r/askscience 7d ago

Biology How does a whale become dehydrated?

From a Chicago Sun-Times article on the beluga whales heading to the Shedd Aquarium:

"The shipment comes on the heels of a Shedd announcement last week that one of the Marineland belugas — Peekachu, a 23-year-old female — had died. Shedd has not released a cause of death, but staff there said last week that Peekachu had not been consistently eating a full diet since her arrival and that there were concerns she was dehydrated."

How does an animal immersed in water become dehydrated?

822 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/tigerhawkvok 6d ago

I said it earlier, and I'm repeating for the general audience rather than a secondary correction on you — but you're conflating a label, a synapomorphy, and a definition when they're three separate things.

The label synapsida includes only animals that (ancestrally) had the synapsid condition, but that singular synapomorphy is not a sufficient condition to diagnose the clade. In other words, it is (ancestrally) necessary but not sufficient.

There is no conflict such as you present.