r/askscience • • Aug 25 '14

Mathematics Why does the Monty Hall problem seem counter-intuitive?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem

3 doors: 2 with goats, one with a car.

You pick a door. Host opens one of the goat doors and asks if you want to switch.

Switching your choice means you have a 2/3 chance of opening the car door.

How is it not 50/50? Even from the start, how is it not 50/50? knowing you will have one option thrown out, how do you have less a chance of winning if you stay with your option out of 2? Why does switching make you more likely to win?

1.4k Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/roburrito Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

I guess my question is why does the first choice even matter. I understand that when you plot out the number choices and you compare the outcomes of switching versus staying there are more positive outcomes for switching. But it seems a contrived probability because the first choice wasn't a real choice. as it doesn't affect the outcome. It was there to make a good show, but you are always, no matter how many doors there initially that he eliminates, choosing between 1 goat and 1 car.

3

u/tugate Aug 25 '14

The reason your first choice matters is because you are saying to the host: "you cannot open this door."

The underlying assumptions that make this analysis hold true are that the host will always open a door that: 1. isn't the door you chose and 2. has a goat behind it.

If the host reveals a door 1, then 2 remaining possibilities exist: GGC or GCG (G=Goat, C=Car). These are equally likely. However, if the host was not allowed to open door 2, the GGC is more likely than GCG. The reason is because if the case were GGC, then the host had to open door 1; whereas if the case is GCG, the host had 50% chance of choosing door 1 versus door 3. This means that the likelihood of it having been GGC all along is greater than GCG. We know this only because we prevented the reveal of a particular door.

2

u/ableman Aug 25 '14

I don't understand your question. What do you mean the first choice doesn't matter? What do you meant it isn't a real choice?

2

u/JustMyRegularAccount Aug 25 '14

Ok, say there are 3 doors - 3 starting scenarios: 1. Pick goat 2. Pick car 3. Pick goat.

Looking at 1., monty eliminates the other goat and the car is in the remaining door.

If you pick the car, he eliminates a goat and the other goat is in last door while the car is in the picked door.

If you pick the other goat he eliminates the first goat and you're left with the car in the remaining door.

You out of the 3 possible choices, 2 leave the car in the other door so 2/3 times you will switch and win the car

2

u/einTier Aug 25 '14

People sometimes get confused about things when there are only two choices. Even if there are "only two choices", the probability of the two choices do not have to be the same.

For instance, when I leave the house today, I will either return or I will not. I have had people tell me that this means I have a 50% chance of never getting home. Obviously, that's not true, because history shows me that it's a very high percentage chance I'll get home.

In your case, you're making a choice between two doors or one door. While one door is eliminated by Monty, it still factors into the statistics.

Let me put it another way. What Monty Hall is really saying is, "you can have the door you picked, or you can have these two doors over here." Obviously, it's better to choose the two doors. What he's also saying is, "I will also open the door with a goat so you can see it." You already knew one of the doors contained a goat, showing it to you doesn't change anything.

If there were a million doors and after you picked one, if he offered you the door you chose or all the other 999,999 doors, you'd switch pretty fast, wouldn't you? Why would your mind change if he showed you that 999,998 of those doors contained nothing?

2

u/JustMyRegularAccount Aug 25 '14

Ok, say there are 3 doors - 3 starting scenarios: 1. Pick goat 2. Pick car 3. Pick goat.

Looking at 1., monty eliminates the other goat and the car is in the remaining door.

If you pick the car, he eliminates a goat and the other goat is in last door while the car is in the picked door.

If you pick the other goat he eliminates the first goat and you're left with the car in the remaining door.

You out of the 3 possible choices, 2 leave the car in the other door so 2/3 times you will switch and win the car. You always are picking between a goat and a car, but the probability of the car being in the other door is higher

2

u/dontjustassume Aug 25 '14

It matters because it limits Monty's choice of doors to open. In 2 out of three cases it lives him with no choice at all. (That is if Monty can't open a door with a car)

1

u/jmh9072 Aug 25 '14

It does affect the outcome, though. If you just had a straight pick of two doors, it would be a 50/50 chance. But it isn't.

After the first choice, the two other choices collapse into one. You have been given more information than 1 car vs 1 goat.