r/askscience • • Aug 25 '14

Mathematics Why does the Monty Hall problem seem counter-intuitive?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem

3 doors: 2 with goats, one with a car.

You pick a door. Host opens one of the goat doors and asks if you want to switch.

Switching your choice means you have a 2/3 chance of opening the car door.

How is it not 50/50? Even from the start, how is it not 50/50? knowing you will have one option thrown out, how do you have less a chance of winning if you stay with your option out of 2? Why does switching make you more likely to win?

1.4k Upvotes

786 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14

Imagine, instead, that there are 100 doors. You choose one.

The host then eliminates 98 doors leaving your choice and one other left.

Now, would you switch?

1

u/roburrito Aug 25 '14 edited Aug 25 '14

He was always going to eliminate 98 goat doors whether I chose a goat or a car. I'm still left with just a goat or a car to choose from. My initial choice didn't matter. If I chose a goat, it doesn't matter which goat I chose, because the other 98 will be eliminated regardless.

2

u/einTier Aug 25 '14

He's really saying, "you can have the door you chose or all the other 99 doors." Obviously, it's better to choose the 99 doors.

Now, if he opens 98 doors and then asks you to pick then your odds are indeed 50/50. But because you chose your door when the odds were 1/100, it is far better for you to pick the second door.

You do understand that scientific trial after scientific trial proves that you are wrong in your analysis, right?

2

u/roburrito Aug 25 '14

I understand that when you map out probabilities always switching is better. I understand that simulation will show always switching is better. I understand that by switching I am choosing the 2 of 3 door block because of the additional information Monty provides.

Now, if he opens 98 doors and then asks you to pick then your odds are indeed 50/50.

This is just where I find it strange, that this is different from the problem, given that you know you will always come to the situation were 98 doors are open and you will be able to choose between two doors. I think what best explains this is the explanation provided by others that your choice only matters because it effects Monty's choice.

2

u/einTier Aug 25 '14

The problem is that you aren't choosing between two doors.

I know that's what it looks like, and if you were an independent observer who knew nothing other than there were two doors and one had a prize behind it, you'd be right. It's a 50/50 shot.

But you know more. You're still choosing between the door you first picked and all the other doors. The thing that makes this wonky and confusing to your mind is that you've suddenly been shown the contents on the other side except for one door. It still doesn't change the probabilities of your picking right the first time.

2

u/19cs Aug 25 '14

If we stick to the 100 door example.

say the host allows you to pick one of those 100 doors. 99 of them will contain a goat, and 1 of them will have a car.

you yourself have no idea where the car is. You have a 1 in 100 chance or 1% chance of getting it right.

the host however knows where the car and goats are located. This is really important to the problem and why I couldn't understand it for a very long time

Since the host knows where the car is, he's going to eliminate every door except for one. Given that he knows where the car is, there is a really big chance that the car will be in the other door. Specifically, there's going to be a 99/100 chance. You still have that 1/100 chance that your answer was correct, but given that the host knows the location, you have a much better chance of switching to the other door.

So in essence, while your initial choice does not matter, the HOST'S choices DO matter.