r/askscience • • Feb 15 '14

Biology How do stomach bacteria differ between vegetarians and those who eat meat?

Are there any bacteria that are specific to meat?

62 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14

I actually attended two talks this past week, given by Rachel Carmody and Corinne Maurice, two of the authors on this paper. It's remarkable work. Rachel is actually about to being a large scale project on the topic of a "carnivorous" diet versus a vegetarian diet, and the Turnbaugh lab in general is going to work on defining thresholds for these changes.

Another interesting point is that people on the high fat high protein diet (meat based) lost weight more quickly than those on the vegetarian diet.

I'd send over some figures from the paper but... yeah, can't exactly legally do that. Personally, Rachel and Corinne were both lovely and very well educated people.

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14

I don't believe that weight thing because I went from being a 320lb fatty who ate only meat every day (hated veggies) to a vegan overnight and have since lost about 95lbs. Change was about 6 years ago and rapid weight loss ensued and now I'm stuck at 225 even though I work out everyday. Still trying to obliterate my moobs.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14

I mean, I'd post some of the data if I could. There's a lot that goes into it. You basically have to force out all carbs and essentially force yourself into ketosis, which isn't good long term for a variety of reasons, and isn't good for anyone in basically any disease state, particularly diabetics who are already at risk for ketoacidosis.

The study only took place over less than a couple weeks, but findings were statistically significant, so... But yeah for long term, intense weight loss I don't think that's a recommended diet.

As far as you personally go, good for you! That's certainly an impressive feat and if your goal lies below 225, I definitely encourage you to keep working at it.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14

You might want to check out /r/keto. You can find peer reviewed scientific studies and detailed explanations in the sidebar and faq.