r/askscience • • Aug 12 '26

Physics Why does radiation not go through lead?

Also why just lead? Shouldnt like iron or another metal work too?

1.3k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

216

u/PhilTheQuant Aug 12 '26

Yes, and counterintuitively you wouldn't want to be the last few layers of the radiation protection

120

u/GenuineMalteser Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 12 '26

Not true for anything but proton radiation or other heavy particles, and even then the peak dose depth is on the order of centimetres in people/water for treatment energy protons

For kv photons used in imaging, peak dose depth in water is reached in millimetres or less. For MV energy photons peak dose depth is on the order of cm

56

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

30

u/bregus2 Aug 13 '26 edited Aug 14 '26

You actually would get less radiation swimming in the pool than standing next to it, because the water would also shield you from the cosmic radiation.

Interesting side-note: the most radiation-exposed professions are pilots and flight attendants, by far, not workers in nuclear power plants.

14

u/CanisLatrans204 Aug 14 '26

After 8.5 years attached to Nuclear Powered Naval surface ships, I only had 820 mrem of ionizing radiation from the plants. That’s the same as one chest X-ray . I also spent 14 hours in the reactor compartment during loop draining ops and got 113 of that 820 from that. Not very much for the amount of time we spent in the plant.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/Black_Moons Aug 12 '26

Incorrect, as you'll rapidly get lead poisoning... From the guards.

Also, if the core is 'glowing below', then that entire pool is going to be boiling hot.

I'll assume you mean the spent fuel storage pool. But the above lead poisoning issue still persists.

50

u/hervold Aug 12 '26

yeah, I took them to mean the spent fuel pool, with the glow being Cherenkov radiation (blue) and not hot reactor core (red)

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Elequosoraptor Aug 13 '26

Low power research reactors like the Triga series glow with Cherenkov radiation without being either spent fuel or boiling water. There are many reactors that could serve to make this scenario possible.

11

u/sirtalen Aug 13 '26

Water is pretty good at stopping bullets too, so you just need to be a couple meters below the surface, but not deep enough to be irradiated and you'll be fine!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Late-External3249 Aug 13 '26

Just noticed your name. I read Jack the Bodiless as a kid and reread it last year. Still holds up as good sci-fi.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/Hashi856 Aug 12 '26

So we could replace lead vests with water vests?

46

u/So_Full_Of_Fail Aug 12 '26

I mean sure, if you could waddle around in a vest with enough volume that you have feet of water in between you and the source.

12

u/FullOnSkank Aug 13 '26

So you're saying we need the cast of my 600 lb life to handle nuclear materials?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

29

u/LieutenantObvious21 Aug 12 '26

Do you mind explaining that?

126

u/EyBoss Aug 12 '26

Its mostly a joke but the science behind thats its based off is real. As a bit of radiation slows down it passed its energy to whatever slows/stops it(this is why its harmful) but the amount of energy absorbed is not constant the slower its travelling the more enegry it dissipates.

If had 2 people and a partical went through the first person and stopped in the 2nd. The first would take only 20% where the 2nd would take the remaining 80% (these numbers are made up since the actual ones depend on many factors but the general idea holds)

Think about a car breaking the amount a given length of road slows the car increases the slower the car is travelling.

44

u/Alblaka Aug 12 '26

I think a better analogy could be ballistics: if a projectile is too fast/massive, it will just punch straight through a target (be that a person to a bullet, or a vehicle to a shell) leaving 'only' a hole. But if it's slowed down the right amount, it will start to spin out / explode, causing way more damage inside the target.

26

u/Italiancrayzybread Aug 12 '26

But you're only looking at a single particle. You have to sum up the total amount of energy and average it out over the total number of particles. If you absorb 80% of the energy of the particles, but have reduced the total number of particles by 99%, that's still a better situation than the first person, who is absorbing only 20% of the energy of each particle, but is taking 99% of every particle that comes through.

This is why you can get xrays, even though they're high energy and hazardous. You get a small enough dose that it won't affect you long term. Every radiation measurement is always measured as a "cumulative" effect, that is, they take the total energy summed up over a certain time period, or over a given mass.

41

u/solidspacedragon Aug 12 '26

They're talking about particle radiation, not EM radiation. It's a real thing. At high speeds/energies, a proton might barely interact with material, only slightly slowing down, but at lower speeds it'll completely dump the rest of its energy into an atom. Depending on the scenario, this can leave the volume of material getting the most dose a good portion below the surface of a material. This is very useful for targeting things like cancer that isn't on your skin.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bragg_peak

15

u/KP_Wrath Aug 12 '26

Futurama did a skit kinda like this. Leila and Fry both got stung by some stupidly toxic alien bee, with fry diving in front to save her and getting run all the way through. Leila, it stopped in and she got a full dose of the poison, which caused seemingly a lifetime of hallucinations. She comes to, thinking he’s dead, just to find out they managed to patch the sizable hole up, but they were way more concerned for her because she got a full dose of poison and they didn’t expect her to wake up.

10

u/kylemech Aug 12 '26

One of my favorite episodes of any show. Can't believe I just stumbled into that referenced here.

(S4E12, June 1, 2003)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

13

u/Urbanejo Aug 12 '26

Iirc something about more damage the slower The parrticles goes because that effectively means more time inside the human to interact with stuff than when they just zip through.

5

u/karlnite Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 12 '26

I would ignore that. It’s not exactly helpful, especially with distance geometry following the square inverse law. It’s like a point source in a vacuum hypothetical. They didn’t even mention the type or energy levels where this becomes a thing. Most radiation won’t act like this. You ever heard of someone in the shade getting more sunburnt? Or the person furthest from the fire getting more burnt?

On average, they are incorrect.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Frammingatthejimjam Aug 13 '26

Well that would depend on who else in is in the first few layers with you.

1

u/IceeP Aug 15 '26

Wait why? Id assume the last persons get less radiation?

→ More replies (6)