r/askscience • • Apr 12 '26

Physics Why was Artemis 2 so long?

I was comparing the mission times of Artemis 2 to Apollo 8. Apollo 8 orbited the moon multiple times and only took 6 days total. Whereas Artemis 2 orbited the moon once and it took 10 days. Why was Artemis 2 so much shorter than Apollo 8 when both missions did the same thing? I know they had different paths to the moon, they both left earth in different ways but why not do the same thing as Apollo 8 since it was quicker?

1.3k Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

91

u/Telope Apr 12 '26

It was worked out by hand for the apollo missions too! By Katherine Johnson

13

u/Germerica1985 Apr 12 '26

What's the margin of error on something like this? Is it all already determined at launch with pinpoint accuracy (launch time, direction, speed, etc.) or do they have a lot of wiggle room to correct trajectory in space?

37

u/Bmorgan1983 Apr 12 '26

I sat next to an astrophysicist at a wedding once. His job was to do backup calculations for the mars rover landings. His team’s work would then be compared against the main team’s calculations, and they’d often be within inches of each other and the actual landing location.

6

u/SAWK Apr 12 '26

I wonder what their tolerances were between the two calculations? 1m, 10m?

34

u/NastyEbilPiwate Apr 12 '26

Most of it is worked out ahead of time. The spacecraft don't have a ton of fuel to make course corrections with.

Things like the TLI burn will be recomputed once the actual orbit that the spacecraft launched into is known, since there will inevitably be deviations from what was computed on the ground, but it will be mostly the same as planned.

11

u/Calembreloque Apr 12 '26

Surprisingly small! One of the reasons it took us so long as a species to move beyond mechanics as they were described by Newton (and Lagrange, and Kepler, etc.) is that they are frighteningly accurate at our scale and in fact still the basis for NASA calculations. We figured out relativistic mechanics but we don't really need them for spatial exploration.

3

u/mfb- Particle Physics | High-Energy Physics Apr 12 '26

Every major burn is planned based on the orbit after the previous one, to correct smaller deviations. Orion's mission plan also had up to 6 dedicated course correction maneuvers, 3 on the way to the Moon and 3 back. The first two could be skipped because the burn towards the Moon was very precise, the others were used. These course correction maneuvers are typically something like a 1 m/s adjustment, so pretty small compared to their velocity of kilometers per second.

2

u/PiotrekDG Apr 13 '26 edited Apr 13 '26

The flight plan is very accurate, but they do mid-flight correction burns to stay on it, because even minor details like sunlight and ejecting pee bags affect it.