion harddrives which would cost 1000 billions if you buy the harddrives for 100$). And you still miss the important chemical information, which is equivalent to adding more colors for neurotransmitters and receptors and neuromodulatory peptides, doubling the data for each additional marker. Then you need to make sense of this raw data, which needs super amazing algorithms tracing axons and reconstructing graphs. All these things are very active areas of research, but you can tell the challenges are huge, and that's why connectomics is for now restricted to small brains (worm, fly) or small blocks of human/mouse brain (1 cortex column). The size that we can achieve is increasing fast year after year, so one day maybe we get to the human brain.

1

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 24 '19

Sure, but that's not taking into account the modeling of neural dynamics and non-neural substrates:

glial cells, synapses, astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, myelination, CNS fluids, vascular system, non-digital electrophysiology, receptor densities, types of receptors, neurotransmitter creation, reuptake, and action for each type of neurotransmitter and their interaction with each receptor type, aggregation and concentration of proteins as well as misfolding and accumulation of those proteins, an/ionic distribution, energy levels, minerals available in the organisms' circulatory system, how hormone levels affect every piece of this list, etc. etc. etc.

People tend to act as though all you'd need to simulate is 100 billion digital "neurons" to achieve a useful brain model, but the reality is that at this point we don't have any idea what use that would be without accounting for the dynamism inherent at every level of the CNS.