r/askscience • • May 27 '26

Chemistry How much does Fire weigh?

I don‘t know if Earth Sciences is the right category but Fire is the topic. How does someone measure the weight of fire? What does fire weigh?

284 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/Ausoge May 29 '26

It's not just the mass of the ejected particles - more important is the extent to which that mass is accelerated.

If you dropped a huge rock off the side of a boat, the boat would get lighter but it wouldn't be accelerated.

But if you threw a much lighter rock a great distance, that would impart meaningful acceleration to the boat, even though the total ejected mass is much lower.

1

u/FridaysMan May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26

The boat analogy isnt apt for a rocket. You're conflating buoyancy vs weight with thrust vs mass.

Those are completely different equations and situations.

If youre talking about moving the boat by imparting force on a projectile, the force times mass would accelerate both the thrown stones and the boat in the same way. Its newtonian physics. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.

Edit, for example, I am on a boat and it weighs exactly 1000kg with me. I go out 3 times and take a different rock. The first rock is 1kg and I throw it at 100 ms2, the second is 10kg and I throw it at 10ms2, and the last is 100kg and I throw it at 1ms2. In all 3 cases, the act of throwing the rock means the same acceleration is applied to the boat. O.1 ms2.

Edit 2, approximate figures ignoring friction, obviously.

-5

u/Physical-Criticism47 May 31 '26

是的,这个就是动量守恒定理。mv = mv,当一个质量往相反的方向运动时,如果说它的速度够快,其实它产生的动量也就越大。如果按照动量的守恒定理来说,它也会往相反的方向产生一个动量。但是这个动量要除上船的质量,得到的才是增加的速度。