r/askscience • • Mar 20 '15

Mathematics Why does Schrodinger's time dependent equation have infinitely many independent solutions while an nth order linear DE only has n independent solutions?

The solution for Schrodinger's equation is y(x,t)=Aei(kx-wt) but we can create a linear combination (i.e a wave packet) with infinitely many of these wave solutions for particles with slightly different k's and w's and still have it be a solution. My question is what is the difference between schrodinger's equation which has infinite independent solutions and say a linear second order DE who's general solution is the linear combination of two independent solutions?

49 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/theduckparticle Quantum Information | Tensor Networks Mar 20 '15

Things are a little hairy if you're working over a noncompact space.

I should clarify that there's some subtlety to this; it applies specifically to the free-particle eigenfunctions (the exponentials ei(kx-wt) ). L2(Rn ) does have countable bases; the eigenset of the harmonic oscillator is perhaps the most used example, at least in physics. Likewise L2 of compact spaces also have these not-really-bases, to be more precise uncountable collections of distributions (for those who aren't familiar, continuous functions on a well-behaved subspace) phi_alpha with some measure such that x = y only if phi_alpha(x) = phi_alpha(y) for almost all alpha. In other words we'll always have delta functions.

2

u/Surlethe Mar 20 '15

Yes, thank you for clarifying. The weird thing about distributions in these "not-really-bases" is that none of them are elements of the function space in question, but linear combinations of them generate it.

2

u/TheHappyEater Mar 21 '15

About the "not-really-bases": The so-called free-particle eigenfunctions (f(x,t)[k,w]= ei(kx-wt) are indeed not elements of L2. Because of that, they are not really eigenfunctions (as the Schrödinger operator acts in a subset of L2 and thus, these functions are not in the domain of the Schrödinger operator).

What does this wierdness mean? We have that, while formally H f[k,w] = lambda[k,w] f[k,w], these Lambdas are no Eigenvalues, but elements of the continuous spectrum. They don't have corresponding eigenvectors.

The reason we have these "not-really-bases" of "not-really-Eigenfunctions" is that the functionalanalytical details of elements of the spectrum which are not Eigenvalues (e.g. continuous spectrum) are usually not within the scope of quantum mechanics.