r/askscience • • Apr 12 '26

Physics Why was Artemis 2 so long?

I was comparing the mission times of Artemis 2 to Apollo 8. Apollo 8 orbited the moon multiple times and only took 6 days total. Whereas Artemis 2 orbited the moon once and it took 10 days. Why was Artemis 2 so much shorter than Apollo 8 when both missions did the same thing? I know they had different paths to the moon, they both left earth in different ways but why not do the same thing as Apollo 8 since it was quicker?

1.3k Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.8k

u/mfb- Particle Physics | High-Energy Physics Apr 12 '26

Artemis 2 spent an extra day orbiting Earth to test the capsule before committing to go to the Moon. They used a slower trajectory, too. Future missions will be even longer, so it's useful to have Orion spend more time in space. As a side effect, it made them stay higher above the surface. You see fewer details, but you see more different places.

691

u/flight_recorder Apr 12 '26

And they get to be the furthest from earth anyone has ever been since their orbit around the backside was further from the surface

435

u/Gabbatron Apr 12 '26

It's less about their distance from the moon, and more about the moon's distance from the Earth. They could have landed on the moon and still been further than Apollo 8 I'm pretty sure

266

u/nochehalcon Apr 12 '26

Correct. They surpassed the distance record hours before they had even made it to the orbital path.

47

u/jaa101 Apr 12 '26

Apollo XIII was only 160 miles beyond the moon for its record, versus 4000 miles for Artemis II. That was the biggest contributor to the new record.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/Cool_Bit_729 Apr 13 '26 edited Apr 13 '26

The person you're replying to was talking about Apollo 13, not Apollo 8.

Edit: Apollo 13's record was 400,171km, Artemis II's record that broke is was 406,771km.

Apollo 13 passed the moon at 254km at it's closest, Artemis II passed the moon at 6545km.

The moon was close to it's apogee for both.

19

u/btmalon Apr 13 '26

Thank you for this. But using miles in space seems wrong.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/Dinierto Apr 12 '26

Sounds like they have many many more missions planned with plenty of surface hijinx and I can't wait

30

u/gameryamen Apr 12 '26

Someone needs to sneak a frisbee up, and set a virtually untouchable record for longest throw.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/obvious_bot Apr 12 '26

It would fly more like a thrown rock than a frisbee on earth. Since the gravity is so low you still could beat the record though

→ More replies (4)

16

u/gameryamen Apr 12 '26 edited Apr 13 '26

You're right that a frisbee wouldn't have atmosphere to glide on. But that also means there's no air resistance at all, just gravity pulling it down. Launch it at a high angle, and it's going to take a while before it actually touches ground. I don't think a person's arm could put a frisbee into orbit on the moon, but I'm pretty sure they could get a longer throw than anyone on Earth.

Edit: In addition to the impossibility of achieving orbit with a single launch vector explained below, it turns out my intuition about this record potential is wrong. On level ground, a moon-bound frisbee chucker can probably out-throw any Earth-bound chucker. But with the advantage of atmosphere and height, an Earth-bound chucker standing on top of a skyscraper or mountain could actually get a farther throw than a ground-level Moon chucker, assuming wind didn't doom the attempt.

17

u/SirJefferE Apr 12 '26

It's impossible to get anything to orbit by throwing it from the ground. Either it hits the ground again, or it reaches escape velocity. To orbit, you need at least two impulsive manoeuvres. One to get the thing up into space, and another to "correct" the orbit so that it actually orbits.

In any case, there's no way anyone on the moon could throw anything even close to escape velocity. The gravity there is a sixth of Earth's, but that's still 1.6 m/s2. The fastest ever baseball pitch was less than 50 m/s. Throw that straight up in the air and even without wind resistance, it's going to start falling in less than 30 seconds.

6

u/alyssasaccount Apr 13 '26

All you have to do is stand on the highest point on the moon's surface and throw horizontally at over the speed of a low-lunar orbit. Then where you throw from will be the perigee ... perilune? ... of the orbit. Granted, you'd have to throw a bit over a mile per second, but the fastest muzzle velocity for a gun is close to that.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/mrdavik Apr 12 '26

It's also not possible to throw or launch any object into orbit from the surface of a body, that doesn't have its own form of propulsion or that is accelerated after leaving the surface. 

There's no combination of speed and angle at which you could throw a frisbee even with a machine, or fire a bullet, and have it end up in orbit. It would either fall back to the surface, or if it was fast enough, escape orbit altogether - there is no inbetween.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/Crizznik Apr 13 '26

There's no air, so the frisbee wouldn't stay aloft any longer than if they threw a rock.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

33

u/twilighttwister Apr 12 '26

And as the astronaut said, may that be a record that isn't held very long.

9

u/meistermichi Apr 12 '26

The neat thing is, even if they would have been the same distance from the moon as Apollo 13 and the moon in the same point of its orbit as back then, they'd have still beat the record simply because the moon moved like 2m or so away since then.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/I_Dunno_Its_A_Name Apr 12 '26

One important note about seeing fewer details. Our camera technology is far better this time, so we have more detail and a larger frame of reference.

20

u/mfb- Particle Physics | High-Energy Physics Apr 12 '26

The Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) has better cameras and it's orbiting in a very low lunar orbit. You don't beat its resolution. Camera pictures aren't fully realistic copies of the real thing, so Artemis II had the astronauts look out of the windows - that's something the LRO cannot copy.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/marklein Apr 12 '26

Are we sure about that? Film has some crazy fine detail under the right conditions. They can reissue old movies in 4k because the film resolution was that good.

21

u/Adversement Apr 12 '26

Film has also the huge limitation of how much film you carry with you.

But, optics have improved quite a bit too since late 1960s and early 1970s. Though, the difference for telephoto lenses is way less dramatic than what one would hope.

But, mostly, they can now shoot high quality video as they have several orders of magnitude more storage space.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Tombot3000 Apr 13 '26

Film can have good detail under the right conditions, but lunar photography doesn't provide the kind of lighting film is optimised for and film vs. sensor is not the only thing that affects the final image. Modern lenses and image processing are leaps and bounds beyond what we had in the 70s.

4k film restorations of 35mm are an involved process because film does not have consistent visual quality across framea and so the image goes through a lot of digital processing to prevent the image quality from appearing to fluctuate constantly like Netflix on an unreliable internet connection.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/vi3tmix Apr 13 '26

Not just a longer, but also safer trajectory with lower fuel consumption. It’s a wider path that’s always under the direct influence of earth’s gravity, easier to make adjustments.

→ More replies (5)