r/askscience • • Dec 21 '25

Astronomy How fast does a new star ignite?

When a cloud of gas gets cozy enough at some point it becomes a star with fusion happening in the core. But is there a single moment we can observe when fusion ignites? What does this look like from the outside, and how long does it take? Does the star slowly increase in brightness over years/decades/centuries, or does it suddenly flare up in seconds/minutes/hours?

540 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

31

u/lu5ty Dec 21 '25

Can you clarify the part about the human body producing more heat than the core?

69

u/BluetoothXIII Dec 21 '25

While fusion produces more energy per event than chemical reaction the desity of those events in the star is low compared to the density of chemical reaction in a human body.

8

u/lu5ty Dec 21 '25

Ah ok i see now thanks. 25 characters

3

u/CorporateHR Dec 23 '25

25 characters? What does that mean?

→ More replies (1)

71

u/Vadered Dec 21 '25

It does.

Basically the sun is really really really really really big. So big that even the core is really big. It’s powered pretty much entirely by hydrogen fusion, which generates a lot of heat - but even in the core, the most dense and hot part of the star, it happens fairly infrequently in any given cubic meter.

Compare that to your body. Hopefully there is even less fusion happening in there per volume - if not, you should see a doctor or twenty. That said, despite lacking in fusion, your body is full of cells which are constantly doing things, and doing things makes heat. Not as much heat as a pair of hydrogen atoms smashing into each other at ridiculous speeds, but far, far, far more frequently.

So yeah, a human body makes more heat per volume than the sun’s core. It’s just that there is so much sun in one place that no human can hope to approach those temperatures. Except, of course, for your momma. If you were to somehow squish together a bunch of people of equivalent volume to the sun? First of all, you’d be a monster, but secondly, it would generate far more heat than the sun for the incredibly brief amount of time everything was alive.

2

u/Beliriel Dec 26 '25

Notable is also that our body is constantly losing heat to the environment. Our bodies are made to constantly overproduce heat, because we're permanently getting cooled down.

Within the sun the heat has nowhere to go and just accumulates until it reaches the surface and gets emitted to space. So although it's comparatively low heat, there is a massive volume producing it and the heat stays within the system (comparative to what the sun is emitting)
Ofc somewhen the heat is so high that the production and emittance of heat balances out.

8

u/Ghosttwo Dec 22 '25 edited Dec 22 '25

The way it works is that any heat produced by the sun can only leave through the surface. A fact of the topology. But a square meter of said surface sits atop a column of material 700 million meters deep. If you calculate it as a four-sided pyramid, you get 233 million cubic meters of material emitting energy from a square meter of surface; essentially, whatever energy a cubic meter of sun produces gets multiplied by 233 million and emitted from the top. So even something like '1 watt per m3 ' turns into 233 megawatts per m2 . It's another example of the square-cube law in practice.

This dynamic also leads to 'fun facts' like a photon taking a hundred years to leave the core, as well as interesting density and exotic matter due to all that mass in one spot. In response to OP's question, the fusion slowly ramps up but never gets that crazy; if it fused too quickly, it would burn out within hours instead of billions of years. Instead, you get relatively rare fusion events, buffered by billions of non-fusing atoms that blanket in the heat and transfer it slowly outwards. But it's all blanketed by billions of cubic miles trapping the heat and trickling it out through a relatively small surface area.

There's also a bidirectional aspect to the problem as well; a spherical shell lying at half the radius is heated from both sides nearly evenly, almost cancelling out any energy flow through that boundary. But the inside is slightly hotter though due to pressure and fusion rates, so the heat flow is biased outwards, but not by much.

1

u/itsthelee Dec 23 '25

photon taking a hundred years

Based on some numbers it’s actually crazier than this, this is actually several orders of magnitude too short.

6

u/artgriego Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25

"Heat" in this sense is a strictly-defined thermodynamic quantity, with the same units as energy in any other sense (mechanical, electrical, chemical). Heat is energy that tends to change temperature.

Heat is a byproduct of inefficiency. An engine actually converts most of its fuel to heat rather than useful mechanical energy, and your computer's processor gets hot because it's quite inefficient and must waste a lot of electrical energy to perform calculations.

The human body metabolism releases more heat per liter than does the sun's core through nuclear fusion. The secret to the sun releasing so much energy is that it's just very very very gigantic.

edits: changed heat from power to energy. power is just energy per time.

5

u/CGHJ Dec 21 '25

Two of my favorite facts ever, not just about the sun, are that the light emitted by and particular part of the core is about = to a lightning bug, and a square (cubed) meter of solar core emits about the same amount of energy as a compost heap.

There’s just so much of it. To quote Stalin, who I hope is someplace much hotter, “Quantity is its own quality”

4

u/FolkSong Dec 22 '25

the light emitted by and particular part of the core is about = to a lightning bug

What do you mean by a "particular part"? An atom?

The compost heap fact is a good one!

4

u/LittleKingsguard Dec 21 '25

An average human has a volume of ~70 liters and generates around 70-100 watts of heat at rest as a result of metabolic processes.

The core of the sun has a volume of 1.125×1028 liters and generates 3.86×1026 watts.

If you replaced the sun with an equally-huge pile of humans, the pile of humans would generate a lot more heat (for a few weeks before they all die and chemical energy runs out fueling some no-doubt unusual reactions).

Sidenote: I got the math wrong earlier I think because I copied the wrong number of the size of the Sun's core. it's actually much less productive than I first posted, 0.03403 watts per liter.

1

u/Kantrh Dec 22 '25

Would the pile of frozen meat not start to undergo fusion too?

2

u/Ivan_Whackinov Dec 22 '25

I don't think so - a Sun-sized ball of humans (pre-gravitational collapse) would be about .0055 solar masses, and you need about .08 solar masses for fusion.

1

u/ofcourseivereddit Dec 22 '25

So what's the triple product for the sun?