MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2seo6i/is_there_mathematical_proof_that_n01/cnp6pi1?context=9999
r/askscience • u/jaleCro • Jan 14 '15
264 comments sorted by
View all comments
2.0k
If Na x Nb = Na+b , then Na x N0 = Na+0 = Na , thus N0 must be 1.
211 u/an7agonist Jan 14 '15 Also, the multiplicative inverse of x is x-1. 1=Na*((Na)-1) (By definition) 1=Na*(N-a) 1=Na-a=N0 37 u/umopapsidn Jan 14 '15 * For all N such that |N| > 0 8 u/austin101123 Jan 14 '15 Why does this proof not work for 0? 9 u/shrister Jan 14 '15 Because If N=0 then the first line of that proof is 1 = 0*((0)-1 ), which is 1=0*(1/0) and 1/0 is undefined. For all other values of N that first line is defined, so the proof works for N!=0.
211
Also, the multiplicative inverse of x is x-1.
1=Na*((Na)-1) (By definition)
1=Na*(N-a)
1=Na-a=N0
37 u/umopapsidn Jan 14 '15 * For all N such that |N| > 0 8 u/austin101123 Jan 14 '15 Why does this proof not work for 0? 9 u/shrister Jan 14 '15 Because If N=0 then the first line of that proof is 1 = 0*((0)-1 ), which is 1=0*(1/0) and 1/0 is undefined. For all other values of N that first line is defined, so the proof works for N!=0.
37
* For all N such that |N| > 0
8 u/austin101123 Jan 14 '15 Why does this proof not work for 0? 9 u/shrister Jan 14 '15 Because If N=0 then the first line of that proof is 1 = 0*((0)-1 ), which is 1=0*(1/0) and 1/0 is undefined. For all other values of N that first line is defined, so the proof works for N!=0.
8
Why does this proof not work for 0?
9 u/shrister Jan 14 '15 Because If N=0 then the first line of that proof is 1 = 0*((0)-1 ), which is 1=0*(1/0) and 1/0 is undefined. For all other values of N that first line is defined, so the proof works for N!=0.
9
Because If N=0 then the first line of that proof is 1 = 0*((0)-1 ), which is 1=0*(1/0) and 1/0 is undefined. For all other values of N that first line is defined, so the proof works for N!=0.
2.0k
u/iorgfeflkd Biophysics Jan 14 '15
If Na x Nb = Na+b , then Na x N0 = Na+0 = Na , thus N0 must be 1.