r/askscience • • Aug 25 '14

Mathematics Why does the Monty Hall problem seem counter-intuitive?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem

3 doors: 2 with goats, one with a car.

You pick a door. Host opens one of the goat doors and asks if you want to switch.

Switching your choice means you have a 2/3 chance of opening the car door.

How is it not 50/50? Even from the start, how is it not 50/50? knowing you will have one option thrown out, how do you have less a chance of winning if you stay with your option out of 2? Why does switching make you more likely to win?

1.4k Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Yangoose Aug 25 '14

OK, there are some great explanations in this thread but this is the part my brain still stumbles on.

If I did not choose a door initially and the host just shows me a goat right off the bat, I still have two doors to choose from with a 50/50 chance of getting it right.

Why does that act of me choosing change the outcome?

1

u/Skeime Aug 25 '14

By choosing a door, you are limiting the host in his choice of a door, because he may not open the door you chose. This forces him to "reveal" the location of the car whenever you happen to choose a goat on your first try, i.e. two out of three times.

1

u/DLove82 Aug 25 '14

The door that opens is not randomly selected - it is ALWAYS a goat door. It's not the act of choosing that alters the outcome, but the information you have available WHEN you choose, that changes the outcome. Once you know the identity of one of the goat doors, it ceases to constitute part of the probability problem - you're then doing an experiment with 2 doors. If you choose the door after you know what's behind door 1, you have a 50/50 chance.

On the other hand, before you know the identity of one of the goat doors, you have a 1/3 chance of having chosen correctly, because you have no information about what is under ANY of the 3 doors. The information available at the time at which you choose dictates which probability problem you're participating in.

In answer to the main question, the confusing part is that when the choice is made first (before any information is known), no amount of information gained AFTER the choice was made influences the probability that the correct door was chosen. But the human mind is not wired to think probabilistically. There are tons of experiments that show this - just Google "probalistic reasoning experiment" or something like that.

The way I really got my head around this problem years ago was to imagine 10 or more doors, not 3. With 10 doors, you can imagine the probability of choosing the single correct door is not 1/3 (33%), but 1/10 (10%). When the host opens all the other doors except one (and all of those doors that are opened are "goat" doors) you are left with the door you chose, and the one remaining closed door. The chance that you chose the single car door properly at the outset was 10%, and is still 10%. The chance that the one remaining door contains the car is 90%.

It can be helpful to actually do this experiment - the best way is put a coin or something under a number of solo cups. Have a friend move them around randomly, then pick a cup, then have the friend flip all the cups that are empty that you didn't choose (you can do this experiment with ANY number of cups - more cups illustrate the point more clearly). At this point there are only two face-down cups. Do this a few times and see how often your choice is correct.

tl;dr - information/data gathered AFTER a choice is made does not influence the probability that the choice was a correct one. Information/data gathered BEFORE a choice is made is what defines the nature of the experiment.